We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Making several red oak bowls (8 inch diameter). Rough-turning left pieces one inch thick. (I knew there would be a lot of warping). Soaked each piece 8 hours in alcohol and paper-bagged. Checked them 3 days later and they're all cracking! CA'd the cracks and coated them inside and out with end-grain sealer to hopefully stop further cracking. Question: Is there a BETTER way of drying red oak so that it DOESN'T crack?
>I have not had that experince with red oak. I found red oak to be very easy to dry. I use the anchorseal, wait 6 months or longer method.
Reaction wood is prone to a good deal of movement. Is it posible that the red oak you roughed was from a limb (characterized by the pith being off center of a log section).
I've had good luck with a coat of sanding sealer or wax-free shellac (two coats on end grain) applied after rough turning, and then bagging in a heavy brown paper bag for 6 months. The slight yellowing you get from the shellac is not inappropriate for red oak, and you'll probably turn it all away anyway because the distortion factor for red oak is pretty large. Make sure you cut your blanks far enough away from the pith -- that's where I've had problems.
>Ken, I use the soap solution, to which I add a gallon of dna occasionally. I rough turn to about 3/4 inch, soak for 7 days or longer, and wrap the outside with brown paper sack, and turn upside down on an expanded metal shelf to dry. They warp like crazy, but seldom crack (keeping the pith in is the exception...they all crack). After a couple of weeks in this hot, dry, country and they are ready to turn to finish. (
My other alternative, (most used) is to turn to a finished thickness of about 3/16", put on a heavy coat of lemon oil or mineral oil/paraffin mixture, and let them warp. I love what they do. So do those who purchase them. Keeping them wet for a week with the oil helps to keep them from cracking.
>I don't know why you all have so much problems with red oak, I have no excessive problems with either red or white oak, I have half a dozen or more here sitting in the house, (and several more in my drying cabin), turned and finish turned between 1 to 5 years ago, no splits and only a little warping on the ones with some tension wood on it.
I turn oak just like cherry or maple, walls 8 to 10 % of the diameter on the top edge, going slightly thinner as I go to the base, paper bag them and store in a airstill place, check maybe once or twice a week and place on the shelf when they feel not too wet anymore.
I do turn in one setting and do not turn oak that has been sitting for a few months somewhere already, and probably has checks in them already.
I concur with the point about limb wood. If your blanks come from large branches, you may be working with wood that has tremendous stress stored inside -- if the pith is way off center, that could be the basic problem (reaction wood). The easiest wood to dry w/out cracks will come from a vertical trunk (pith in center of log), with weight loads balanced in all directions. Limbs at an angle are more difficult, but usually workable, and horizontal limbs, as in Live Oak, can be exceedingly difficult.
Could you be exposing fine cracks already in the wood ? If the tree was felled onto a hard, dry surface with the big limbs still attached, you might be working with shattered wood (?)