Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Gouge?

Posts

Gouge?

#1

Gouge?

Monty

>I usually hang out on the hand tools forum but have a question on turning. I have bought a new lathe and want to buy some new turning tools. It may sound dumb to you experienced turners but what is the difference bewteen a detail gouge and a spindle gouge. Is there a difference and if so do I need both? Also what steel do you prefer?

Re: Gouge?

#2

Not much...

Peter Teubel

>A detail gouge is usually a spindle gouge with a steep bevel and narrow point to get into tight areas normally reserved for a skew.

Re: Gouge?

#3

Re: Gouge?

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>A detail gouge has more "meat" at the bottom of the flue. Other wise about the same. They can be used interchangablely, but the detail is smoother since it has less vibration, espesially if long over the rest.

Re: Gouge?

#4

Re: And you want M2 HSS, no carbon!

JamieDonaldson

>

Re: Gouge?

#5

Richard Allen

Re: Gouge?

Richard Allen

>More important than which spindle gouge is hands on instruction. Woodturning is more like hand tool work than power tool work. Hands on instruction will get you started quickly. A LOT more important than detail gouge vs spindle gouge.

Re: Gouge?

#6

Re: Gouge?

Fog Tanner

>I have a several shallow (spindle) gouges (1/4", 3/8", and 1/2") ground with a long bevel (30 degrees) and a narrow tip. I also have a couple of "real "detail gouges (3/8"and 1/2") ground the same. They all have secondary bevels (actually 3) to keep from lifting the tip off the wood. The only difference between the ones I have is the amount of metal under the flute. The "real" detail gouges have a lot more steel and can overhand the rest longer than the shallow gouges.

As far as steel either M2 or M4. If you are looking at detail gouges you may want to take a look at the P&N line. That is what I got for my 1/2" and its as good as my Henry Taylor.

Re: Gouge?

#7

Brad Vietje

BINGO !

Brad Vietje

>

Re: Gouge?

#8

Brad Vietje

Re: Gouge?

Brad Vietje

>Hey Monty,

A pretty standard answer on this forum is to either seek out the nearest AAW group to you, and get some help and advice from their meetings, or to contact a local group and see if there might be a member near you who could turn with you one on one, so you can master your new tools more quickly. Maybe this will work for you ? The AAW is found at www.woodturner.org

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Gouge?

#9

Re: Gouge?

merv Graham

>Ditto that bingo three important things for beginners 1 basic tools 2 good instruction 3 practce practice practice. If you are going to spend money make it good instructiion. Join a guild and buy into some of the classes by traveling professionals like Jordan Foster Raffin Clewes the latter are two of my favorites. Most of us dare I use the word-old- fellows have tool boxes full of those things we had to have at the trade show.