Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

Posts

Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

#1

Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

Barry Turner

>I bought a new Super Nova 2 at the Symposium in Louisville. I used it to turn a bowl Saturday. With a wood worm screw held in the jaws, I mounted a blank to rough the outside of a bowl. When I had finished turning the outside of the bowl, I noticed a slight wobble, not just in the bowl, but the bowl and the chuck were both wobbling. I switched the blank and wood worm screw to my old Super Nova chuck and there was no noticeable wobble at all. The threaded insert in the new chuck does not seat all the way into the chuck body. There is about an eighth inch gap between the hex head of the adapter and the chuck body. I think herein lies the problem. I have been in contact with Teknatool and they have been very helpful and also very concerned. I love the chuck and believe it is a vast improvement over the old Super Nova, but a new chuck should not have a wobble/ runout problem. I wonder, has anyone else had this problem with this chuck?

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

#2

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

Carole Valentine

>Barry,

I have two SN2s with inserts and I have the same eighth inch gap between the top of the hex head and the chuck body on both. I just figured it was supposed to be that way. The insert seems seated.

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

#3

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

Barry Turner

>My old Super Nova has the gap, too. But, it doesn't seem to cause a problem with it. Maybe I'm just being too picky, but this was not a large (9") bowl I was turning and the rim was moving at least 1/4". I'm sure with a larger bowl or a platter, the movement would be even greater.

I like the S/N 2 much better than the old version. It seems much better made. Do you suppose I could have a bad insert? My first impulse is to go to a local machine shop and have about 1/8" milled off the nose of the insert.

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

#4

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

Carole Valentine

>Gosh, I don't know, Barry. What did the folks at Teknatool say? Will they send you another insert? I would try that before I ground off the old one. Maybe you could switch inserts with your old chuck and see what happens. If you get the wobble with the old chuck and the new insert, then you know it is the insert.

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

#5

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

Barry Turner

>Teknatool says the gap itself is not a problem......the insert seats at the front, inside the chuck. Still, I think the insert should seat into the chuck far enough so as not to have a gap, but it may not make a real difference. I had thought of swapping inserts, just didn't have the time yesterday. Teknatool is going to have their East Coast Rep contact me about the problem. I have swapped a couple of emails with Roger Latimer of Teknatool over the weekend.

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

#6

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

Allen Neighbors

>I have two SN2s and recently changed the inserts to a different size. I had noticeable wobble with one of them, and after all I did trying to correct it, I realize I didn't have the insert bottomed out.

I clamped the chuck onto a piece of 1/2" X 2" piece of aluminum (by putting the aluminum perpendicular to the face of the chuck, between the jaw edges) and then clamped the metal into a vise. I tightened the insert with a 1-1/2" socket and long breaker bar. It moved very little, but when finished, the runout was gone. :o) (I still have the 1/8 inch gap between the hex head and the chuck body).

I haven't installed the locking setscrew yet, but I will, after I file a notch in the insert threads. (I purchased a longer set screw to allow for the added depth of the notch in the insert.)

Hope this helps you a little.

Allen

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

#7

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

gtwilkins

>Barry, I was just at a supplier and was told they had received a shipment of defective chucks, I would try change the insert, then get them to replace the chuck immediately.

I have just gone thru an absolute nightmare with Teknatool, one of their US vendors and the US rep. I took over 6 months to get a decent DVRXP from them and I still hadn't received an undamaged outrigger before I just said enough and got rid of everything and bought a Vicmark instead.

As far as I am concerned the DVRXP is nothing but trouble looking for a place to happen, I fear Teknatools problem is they release products way before the bugs are worked out. It was my finding from multiple people that if you have a problem and they don't agree with you they just refuse to answer your mail.

This was about major casting flaws that they referred to as cosmetic, I don't call a bowed bed a minor cosmetic flaw! The tool post would not fit into the banjo and I felt in general that the fit and finish was abysmal, not what I would expext for a 2K machine.

There are a few people out there who had asked me questions about my experience, but I felt it unfair to comment until I had resolved my issues with Teknatool et al. now how ever I have no such worries I will tell you I will never ever recommend Teknatool, the vendor Woodchips ever again! Please feel free to ask away now.

Yours Sincerely, Trevor Wilkins

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

#8

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

Bob Fawcett

>Barry,

There is not a small piece of trash or a burr stopping the insert from seating is there?

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

#9

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

Wayne Leach-NW Ontario

>Barry,

I experienced slight wobble after using my SN2 the first few times. I found the setscrew came loose and the chuck loosened on the threads and began to wobble. I really dont think it was seated prperly ?

I removed it, took the insert out and cleaned the threads then reinstalled and tightened the insert with the chuck in a vise using a "humongous" (thats Canadian for "big") wrench and then really tightened the setscrew down. No problems since then and that was many months ago!

REgards,

Wayne

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

#10

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

Bill Hale

>If you buy a new tool and it does not work out of the box return it !

My opinion is that if they do not ship a quality product it is not the buyers responcibility to have to rework it or to have to fight the problem.

I have always had the opinion that I have worked hard for my money and I expect to enjoy spending it. Poor quality certainly is not an enjoyment.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grane, AZ. ( HOT )

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

#11

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

Rick Allen

>Tell us what you really think.

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

#12

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

Ron in Drums PA

>FWIW

I received a new SN2 on Friday via UPS from CSUSA. (great poeple BTW - I asked them to delay shipment until I returned home). I installed it yesterday and I also have about a 1/8" gap. I installed a set of cole jawson the chuck and it ran true.

� Did you sock down the inset as far as it will go into the chuck?

� Is there a burr on the spindle side of the insert?

If both these test out, get a replacement instead of messing around.

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

#13

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

gtwilkins

>Teknatool should have figured out by now they don't have any QA, when they ship 200 defective chucks to one supplier it starts me thinking how many other chucks were shipped.

For your information I ordered and paid for the DVRXP and outrigger on Jan8/06, prepaid mind you, for guaranteed delivery the first week of March. Third week of February the excuses start, they shipped the DVRXP on 3000 beds etc.

However by this time I had already been told that Teknatool was having trouble with the castings in CHINA so I inquired as to the problem and was informed there was no problems. This was the just the first lie I was told.

First lathe arrived without outrigger April 28/06, box just shipped as is, not on pallet. Box had been cut open and a couple of pieces of tape used to seal it, no sign of any shrink wrap, box beaten to pieces during transport and had been punctured thru the side far enought to damage the paint on the front of the head stock.

When I started to inspect the lathe I was disgusted by the lack of attention to detail, it looked like a cheap Chinese counterfeit. When I complained first to the vendor then to the U.S. rep. I was told it was all minor cosmetic flaws and would not affect the operation of the lathe.

Except the tool post wouldn't fit into the banjo, the bed was bowed, the maching on the bed looked like a first year student had used a draw file, the beds are cast at different angles and it looked like someone had taken an angle grinder to try and sort out the edges, there was casting flash everywhere and the first thing I did was flay my finger open on the bottom edge of the banjo, not a single machined edge had been broken. Never mind the headstock and tailstock were about 2 mm out of line!

It was at about this time the vendor admitted to me he had been in contact with Nathan (Teknatool production) and they admitted they had the bed problems sorted out!

In other words for a 2K + lathe it was a POS. Meanwhile I had been told that Geist the US rep had washed his hands of the whole problem so I was on the blower to R&B Latimer immediately. They talked a good talk and woe to me I believed them.

Second lathe arrives on June 21/06 still minus outrigger. Outrigger arrives a week later looking like it had been kicked from NZ, powder coat chipped on all the oieces as it had not been packaged properly and the vendor has the gall to say he can't see any damage in the photos I sent him.

After that no more replies to any of my e-mail(and I am not the only one) I finally had to go through another dealer here in Canada to even get a message to the brother's Latimer, no offer of recompense even though by now my summer sales season is basically shot.

All in all I wouldn't trust Teknatool as far as could throw their lathe and I hope the people who have bought these early lathes demand a new lathe as a lathe that will not center is just an expensive sander. This first lathe I recived was Serial # 4490 so how many others like mine are out there with people wondering why they can't turn anything round.

If I had known right from the begginning that the lathes where cast and machined in China I would not of even considered the machine as I have a personal policy of refusing to purchase Chinese made goods( I don't need to explain the reason for that I am sure).

After all this I am still getting e-mails from people who cannot get the alignment sorted out, just try to loosen the tailstock bolts and you will see why!

All in all a very frustrating and disgusting way to deal with clients, if I ran my business like they run theirs I would be finished. I have never ever been treated in such a cavalier and insolent manner as I was by B Latimer and I sincerely hope that no one else fall into the pile like I did!

I have photos if any one wants to compare their machine to 4490, please e-mail.

Trevor Wilkins

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

#14

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>Barry,

I have a gap in my SN2 and it is not a problem, the real problem in mine is that the jaws themselves have a wicked amount of slop on the sliders, I can wiggle every single one in the supernova, but not at all in the Vicmarc.

Jorge

owner of a lemon chuck

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

#15

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

Barry Turner

>I agree. But, from a practical standpoint, I'll do what is the least quickest and easiest for me. If that's taking the insert to a local machine shop and having it milled 1/8" shorter and shelling out $10.00 or so, that's probably what I will do. But, I agree, new stuff ought to work properly or be replaced promptly by the manufacturer with as little inconvenience to the customer as possible.

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

#16

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

Barry Turner

>You may have something there. I didn't put that much effort into seating the insert in the chuck. Maybe I need to try again. Thanks.

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

#17

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

Barry Turner

>I certainly hope not, but I'll pull the insert and make sure. Thanks.

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

#18

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

Barry Turner

>I did it. I put the insert from my old Super Nova chuck in the new chuck and guess what? No wobble! I would appear that I have a bad insert, not a bad chuck. Wouldn't you agree? Thanks.

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

#19

Re: Super Nova 2 Chuck Problem

Carole Valentine

>Seems so, but there is a possibility that the "bad" insert was just not seated properly. At least you know it's not the chuck.