Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Finish for buckeye burl?

Posts

Finish for buckeye burl?

#1

Ellis Walentine

Finish for buckeye burl?

Ellis Walentine

>I just finished turning a piece that I started at Bill Grumbine's picnic last weekend. Now I'm all set to finish it, but I am undecided whether to go with something clear and water white, e.g. lacquer (in which case I will have to go back and put in a lot more sanding), or something like my old standby, Waterlox. From past experience with spongy wood, I have the feeling that the amber color of the varnish and its penetrating qualities will turn the blue and white buckeye burl to a brown, murky mess. The other alternative I've considered is clear shellac and wax, but I don't think it will show off the curly burly figure nor saturate the blue colors.

Usually, I just run a few tests on scrap, but in this case, I don't have another piece of buckeye that I can play with. Any insights from people who have confronted this choice before?

Thanks,

Ellis Walentine, Host


img

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

#2

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

John Lucas

>Have you thought about Minwax wipe on Poly. I haven't tried it on Buckeye yet but it sure looks great on maple.

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

#3

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

Russ Fairfield

>Polish it up to about 1500 grit and give it a coat of wax. That will change the color of the wood the least of anything you can do to it, and there is nothing there to turn "orange" with age.

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

#4

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

Carole Valentine

>Ellis, I have only done one Buckeye piece but I used a sealer of thinned lacquer (not water based) and then used Waterlox. It did "amberize" the light wood a bit but not much. Wally has done a lot of Buckeye burl pieces as I recall. Maybe he will chime in here. I don't think my piece was quite a blue as yours originally - more dark gray.


img

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

#5

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

RevDoug

>Ellis, if it helps here is a pic of my buckeye and it has nothing but danish oil on it.

Turn 'em round,


img

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

#6

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Ellis, I've done a number of buckeye burl pieces. I've always used Daly's Ben Matte tung oil finish. It's similar to Waterlox. It darkens the dark color while not affecting the light color very much. Good contrast is what you want with this wood.

Wally


img

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

#7

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I sometimes wish that I could edit posts on WC.

It's important to add that my first coat of finish when doing Buckeye is a brush-on coat of Semi-gloss Deft. I apply it on the lathe and immediately polish it dry with a paper towel while the lathe is running.

Wally

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

#8

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Oh, Wow! Ellis that is a beauty! It looks like a sculpture. I'm not one for giving advice on finishing. Mine always seems to be different every month. Still haven't tried the Waterlox like we talked about in Louisville. Whatever you put on it...I'm sure it will look even more spectacular! Very nicely done.

Jen

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

#9

Wood bleach & Buckeye Burl, Same as on Box Elder?

Craig Daymon

>Wally,

Do you know if wood bleach works on buckeye burl like it does on box elder? I've seen some bleached box elder pieces that look almost perfectly white with the red looking just that much brighter in contrast. I'm wondering if the blue/gray of buckeye burl holds up to bleach the way the red does on box elder?

-Craig

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

#10

Re: Wood bleach & Buckeye Burl, Same as on Box Eld

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I have no idea how bleach would affect the colors of buckeye. It would be interesting to experiment with a piece of scrap buckeye to find out.

Wally

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

#11

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Ellis,

Velvit Products makes a water base poly that soaks in and does not yellow. I use it on the holly bowls I turn for use. It is the only time I would even consider poly.

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

#12

Brad Vietje

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

Brad Vietje

>Ellis: This is far too beautiful a piece for mere speculation at a distance... for best results, you'll just have to send it to me, and I'll put a finish on it at my end ;-)

Beautiful work !

Brad Vietje

Springfield, VT

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

#13

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

George@Colonel's Workshop

>Ahhh Ellis,

You did what you said you were gonna do with it last Saturday. It looks wonderful. You need a spectacular finish, be sure to post when its completed.

George

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

#14

Ellis Walentine

Gonna have to try that, Barb

Ellis Walentine

>This sounds like just what the doctor ordered. I am imagining that a couple coats wiped on and scuff sanded when dry, followed by a coat of wax, might give just the look and feel I'm thinking of.

Ellis

PS I also like the earlier suggestions by Carole and Wally regarding a sealer coat of lacquer or Deft followed by an oil-varnish mix. I suspect that these methods would give a richer color, while the poly/wax approach would give a lighter look. Decisions, decisions. :-)

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

#15

Re: Gonna have to try that, Barb

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>True about the water base poly and lighter. The only time we ever used poly on any of our custom floors was for a friend who had us put in a very wide board white oak floor. He wanted the oak to stay bright. We used a water base poly and the floor lookks almost a bright as the day we put it in (probably 5 years ago).

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

#16

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

Ed Heuslein

>Howdy Ellis: I gotta put in my two cents worth. First, if you decide on just wax, try Renaissance wax. It doesn't yellow with age. Second, for pieces like this I like to use a coat of pure Tung Oil, thinned 50%, for grain depth. Then, finish with water based lacquer. Highland Hdwr. has a good product that is used by several members of my club. I use gloss then sand with Micro-Mesh to the degree of shine that I prefer for that particular piece.

Please post the results, regardless of which method you use.

Ed

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

#17

See the creation of this burl...

Walt Drummond - Middlesex, NJ

>Ellis used great inspiration to master Big Blue to turn the buckeye burl...


img

Re: Finish for buckeye burl?

#18

Re: Is this Ellsworth with a haircut and beard tri

JamieDonaldson

>