Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

What looks better ?? *LINK*

Posts

What looks better ?? *LINK*

#1

Leo Van Der Loo

What looks better ?? *LINK*

leo Van Der Loo

>I'm not sure on this one, turned the HF and thought it needed something more, made the lid and did not think it was what was needed, so than made the ring, I still don't know if that looks any better, any thoughts ???

American Elm HF 6"D, lid black walnut with bone finial, ring is honey locust.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo


img

http://homepage.mac.com/l.vanderloo/PhotoAlbum25.html

Re: What looks better ?? *LINK*

#2

Re: What looks better ??

john lucas

>Leo Not sure why but I think I would like to see the lid sort of follow that downward curve. I'm thinking that you start with a large bead or convex curve then go concave to carry the HF curve through. Then some sort of raised detail toward the middle and then add your finial. I guess I sort of see the lid with large ripples like you dropped a stone in the water. Does that make sense? I'm not sure what kind of wood I would use. The lid would look and feel completely different with dark wood vs light wood.

Re: What looks better ?? *LINK*

#3

Re: What looks better ??

merv Graham

>I like the one with the lid and white finial it looks complete

Re: What looks better ?? *LINK*

#4

Re: What looks better ??

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole

>The lid, and the the ring look fine, but not on this HF. I like your HF plain, as in the top left pic. Nice work, and good looking wood.

Re: What looks better ?? *LINK*

#5

Well - I Think

Jake Niedling

>the vessel looks good plain. It might look good with a small dark colored ring like 3/8" x 3/8". I have a few projects on the shelve that I just can't seem to get the right to my eye no matter how many times I take them out and stare at them. Then other projects come together right from the start. So you are not alone.

Re: What looks better ?? *LINK*

#6

Re: What looks better ??

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Of the choices here....I like the collar the best. It sort of swirls with the grain of the bowl. The walnut lid's grain makes my eyes work too hard because the straight grain is fighting with the swirl of the HF. Just my 2 cents.

Jennifer

Re: What looks better ?? *LINK*

#7

Re: What looks better ??

David Harris

>I think it might look good with a lid from the bowl blank itself, that way the grain would fit nice. Good looking bowl.

Re: What looks better ?? *LINK*

#8

Re: What looks better ??

Ed Moore

>Leo,

I looked at the pictures, read all the responses, and then looked again. My choice would be the natural unlidded hollowform. That said, a small ring of ebony or blackwood could be equally as good. The ring you have is too close in color to the hollowform. And like Jennifer said, the character of the walnut fights the hollowform.

Ed

Re: What looks better ?? *LINK*

#9

Re: What looks better ??

Allen Neighbors

>What he said. Without, or with ebony collar. Either way, you always do good work... when it's finished the way you want it, it'll work!

Allen

Re: What looks better ?? *LINK*

#10

Re: What looks better ??

john lucas

>I agree with Allen on this. The basic form is excellent. With or without a lip or lid. The trick will be applying either one without losing anything.

Re: What looks better ?? *LINK*

#11

Re: What looks better ??

GaryG in MD

>Leo,

The additions detract. The piece is lovely the way it is but might benefit from just a slight accent -- something that adds a point of interest without taking away from the natural flow of the form and grain. Would you consider either 1) reworking the rim into a bead by removing a little material (and I know you don't have much there) just to the outside of the rim by slightly reshaping the inward curve, or 2) adding one or two shadow lines appropriately spaced around the rim? If it were mine, those would be the things I'd be thinking about.

It's a beautiful piece. KISS. ...Gary

Re: What looks better ?? *LINK*

#12

Leo Van Der Loo

The toughts on what looks better

leo Van Der Loo

>echo what I have been thinking, the lid looks ok, but like Jen said the grain and color clashed with the HF, the ring is not bad but does not really ad and the color is sorta off, cutting a small bead had crossed my mind, but it's a little late as the wood has warped some I think.

So I will try a narrow ring of ebonized something and see, if that does not pleases than we will just leave it.

Thank you all for taking the time to put down your thoughts on this.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo