Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Getting Warped

Posts

Getting Warped

#1

Getting Warped

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>I acquired some Honey Locust, sawn 6/4 thick, 17" wide bark edge to bark edge about 10' long. It was plane sawn about 4" from the pith. It had been stickered but not weighted in the open, in Texas, for about 7 months. My intention was to use it for platters. I cut it into 3' long boards and left in my shop standing on edge for 3 months. The boards have cupped about 1/2".

Last night I bandsawed out a blank the full width of the board and rough turned the platter to about 3/8" thick with 4" of the center left 3/4" thick for a mounting tennon. The wood seemed dry all the way through. It was flat when I stopped. I don't have a moisture meter.

This morning the blank had cupped about 3/8" toward the pith. The cup seems to be evenly distributed across the width. The was it is now it's trash, can't be flattened without loosing 80% of the width.

One solution may be to let it sit for a couple of days then rip it into three pieces, joint the edges and glue it back together. It could also be clamped flat, or with some reverse cup, and left for a while. It won't fit in my microwave or I'd clamp it and run it through a couple of cycles.

I'm wondering if the additional cupping is due to additional drying or from release of internal stress. Will these pieces keep warping after they're finished? I thinking about ripping the rest of it into 1/2" to 3" wide pieces, letting them set for another 3-6 months, and gluing them back together with contrasting wood in between.

What do you all think?

Re: Getting Warped

#2

Re: Getting Warped

Russ Fairfield

>I have always seen Locust as one of the LEAST stable woods when going from wet to dry, but one of the MOST stable woods after it has dried.

One of the problems you are having is from how the wood was sawn. Locust has a high tangential shrinkage rate. The movement and cupping in Locust would have been less had the wood been 1/4-sawn, or vertical grain.

In a former life (sometime about 1960), I made a lot of ship and boat wheels for restorations and display. The wood was Locust in whatever variety of Honey or Black that was available. The reason was its strength and stability AFTER it was dried.

Re: Getting Warped

#3

Re: Getting Warped

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Phil,

I had good luck with clamping a camphor platter that I turned to finish from green wood. I just used two pieces of 3/4" plywood and clamped them with the various clamps that I had lying around. I would use something like the no-slip shelf liner at the edges and at the bottom to give the wood a chance to breathe a little while it's clamped. A hole drilled in the top board might not be a bad idea either.

You may have to tighten the clamps over a day or so to force it flat. Let it dry for a few weeks before you unclamp it. I would at least try this approach before I started ripping it up. You don't have a lot to lose. If it works, you'll know that you can proceed the same way with your other blanks.

Good luck,

Gary

Re: Getting Warped

#4

Re: Getting Warped

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>I thought about that but will it warp again latter due to changes in humidity?

Re: Getting Warped

#5

Re: Getting Warped

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Phil,

Mine hasn't warped perceptibly in the past year or so. I think if you can dry it flat to the EMC where it will live, you shouldn't have trouble with it warping later.

Gary

Re: Getting Warped

#6

Re: Read again

Russ Fairfield

>Read my first sentense again. Locust is one of the least stable woods there is during the change from wet to dry. Locust is one of the MOST stable of all wood species AFTER it has dried.

Re: Getting Warped

#7

Re: Read again

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>Russ,

If I understand what you are saying if the cupped piece is flatened using a clamping device it will stay that way after it dries. I suppose that is because the fibers have "set" and unless they got wet enough to make them elastic again they won't move. Kind of the reverse of steam bending. Wish I had a microwave large enough to hold it and the clamping device just to see what would happen.

Re: Getting Warped

#8

Re: Getting Warped

robo hippy

>The wood hadn't reached equilibrium before you turned it, so it moved a lot after it was turned. Most of the air dried wood that I have worked with doesn't have any internal stress in it that will result in more movement later (left to dry without any pressure on it lets the wood find its natural form). If you dry it in clamps and under pressure, you are putting stress back into the wood, and normal changes in humidity can cause it to move later. Personally, I like warped shapes, the more the better.

robo hippy

Re: Getting Warped

#9

Re: Getting Warped

Peter Hyde

>Phil,

the way I see it is 7 months is not a long enough time for drying. I would be thinking maybe 2 years. Also the thing to remember is the wood shrinks along the rings tangentially so you have to orient the chuck tenon on the side dictated by the direction of shrinkage.

So if possible a quarter sawn board should be used.

Also if you rough turn and then wax the whole piece and do the paper bag routine you can slow down the drying and eliminate a lot of the warping and cracking.

Here's a sketch of how the shrinkage warps a flat sawn board. I hope this helps.


img

Re: Getting Warped

#10

Re: Getting Warped; let it rest

merv Graham

>I have been fortunate to have been given a large sum of both honey and black and in both cases I have found it becomes quite stable. I turn rough and let it sit for at least 6 months even in what I consider dry state, Though the wood is dry it is not stable and will react to the removal of a large mass for some time I leave a lot of wood to do the final turning as you have realized it can change dramatically in some instances. After the wood does not loose any more weight and seems dry I measure the two axis X-with the pith and Y across the pith; when it stops changing I finish it. Seems a lot or bother but in my limited experience it seems the only way.