We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>A fellow turner suggested -- hands on-- that I practice with the skew at the fastest possible speed( for that lathe). I tried it, and I must say I seemed to have more control and got fewer scroll backs. But I remember Don Derry at one of our demonstrations say that you should slow down if you're having any trouble. So which is it? What do you think?
>For spindles up to about 1 1/2" I use the top speed, 3900 rpm. It get reduced as the size goes up. About 700 rpm for roughing 4" stock. Don't uses material with cracks.
Faceplate work or bowl type work is way slower, down to 50 rpm if it's out of ballance.
>I prefer a slightly higher speed than slow for me. I never turn above 2000 rpm. No particular reason other than having my lathe set on the slow pulley for big work. I just never found really high speeds necessary. I find that turning large fair curves or straight tapers are easier with a higher speed and it seems like it's easier to move the skew in the 3 directions required to turn a bead when the lathe is up a little. But that's now and I have hundreds of hours with the skew.
When I was learning to turn I had one heck of a hard time with the skew. I just couldn't seem to get the hang of it. Then I took a chair making class and we used a spring pole lathe and a skew for some of the parts. The wood moved so slow you could watch the skew work. When you tried to turn a bead you still got kick backs but they weren't violent instantanious things. I got the hang of the skew fairly quickly by turning at really slow speed.
I think the difference is cutting technique. The beginner has a tendencey to make large movements with the tools when making corrections or adjustments in cutting angle. The experienced turner makes small fine adjustments. When turning a bead most people get the catch near the bottom of bead and that's because it only takes a very small movement to come off the bevel. If you speed up the cut sometimes you can finish the cut before these gross movements catch up with you. With the really slow you can concentrate on the movements. Which will work best for you(slow or fast) is probably more a matter of style and technique than the speed of the lathe.
Here's what happens when turning a bead. You have to rotate the tool by twisting the handle, you have to move the handle from right to left(turning the left side of the bead) and you have to lift the handle to cut the bottom portion of the bead. Add to this the fact that the wood is moving slower near the bottom of the bead than at the top so your cutting speed is reduced meaning the movements must slow down at that point. This makes this probably one of the most complicated cuts in woodturning. Undercutting under rims of bowls is probably next on the list when it comes to catch's.
Once you get the technique for turning a bead you wonder what all the fuss was about because all the sudden they just sort of flow. It's because you do all these movements at the right speed at the right time without thinking about it.
What really makes the difference is practice, not speed. Turn lots of beads in scrap wood each time you go to the lathe. It only takes 5 minutes. don't worry how they look. This is an exercise to build muscle memory. Start with large ball shaped beads, thier easiest. Then work your way up to large beads with parallel sides. Small beads with parallel sides are probably the hardest because all the movements happen faster.
>John Lucas, It's funny that you just knew that it was beads that I was practicing, because I didn't say so. I've posted before about my problems with scroll backs just as I round the turn. but I am getting better with practice. Several small cuts, a higher speed, and a sharpening angle of about 10 degrees,( so the total angle comes to about 20 degrees) has helped.. In Louisville I went to two rotations on spindle turning by Mike Darlow, who, as you probably know, is very analytical, and, like you, seemed to know that it was the bead that caused the most trouble. He said just about what you and others have told me, but I find that there's no substitute for practice. The odd thing is that I really don't care to do spindle work; I turn mostly hollow vessels. It's just that I'm determined to master the skew.
Anyway, thanks to you and the others for your advice.
>I would only add one factor to consider. If you're going to practice using your skew(s), don't drive the wood with a chuck -- use a dead cup center, if possible, or a spur drive center. If this seems a silly point, do consider that there are some occasions when driving a spindle with a chuck can be advantageous, such as stiffening one end of a thin piece, but only do that when you feel confident with the tool.
I say this because when practicing cuts to the right, especially beads, a catch drives the tool to the left -- possibly into the chuck jaws. At high speeds, this can happen so fast that there's no saving the steel-steel impact. It would be a lot better if there were nothing there at all -- assuming the spindle piece is a larger diameter than the drive center.
At low speeds, the only real danger is to the wood. At higher speeds, the wood can snap and possibly smack you upside the head, while with a chuck, things just get a whole lot worse in a hurry, especially at higher speed.
>If you would like to get some practice with the skew, one of the best tools I have found is a light pull drive. It is a friction drive, so when you get what would normally be a catch or scroll back - the wood stops and you can see what you did. You can make any shape you want, beads, coves, planing and be fairly fast and loose.The one downside is when you switch back to a postive drive, you can't be quite as loose. I generally run the lathe at the higest speed when using the light pull, but down around 2000 for making boxes. If it is a tall box, down around 1500.
Another thing that helped me was reading Raffin's Turning Wood and his descritions of what causes a catch. I then hand turned the piece to get a realtime visual - much better than a powered visual. The next thing was lots of practice. I made a number of projects which were all done using the skew only for the outside. I normally did these in batchs of 100, and light pulls by the "bag full" - however many blanks would fit in a shopping bag. Along the way you will find what is comfortable for you and what does and doesn't work in your hands. The challenge is to make it as pleasant a learning experience as possible, and that comes through patience and concentration.
And since you like hollow forms, I took a hands on with Trent Bosch making one of his Vessels of Illusion. The outside was hollowed using his hollowing rig, but to get the outside curves that I wanted I revereted to my skews (3/4" and 1"). It was endgrain so I could use them. So the tool is not stricly for spindles and boxes.
>Fog You bring up a good point that I had forgotten. If you have someone turn the lathe by hand and then use the skew you can really see what is happening. One demonstrator did this at a club meeting. I forgot who it was but you can really watch the cut and it goes slow enough you can really concetrate on the movements of the handle. Thanks for bringing that up.
>Fog Tanner, Thanks for your long response. Just curious, though: what kind of shape for the outside of a vessel do you like that makes you prefer a skew to turn it? I suppose you can get a smoother surface with the skew, but I have trouble visualizing a shape that would benefit from a skew over a gouge.
>If you have seen Trent's work or seen his demos, you will find that he likes "organic" shapes. He did a demo where he made an shape with an "exploding" or peeling opening. I was interested in that process and was able to achive that part with surprising ease (I was surprised I was able to do it). But, the rest of the shape was a design opportunity. I had gotten deeper than I intended using his hollowing rig. I had never used it before and got carried away and went deeper than I intended. I had intended to bring the base down to a point, but there was not enough material and it changed the curve. The result was an organic light bulb, which is sorta cool in itself. A bulb caught in the act of exploding and frozen. I even toyed with the idea of threading the base.
One of the other club members in the workshop later told me that Trent stood behind me watching while I was shaping with the skew, with his mouth open in disbelief.
>The only difference between turning with a skew and whittling with a pocket knife is that the wood is spinning when turning with the skew. The cuts are the same.
>That's because beads beat me to death until I finally got the hang of it. I can't even tell you how it happened for sure. Like you I was determined to learn the skew and practiced a lot. Suddenly one day I could do it and now rarely have a problem. What did I change? I don't really know other than mentally understanding where the bevel is, that you can't see. If you know where the bevel is then you know not to go too far so you come off the bevel and you get a catch.