Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

Posts

Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

#1

Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Hi Everyone,

I've turned a red cedar bowl that just smells delicious, and I'd love to be able to keep that aroma, however I'd also like to put some form of finish on it to bring out the beautiful colors in the piece. It goes from creammy white to pale pinks and deep purples. Any ideas, or do I need to choose one or the other? I've never turned red cedar before but had an opportunity when a friend dropped off a 3ft log about 14" in diameter.

Thanks for any ideas.

Jen

Re: Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

#2

Re: Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

Carole Valentine

>Jen, the smell will fade eventually no matter what (unless you resand, which no one wants to do!) To make it last as long as possible, just sand to a very high git through micro mesh and leave it natural. This does not, however, enhance the colors. I prefer an oil finish if I want to darken the colors and keep the silky feel. I no longer try to keep the cedar scent.

Re: Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

#3

Just had a thought...

Carole Valentine

>Dangerous 'cause I have only had one cup of coffee, but here goes. Wonder what would happen if you added a tiny bit of that cedar oil they use to refresh cedar closets to whatever oil finish you are using?

Re: Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

#4

You beat me to it,

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>I was to suggest, after all the sanding is done, to rub it with cedar oil, it will enhance the color and the feel of it.

Re: Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

#5

Re: You beat me to it,

Bill Crommett

>Jen: I have had the best results when finishing red cedar by using CA thin glue followed by a light buffing. It does darken the color, though.

Re: Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

#6

Re: Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

John Lucas

>I tried every finish I had and more to see if I could maintain the fresh cedar look. None of them worked, not even Krylon Fixatif. I didn't try to hold the smell. I did try to bleach the wood to see if I could lighten it and then when I applied the finish it would go back to what I wanted. It blew up the bowl. The bleach apparently penetrates so rapidly that the wood in that one area expanded before the rest could catch up. I watched it disentegrate in my hands, bummer.

Re: Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

#7

Re: Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

Devon Palmer

>WOW,

The fixatif has UV protectant in it, right? I would thought that would have helped at least slow it down. I've finished one with UV protective varnish. Its a year old, and still pretty red/purple, but, you can tell its faded a little.

- Devo

Re: Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

#8

** Cedar dust **

Ed Moore

>Jen,

I've been told that cedar dust can be quite harmful. So, please wear dust protection when you are sanding and vacuuming up the shavings.

Ed

Re: Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

#9

Thanks gang....

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>I may try the cedar oil trick? The CA would be a ginormous mess I'm sure, not to mention, smelly, sticky and expensive. It's a rather large bowl. I can't even finish a pen properly wiht CA. But thanks for the idea Bill.

Jen

Re: Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

#10

Leo Van Der Loo

Jen I just went to smell

leo Van Der Loo

>a small juniper (eastern red cedar) weed pot that I turned 2 years ago, finished with pure tung oil, or I might have mixed it with real turpentine, I can still smell the wood when I lifted the little flowerpot insert out, not the outside wood though.

Also the color has faded a lot, even though it is standing in the dark.

What I usually do is take all the shavings and put in a fine mess bag, the smell last about a year I would say, shaking it up once in a while helps, but yes it fades away, smell and color.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo


img

Re: Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

#11

Sniff

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Well Jen,

I'm for sanding it smooth and leaving it alone...nothing like scratch and sniff!!

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

#12

Re: Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

Ed Heuslein

>Howdy Jennifer: I also just completed a cedar piece. Mine is a large vase. I hope you didn't have the cracking & splitting problems I did. Everytime I turned around I had another crack. Lots of turquoise in it now. Anyway, to your question. I used lacquer because I wanted it to darken just a little, but not as much as oil. Cedar is going to darken with age anyway, like all woods, and it just takes ona richer look in my opinion. Water based lacquer is not a good idea as it leaves a gray cast and is not attractive at all I believe. I like the cedar oil idea - I'll use that with my vase (even though I didn't finish the inside so I could enjoy the smell for a while at least).

Please post a picture.

Re: Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

#13

Re: Splitting Red Cedar.

Allen Neighbors

>Ed, first few times I turned aromatic Cedar they split and cracked quite a bit. I even heard some of them cracking on the lathe! Found out I was generating too much heat during sanding.

I haven't turned anymore yet, so I haven't borne this out, but it sounds possible to me.

Allen

Re: Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

#14

Re: Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

John Veerkamp

>Jen,

I use wax only for the finish on my cedar turnings. It will let the aroma thru and give a wonderful silky finish. The cedar will lose most of the red/purple over time. Exposure to light hastens this ageing. I have a piece turned for a present that has been finished for 6 months. It is wrapped loosley in cotton and in a dark closet. It hasn't faded noticeably yet and still smells nice. Others turned at the same time and on display , not in the sun, have lost most of the red/purple and now are a very attractive mix of browns and creams in the sap.

John

Re: Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

#15

Re: Scratch and Sniff

Chris K in MD

>That says alot about you Jim! Are you smelling some model glue too? =)

Re: Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

#16

Re: Splitting Red Cedar.

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>Hi Allen,

The piece of cedar I got at TD gathering started spliting as soon I started turning it right there, even before it was a cylinder it had a bunch of cracks already, seems like it grows with lots of built in stresses and as soon as the balance is disrupted, something gives. I bagged it and put it aside and made a flower por out of it, (dry flowers).

jorge

Re: Finish or Not for Red Cedar?

#17

Re: Splitting Red Cedar.

Allen Neighbors

>You're right, Jorge, sometimes they have some built in stress checks... many times we have wind over 75 miles per hour here, and that places some pretty hard stresses on a standing tree. I think that's why most of the trees that are in these FDR Shelter Belts (long narrow strips of trees planted throughout the country during the dust-bowl days), are full of cracks. I cut a 50'tall x 24" dia Bois d'Arc tree down recently (from a Shelter Belt), and I've only gotten about 12 to 15 useable blanks out of it, because the rest is too cracked up to use. But it's awesome fire wood!

If that cedar you turned was a piece that I took to GA, either it came from my back yard, or it came from right down the street in a pretty well protected area, with houses all around it.

Allen