Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Which is sharper?

Posts

Which is sharper?

#1

Which is sharper?

eliot

>I believe I know most of the advantages of HHS over carbon steel. But I have this idea (which I picked up somewhere -- so it's not new with me) that carbon steel can actually be sharpened to a sharper edge --even if it doesn't last as long ,etc. Is there any truth to it? Perhaps someone with deep knowledge in ceramics could provide a scientific answer.

Re: Which is sharper?

#2

For Our Purposes

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>They are the same with regard to sharpness from your grinder.

This came up on the WOW site and we were able to get input from Aaron Gesicki, a turner who also happens to be a metallurgist and foundry engineer.

Yes, the internal structure of the two allows is different with the "grain" of the carbon steel being finer. Aaron noted that it is true that carbon steel can be sharpened to a finer edge, but he also informed everyone that the difference will not show up until after you pass the edge quality of razors and scalpeles. The important point is the size of the grit in your grinder's wheel. I had the following e-mail exchange with Aaron which says it all really:

"Aaron,

Caught your input on WoW. Thanks for stepping in, and I may look up that book.

Since you didn't specifically address "my issue" I'll ask you privately. That is, simply, a 120 grit edge on carbon steel should be, for all woodcutting purposes, the same 120 grit edge on ASP 2060 or any alloy in between, right? (or wrong?) As you may have read, I tried to resolve this with Hamlet, but the answer was a bit unsatisfactory.

I do understand a little bit about particle size limiting the size of an ultimately honed edge, but I don't hone my tools to freekin molecular levels . . ."

Reply:

"Yes, the edge is the same from a wheel on all tools that see that wheel.

I suspect the Hamlet problem is that they don�t know much more about metallurgy than most other users. As you probably read in the Nick Cook article, Hamlet doesn�t make steel or even heat treat it. They shape and then sell tools, and are basing their material selection and specification on the recommendations of others."

So, Eliot, The Bottom Line is:

Yes, there are differences in alloys and their molecular and crystaline structures, and some will ultimately take a finer edge than others. But the same grind wheel will not grind a finer edge on one as opposed to another. A 100 grit wheel gives a 100 grit edge. Want a finer edge? Use a finer wheel.

I hope this helps.

Re: Which is sharper?

#3

Re: Which is sharper?

Thom D

>There seems to be some evidence of that. I don't think science is the thing since the testing tool steel for hobby woodwork is a pretty narrow field. But hands on experience with knives and tools shows it to be the case. However some of the very nicest, from the point of view of finest sharpenable edges, tools are HSS. Examples are some of the japanese planes and chisels made out of HSS sharpen as easily and to a furiously sharp edge. Another example would be the Japanese Blue steel that while not a HSS has some similar alloy content. I have even had Japanese crbide router bits that were razor sharp. I have also had really good edges on the HSS bits they make for metal lathes. So I think part of it is the luck of the draw with the particular HSS, and in the case of the Japanese market, their expectations. Think of their razor saws,even at the brutally cheap end of the market people obviusly expect a very sharp saw. So maybe it's a mater of expectations more than raw materials. In turning the power of the lathe can make a relatively dull edge cut as though it was razor sharp, so I am not generally all that worried about ultimate sharpness.

Re: Which is sharper?

#4

Re: For Our Purposes

Thom D

>"Yes, there are differences in alloys and their molecular and crystaline structures, and some will ultimately take a finer edge than others."

I think this is an example of the bad science I was refering to. We sharpen our tools with rocks, even the 30 000 stones are nowhere near the same fineness as a molecule wide. So the carbide size limt at the edge is not the issue that limits sharpness, whether grinding or polishing. I have my guesses but I think most of this stuff is just story telling. Like dragons they explain complex human realities, though they are not real representations.

Re: Which is sharper?

#5

Re: Careful

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Thom,

I think the issue is less bad science and more faulty logic or intuition. Someone correctly says that carbon "will" take a finer edge, and others who hear that statement then assume that a carbon steel edge is somehow finer than a HSS or 2060 edge even when done on the same wheel.

Straight high carbon steel will, however, push up a very sharp wire edge when wheel ground; more so than the "higher" alloys because it's softer. I've spoken to turners who don't hone off that wire edge, but say their tool goes dull with a few cuts. I suspect what they're doing is cutting with the wire edge rather than the true edge they would have if they lightly honed after grinding.

Others whom I respect, purposefully do not hone their HSS tools and use the very small grinder burr as their cutting edge.

Yes, sharpness of the edge on metal is determined by the grinding stone rather than the steel alloy, but carbide is a ceramic material, not metal. You don't want to try sharpening cardide on an AO wheel; most of what you'll get is groves in the wheel.

While carbide is given a sharp edge on the tips you mention, it's shape is not as keen as steel edges because the brittle carbide materal requires a fairly blunt grind angle. It was explained to me that if you were to grind carbide to a fine pointed edge like a skew or even a bowl gouge, the sharp edge would crack and break off with little force. Perhaps that's why we don't see it much in turning tools.

m

Re: Which is sharper?

#6

For Further Info

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Aaron recommended the following book.

"The Complete Guide To Sharpening," by Leonard Lee. Has photomicrographs of edges and wood cuts made by them if you're really into it.

My local library has it and I believe it's available through the online joints as well.

m

Re: Which is sharper?

#7

JL

Re: Tell you what..

JL

>Sharpen a couple of scraps of known steels on whatever you wish to sharpen them. They have to be small pieces (cutter inserts would work nicely). I'll take some photomicrographs of them (optical and scanning electron microscope. If they are cutter inserts, I'll send them back. Then you can decide (or not). The pieces can be no more than 3/4" long if I'm to get them on my old model SEM.

Re: Which is sharper?

#8

Re: PM 3520 vacuum rotary adapter

Mike Nelson

>I don't know which takes a sharper edge but carbide will stay sharper many, many times longer than HSS. I'm curious why carbide is not used in wood turning, is it because you have to brais it to the steel? Too brittle? Mike

Re: Which is sharper?

#9

Re: Which is sharper?

Mike Nelson

>Sorry about that, don't know how that subject got there.

Re: Which is sharper?

#10

Re: Which is sharper?

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Carbide could be used for tools but the cost to produce a solid carbide blade would out weight any benefits. Carbide inserts can be used with no problem and are available in any shape or size. I make my own tools from A-11 and found this to be reasonably priced if you consider the price of steel.