Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

design help needed

Posts

design help needed

#1

design help needed

TDaniel

>I am doing a pet urn with a foot. The dimensions are 4 5/8" diameter at top by 4 5/8" high. Base is currently 2 1/8" but that needs to be smaller. Also, base is currently pictured at 1/4" thick but when parted off that will be 1/8" thick. Can someone with one of those fancy drawing programs play with this and see what would be the most pleasing size for the foot? My guess is 2" but that is only a guess.

Thanks

TD


img

Re: design help needed

#2

Re: design help needed

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>TD, I don't use triangles and such but if this were mine I think that I'd do a "tucked" foot. Starting at about an inch above the bottom cut a radius curve in to a foot of a little over an inch and a half.

Wally

Re: design help needed

#3

Re: design help needed

Carole Valentine

>You always seem to like the rule of thirds so why not use that? That would make the base diameter 1.54". Personally, I would design an urn for stability as well as appearance. Last thing I would want is Fido's or Grandpa's ashes strewn across the carpet! LOL

Re: design help needed

#4

Re: design help needed

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>4-5/8 = 37/8 div by 3 = 12/8+

So doesn't that do it with the same formula applied to the lid?

Re: design help needed

#5

doesn't apply

TDaniel

>rule of thirds does not apply to foot height or diameter. My eye says that if I leave the foot it cannot be much smaller than it is now for the stability reasons you mentioned. If I had an autocad program and knew how to use it I would play with different looks before parting it off but, unfortunately, I do not have either of these capabilities.

Re: design help needed

#6

My thoughts too

TDaniel

>Thanks Wally. As you can tell by the area not colored the foot was not intended in the beginning and I planned to part it off similar to what you are suggesting. As I looked at the wood left I decided to play with it before parting off. Since we have talked a bit about this very subject recently and I have seen some good computer generated examples I decided to see what alternatives we might come up with. It is on the tumbler now getting the inside slicked up but by this afternoon it will be time to part it off.

Re: design help needed

#7

Russ's Rules

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Rule 1 - "The bottom diameter is 1/3 that of the largest diameter." Using our same 10" bowl as an example, the bottom diameter would be 3 1/3", but 3�" can be used for easier measurement.

Re: design help needed

#8

another question

TDaniel

>If this is to be used and will have some weight inside would you make the foot a little larger for stability?

Re: design help needed

#9

Re: design help needed

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Would a pet urn be called a utility vessel? Probably not. This type of foot could be 2 inches and would look good. I would think about making the smallest dia. a little smaller and adding a small bead there.

Wally

Re: design help needed

#10

How about this Wally?

TDaniel

>Wally, I tried turning a bead on the stem but there wasn't much room. I finally turned it with an upside down utility knife for a blade. the base is now 1 7/8" diameter. Base would look better without the step I think but it is done now. Pedestal vases seem to challenge me more than others.


img

Re: design help needed

#11

Alternatives *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Following link might provide some assistance to see how others have approached the issue. Page branches into catagories from each thumbnail


Feets Don Fail Me Now

Re: design help needed

#12

Re: How about this Wally?

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>I like this much better!