Re: Tormak fixtures and jigs
Rick Allen
>Hi Eliot
I sharpened on nothing but the tormek for 3 months (12/2005 - 2/2006). I couldn't detect any improvement in the way my turning tools worked. I switched back to the dry grinder, which most folks use, and I was unable to detect a difference in the way the turning tools worked.
All this to say that the Tormek may have put a sharper edge on my turning tools. But I was unable to detect any advantage at the lathe when my tools were sharpened using the tormek. There was one exception. The skew was sharper and I found the skew cut more effortlessly when sharpened on the tormek
There were several disadvantages with sharpening using the tormek.
Water. The tormek needs water, it need more and more water. Fill up the water reservoir, turn the machine on and watch the water level drop as the water in the reservoir is absorbed into the stone.
Clean-up. The tormek collects the waste from sharpening in the water reservoir. That waste has to be scraped out. Of course the Tormek doesn't collect all the waste. Naturally some of the waste ends up on the surface the tormek is placed on. And that waste is wet and requires additional clean up. And don't forget about the leather strop and the cream honing compound. That stuff gets tossed off and requires clean-up. Not to mention that the tool itself needs to be cleaned after sharpening so you don't transfer the metal particle laden honing cream to your woodturning.
Time. The Tormek takes a LOT more time than the dry grinder. I heard all the folks who are enamored with the tormek for sharpening turning tools talk about how quickly they could sharpen using the tormek "once the profile was set". The sharpening takes longer. At least 3 times as long. Add in the Gunga Din effort at the start and the clean-up after sharpening and I was adding several minutes to each sharpening session. Sharpening on a dry grinder is a necessary inconvenience. Sharpening on a tormek is a production.
Wheel wear. You have to be mindful of what the sharpening is doing to the soft grinding wheel. sharpening fingernail gouges is especially hard on the flatness of the wheel. You will want to be sure that you sharpen all your flat tools before shaping gouges as the wheel needs dressing before sharpening flat edge tools like a skew or bedan. There is a diamond wheel that you can get for the tormek. Turns out that this wheel is specifically counter indicated for "point source" sharpening. A long flat edge such as a knife sharpens without undue damage but a gouge where a small surface is in contact with the wheel while sharpening will wear the diamond coating off the wheel quickly.
Awkward to sharpen gouges. The angles that you hold the tool at to sharpening a bowl gouge are not well suited to the task. I tried both the top and back bar positions and found that both positions put you at a disadvantage when trying to control the sharpening process for gouges. The jigs for knives, skews and suck are well suited for the comfortable and controlled sharpening.
I found the tormek to be poorly suited to sharpening of turning tools
Good luck with your tormek efforts. I hope your results are more to your liking than mine were.