Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

Posts

Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#1

Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

John Lucas

>Here's a question for you experts. many years ago I swore by Waterlox, and then swore at Waterlox. It always went bad way before I used it up. I'm now trying Minwax wipe on poly. If I remember correctly they both seem to go on about the same with roughly the same consistency. Not having a new can of Waterlox I want to know the difference between these two. They may be completely different, I don't know.

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#2

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

Russ Fairfield

>Waterlox and Minwax-Poly are the same, but different. Both are Oil/Varnish finishes, and the results are similar.

The oil in Waterlox is Tung Oil, and always has been. The oil in the Minwax used to be Soybean Oil with driers to makes it polymerize. I have no idea what is in it now, but it still smells like Soybean Oil.

The varnish resins in Waterloz are phenolics. The resins added to the Minwax-Poly are Polyurethane.

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#3

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

don in central IL

>Russ, you amaze me. How do you keep all that info straight? Also, thanks for the help. At least we have the brightest people around to ask our question.

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#4

which Waterlox?

TDaniel

>John, there are 4 kinds of Waterlox: green can, red can, antique, and marine. The red can does not go bad so fast and it is thinner and spreads or flows easier but it takes more coats to get a good finish. You can slow the problem of hardening in the can by several means. I use a mustard bottle (yellow one) and make a holder so that it always remains inverted. Then I give a shot of bloxygen into the bottle after filling it and immediatedly invert it. Never sit it upright again with the cap off or you will lose the bloxygen. You can also use propane from a torch instead of the bloxygen but it will not be as effective. I like a blend of the red can and the green can Waterlox.

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#5

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>John,

I did use Minwax wipe on poly in a bed I made recently, it goes in easy and it seems to me that it is just a thin down poly. When I ran out of it I continued with thinned poly and I cannot tell the difference.

$0.02

Jorge

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#6

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

John Lucas

>Jorge I used to make a home brew using polyurethane with tung oil, I think I mixed it one part tung oil to 7 parts poly but man was that a long time ago. I would apply the finish using 600 grit wet/dry paper and then wipe it off once it started to smear. The combination of sanding and finish filled in the pores so it didn't take as many coats to get a really beautiful finish both visually and tactile.

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#7

Re: Russ

Dinyar Chavda

>Don:

After having met him, I can let you into a secret. Russ is actually an advanced prototype of a computer (think of him as a cuddly bear version of an intellectual Terminator). In fact, RUSS stands for Robotic Unerring Ultimate Sage.

Dinyar

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#8

RUUS?

TDaniel

>

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#9

Shouldn't that be....

Ron in Drums PA

>Robotic Unerring Super Sage

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#10

Picky! Picky!

Dinyar Chavda

>OK, Terry, if you're going to be persnickety about it:

Robotic Unerring Supreme Sage.

There, now do you feel better? :-)

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#11

Re: Shouldn't that be....

Dinyar Chavda

>Et tu, Ron!!!

Give a guy a break. After all, American is a 2nd language for me! :-)

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#12

Re: Shouldn't that be....

Ron in Drums PA

>Heck No!! You get no breaks!!

You do better than me and it's my native language!!

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#13

Re: Hey Ron- Dinyar uses that ....

JamieDonaldson

>... second language excuse all the time, and really studied American more than did we! And regarding Russ- I did notice that he has a rather mechanical walk- is there such a critter as a "finish droid?"

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#14

2nd language....

Dinyar Chavda

>American is my 2nd language. I grew up in India on the East and West Coasts (sequentially, not simultaneously--just wanted to clarify that), and English was the common language we communicated in.

Then, when I came to the US, like most immigrants I had to learn a new language---American!

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#15

Re: 2nd language....

Stephen Mushinski

>The hard part is you have the east coast American, the southern American, the west coast American, northern American and the middle American. And if that is not bad enough you have to learn Detroit, New York, and something I never was able to understand language of Kentucky. :) This coming from a Canadian Eh!

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#16

American....way, way, way OT by now (and long!)

Dinyar Chavda

>Steve:

You have a very limited ear for American accents! :-)

What do you mean "East Coast American"? There's Maine (ayup), Manhattan, Brooklyn and the Bronx, to say nothing of the yiddish influence (oy vey! That's not bupkus). Then we come to Philly, with its Italian sound (YO!), as well as the nasal tones that would make Eliza Doolittle feel right at home (Did you know that "Ow" consists of at least 3, if not 4, syllables?). And of course there's Boston, where one can paak one's ca in Haavud yaad! Actually, the one accent that is almost impossible to fake convincingly is Bostonian---most actors pretending to be from Boston end up sounding like aircakes.

The only East Coast place that does not have an accent is New Hampshire, and that's because the natives there don't speak, they only list'n!

It's gotten so that I now treat every American-made movie (unless set in the mid-west)as though it was a foreign movie, and turn the sub-titles on! Otherwise, I can't understand most of what the regional characters are saying. Except for the Australian actors playing Americans---they are perfectly understandable while they are on the set---can't understand a word of what they say when they are doing interviews! :-)

I think movies and plays should handle accents like they did in The Hunt for Red October----it starts with all the actors speaking Russian, with sub-titles, but then quickly switches over to everyone speaking in English! They should do a version of this in American movies also---at the beginning, all the actors come out and do a scene in their character's regional tone (with subtitles), just to prove that they can, and then they go back to speaking unaccented American (well, at least what we consider to be unaccented American).

Mind, though, that I have no objections to hearing local phrases and idioms (from all over the world)---they are rich with meaning, and provide delightful images. I love to come across them, provided, of course, that they have the translation in subtitles!

All this talk about words and accents makes me think that I'll go sign up for a class with Jimmy Clewes, just to hear him say that a turned piece he is working on is going to be dead bonnie!

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#17

Watch it

RevDoug

>I resemble that remark!

Turn 'em round,

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#18

Ah shucks, What ya'll talkin bout

john lucas

>

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#19

Ric Taylor

It Doesn't Go Bad

Ric Taylor

>John,

I'm a long way from being an expert, but I used to use Minwax wipe-on poly. I switched to Waterlox and never looked back.

Waterlox doesn't go bad as many people believe. It just gets a thick layer on top. Everything below that layer is just fine.

Simply use a long eyedropper to stick through the top layer, and draw the good Waterlox up from below. I have waterlox in a jar that I've been using for a year and a half. I just keep drawing the good fluid up from the bottom of the jar. It's easy, and it works great. All I do is keep the lid on the jar the rest of the time. No fancy oxygen replacement methods or bottle inversions required.

Ric

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#20

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

Wilford Bickel

>John,

Our finishes have been hit by the enviorenmental laws! Some time back I noticed my Minwax Wipe on Poly was going bad much faster then it had previously. I contacted the chemists over Minwax and found out that all their finishes had to be brought into compliance with the laws concerning Volatile Organic Solvents (VOC's). I am aware of the laws they are talking about as I have had to do a lot of testing on our products here at the chemical company that employees me. While they would not say (legally could not) how much of what they took out - they did tell me that contrary to what the can says about not thinning you could now add up to 15% pure mineral spirits and 1-3% Linseed Olil to the product without hurting the film characteristics.

I added 13% Mineral Spirits and 3% BLO (did not have any plain linseed and this should about adjust the formula) to the last can I purchased and my finishes were actually improved - went on thinner and leveled more like the old product. In addition it has been put into smaller bottles to prevent air contamination and has lasted over 6 months and is still good to use!

Wilford

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#21

Reminds me of the joke about...

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>the old guy who was stopped by a KY State Trooper on I-75, South of Lexington.

The Trooper walks up to his truck window and asks, "Have you got any I.D.?"

The old man looks up at him and asks, "About whut?"

Gary

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#22

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

ken chase

>John: I used Waterlox on a desktop and bartop. What I learned after some problems is you can't let the can get too low. Air causes little specs to form and they are nearly impossible to screen out. I even strained through kleenex and couldn't get them out. What you have to do is pour the remaining finish from the can into a smaller container and keep doing so to prevent air contamination. I like the Minwax because I haven't had the same problem.

Re: Waterlox vs minwax wipe on poly

#23

Re: Sorry Jamie,

Russ Fairfield

>that "mechanical walk" you referred to is from old age and bad knees.