For Our Purposes
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>They are the same with regard to sharpness from your grinder.
This came up on the WOW site and we were able to get input from Aaron Gesicki, a turner who also happens to be a metallurgist and foundry engineer.
Yes, the internal structure of the two allows is different with the "grain" of the carbon steel being finer. Aaron noted that it is true that carbon steel can be sharpened to a finer edge, but he also informed everyone that the difference will not show up until after you pass the edge quality of razors and scalpeles. The important point is the size of the grit in your grinder's wheel. I had the following e-mail exchange with Aaron which says it all really:
"Aaron,
Caught your input on WoW. Thanks for stepping in, and I may look up that book.
Since you didn't specifically address "my issue" I'll ask you privately. That is, simply, a 120 grit edge on carbon steel should be, for all woodcutting purposes, the same 120 grit edge on ASP 2060 or any alloy in between, right? (or wrong?) As you may have read, I tried to resolve this with Hamlet, but the answer was a bit unsatisfactory.
I do understand a little bit about particle size limiting the size of an ultimately honed edge, but I don't hone my tools to freekin molecular levels . . ."
Reply:
"Yes, the edge is the same from a wheel on all tools that see that wheel.
I suspect the Hamlet problem is that they don�t know much more about metallurgy than most other users. As you probably read in the Nick Cook article, Hamlet doesn�t make steel or even heat treat it. They shape and then sell tools, and are basing their material selection and specification on the recommendations of others."
So, Eliot, The Bottom Line is:
Yes, there are differences in alloys and their molecular and crystaline structures, and some will ultimately take a finer edge than others. But the same grind wheel will not grind a finer edge on one as opposed to another. A 100 grit wheel gives a 100 grit edge. Want a finer edge? Use a finer wheel.
I hope this helps.