Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Router Speed Control on grinder

Posts

Router Speed Control on grinder

#1

Router Speed Control on grinder

Brad Thompson - Hartselle AL

>Hello all,

Has anyone tried using a router variable speed control or any other type of rheostat with a standard 6" bench grinder? Am curious if it would work for lathe tool sharpening by reducing heat.

Thanks in advance,

Brad

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

#2

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

John Lucas

>It won't work. If you have High speed steel tools don't worry about the heat. Of course if you don't like heating up your hand you'll just have to learn to sharpen with less pressure, cool frequently with water, or both. Even with a 1725 rpm grinder, if you leave the tool there very long you will heat up the tool. What I do is to make one pass across the wheel and then hold the tool very close to the wheel as move it back for another pass. The air from the wheel cools it down pretty well. If I'm having to reshape an edge I just keep the water handy.

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

#3

JL

Re: Of course if you are really worried about..

JL

>heat - get a Tormek ;).

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

#4

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole

>If the motor has brushes (universal motor), the speed control will work. Never saw a bench grinder with a universal motor.

Also, water-quenching HSS during grinding/sharpening is not a good idea; you may make the cutting edge brittle, and easily breakable (at least on a microscopic level, which is where the real cutting is done).

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

#5

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

Wilford Bickel

>John Jordan said in the AAW sharpening DVD that water quenching HSS is not a problem and will not make it brittle. I hear a lot of people say you should not quench it but I've never had a problem because of it and JJ knows a lot more about steels and tools than I will ever know.

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

#6

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

Bob Fawcett

>The best thing you can do to reduce heat is buy a good wheel. Try one of the Norton SGs for the best available. A good white AO wheel works well also, but will wear a lot faster.

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

#7

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

Brad Thompson - Hartselle AL

>John,

My tools are all HSS (Sorby and Taylor), with the exception of a couple old scrapers.

I am using a Norton white AO wheel (fine/120 grit) and am also using a jig based on plans/photos posted here. I touch up/reface the wheel before each time or when it shows the dark build up lines.

The jig maintains my angle and I only allow the weight of the tool to determine the pressure on the wheel. Always use light passes.

Have noticed that if I start grinding before the grinder gets to full speed the edge is much better.

Hence, the question about slowing down a standard grinder to reduce heat without buying an overrated and expensive Tormek :)

Thanks,

Brad

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

#8

Could it be balance?

Bob Fawcett

>I don't have on of the OneWay wheel balancers but maybe others will chime in.

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

#9

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

John Lucas

>Well I'm not sharp at all when it comes to metalurgy and I've read the reports, I think Gerry Glaser started it and he does know what he's talking about. However I've sharpened HSS for years with and without water quenching and I can't tell any difference so I don't worry about it.

There shouldn't be any difference in edge quality at lower speeds. Optimum sharpening speed for HSS is an 8" wheel at 3450 rpm, at least that what I've read in several different sources, one was Norton abrasives and I think they know what they are talking about.

The only thing I can think of is you may be aproaching the grind differently when the wheel is warming up vs how you do it when the wheel is full speed. That's just a guess however.It sounds like your doing everything else right. Look at the edge carefully after you grind, maybe even with a magnifier. If you can see the edge it isn't sharp.

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

#10

I can't sey it simpler than this.

Russ Fairfield

>Copied from "The Universal Truths of Woodturning".

8. The speed of the grinding wheel doesn't matter. They all remove metal. The faster wheel removes it faster. There is some justification for the new woodturner to use the slower wheel.

14. Getting HSS to turn blue or even red-hot while grinding is not a problem. But, if you do, let it cool in the air. Don't shock it by submerging it in cold water because that can start micro- cracks in the thin cutting edge.

15. Getting carbon steel hot enough to turn blue can be a problem. That temperature allows the Carbon to move around in the steel and it looses its temper. All is not lost when this happens, just get it hot again, immediately dip it in cold water, and then grind away the blue steel, keeping it cool this time with frequent dipping in cold water.

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

#11

Re: Could it be balance?

Allen Neighbors

>I have the Oneway Balance system on my Delta 8" two speed grinder; My wheels are white AO 120, and Blue AO 80. I like the 80 Grit wheel most. (Somebody predicted that, before I bought) (I'm not sure the color makes a bit of difference... but I've read somewhere that it signifies the hardness of the wheel.)

When the wheels are in balance, the grinder can't be beat! But let the collar get loose, and change the balance, and you can't stand it.

Balance is everything, in my book.

If your motor is a capacitor start, the router speed control won't work.

Allen

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

#12

Re: I can't sey it simpler than this.

Brad Thompson - Hartselle AL

>Russ,

Thanks, very interesting info.

Not trying to be a "Doubting Thomas", but the more speed has to result in more friction equalling faster heat build up. If this wasn't the case then why are products like wet grinders and Tormex out there?

Agree that all grinders remove metal, but doesn't logic say that the more the wheel is in contact with the tool (aka speed) the more metal will be removed. Maybe that is a different topic?

I guess one way for this to be tested would be to mount my current wheel on an arbor on the lathe and test the results at different speeds.

Thanks again,

Brad

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

#13

Re: I can't sey it simpler than this.

john lucas

>Brad Wet wheel grinders are out there mostly for other tools like carving tools, handplanes and hand chisels that may not be HSS. They simply adapted them to turning tools because they saw the market. I know I'll get a lot of argument over this but I don't think they are the best choice for turning tools. That's just my opinion and obviously there are a lot of turners using them and loving them.

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

#14

Re: I can't sey it simpler than this.

Thom D

>Wet grinders are not quenching the steel they keep it cold from the begining which is completely different. If at the micro level there is something going on that is on a very small scale.

I've used my 8" dry grinder with 1800 rpm without a problem. I use a coarser wheel than 120 for just about everything, I used to have two wheels on the grinder, but now I have a buff I use for stuff other than turning tools.

Having the right touch and a good firm approach that removes metal with minimum heat is a learned thing. I use a belt sander to do any tool making, but they are so efficient they tend to remover too much material and don't form as good a burr on scrapers, so I stll use the grinder for turning. Some of my tools are carbon while most are HSS same grinder works fine.

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

#15

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

Bill White

>Brad,

As I understand, the router speed controls are for universal (brush-type) motors. Most grinders that I have seen are induction motors.

Bill in Tupelo

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

#16

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

Brad Thompson - Hartselle AL

>Bill,

Thanks, that really was what I was trying to ask - would it work.

Also, thanks to all the others who "hijacked" :-) my question. No really, the information was relevant and helpful.

Brad

Re: Router Speed Control on grinder

#17

Thank you, Russ :

Bill Crommett

>I have been using any speed that comes with a motor I can scrounge up to put a wheel on. I figure that if a turner can't learn not to get his tools burned he better send them out to a professional grinder.