Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

OT: More Digital Photography questions

Posts

OT: More Digital Photography questions

#1

Steven Antonucci

OT: More Digital Photography questions

steve antonucci

>I got some good good advice on editing programs, but now comes the really hard stuff...

I own a Hasselblad and I used to shoot with it frequently. I have a bazillion slides that I would pick through and potentially scan into digital images.

So far, I've found a service that will do 4000 DPI scans at $6/ea. The resulting file is 600MB, give or take. Why would you want that much information, you say? I've projected these slides on the back wall of my living room at 8' x 8', with no grain- that's why!

So here come the hard questions:

1.) Has anyone tried working with large files in GIMP? Is there a limitation to practical file size?

2.) At $6/ea, I will chose my images sparingly. Anyone know of a better deal?

3.) If GIMP isn't viable, do I need a mega-Workstation to be able to handle this sized file? I have a feeling I know the answer to this one...

Steve-

Who is thinking of shooting with the Hassy again and "stitching" digitals together to make a VERY LARGE IMAGE...

Re: OT: More Digital Photography questions

#2

Buy a scanner

Mike Brazeau

>For a $100 you can buy a flat bed scanner with overhead lighting attachment for slide scanning. I bought one when we updated our scanner, but have never got around to opening my umpteen boxes of slides from the 60's and 70's before I could afford colour prints.

Mike

Re: OT: More Digital Photography questions

#3

Re: OT: More Digital Photography questions

Scott Longberry

>Hi Steve,

Modern operating systems have made it so you can work with very large files (up to 16TB or more) so the real problem you run into is memory. How much memory does your machine have? If you are on a windows box, most motherboards limit you to 4GB. Apple will let you use up to 16GB in their G5 desktops.

When considering memory usage, you need to be very generous. For example, you may think that to edit a 600MB file should only take 1GB of RAM (600 MB leave 400MB for the OS, right?). The problem is that A. the OS really needs more than you think and B. that pesky undo feature in photo applications eats a LOT of memory. I'd suggest 2GB of RAM to work on that 600MB file. For those REALLY big panos you're talking about, I'd by a Mac :)

Also, if you don't have enough memory to actually edit the file, the program will still let you work on it. The problem is that the OS will start using hard disk space as memory after you run out of acctual RAM. Hard disk is orders of magnitude slower than RAM, so the rogram will run painfully slow.

Probably nore than you wanted to know... :)

Scott

Re: OT: More Digital Photography questions

#4

Re: Buy a scanner

John Lucas

>I would agree with Mike. I don't think our scanner is top of the line but we scan 6x7 and 4x5 transparencies and make prints as large as 48" x 6'. They look really good. Ours is an epson 4870.

Re: OT: More Digital Photography questions

#5

Steven Antonucci

Have a scanner-

steve antonucci

>All of the slide scanners I've seen for 6x6 have been ridiculously evpensive, and 'low resolution' (1200DPI)

I've seen ones for 35 mm, but not 120 roll film? Have they come down so much that I need to look again? A quick Google this AM had me at $1500 for a slide scanner. OUCH!

I've also seen people talk about rigging a light source above the slide, and scanning with a regular flatbed- tried it with mixed success.

FWIW- the printing service told me that silver halide film has an optical resolution of 3000 DPI, so I might look for a 2400 DPI scanning service...

And I still need to look through the box to see what "is worth this effort".

Thanks

Steve

Re: OT: More Digital Photography questions

#6

Steven Antonucci

Thanks-

steve antonucci

>pretty much what I guessed- Worked in and around IT for 18 years, and computers since I was 14...so I had the suspicion.

I'm going to muck around with it some, and I'll let you know what happens...

Steve

Re: OT: More Digital Photography questions

#7

Re: Have a scanner-

John Lucas

>Steve I talked to my boss and he says our scanner is 4800 dpi and ran about $450 several years ago. He thinks the new models may be cheaper. He did some rough math and though you could make a 30x30 print at 300 dpi from a 2 1/4 neg.

Re: OT: More Digital Photography questions

#8

Re: OT: More Digital Photography questions *LINK*

Rick Allen

>This was done with 6MP images.


Gigapixel image

Re: OT: More Digital Photography questions

#9

Steven Antonucci

Isn't Google wonderful?

steve antonucci

>Believe it or not, this is what started me down this path. I saw this yesterday, and thought that there had to be a better way to create this type of image, so I started looking into hi-res scans of my slides. Apparently, my Hasselblad with slide film records on the order of 45 million bits of optical resolution, with an upside of 81M. When you factor in the "color" (x4), the files can easily end up 500MB.

I've spoken to a few people and they believe that a 3000 DPI file would put me around 300 MB, so I could conceiveably recreate this image with only 3-4 stitches vs. this guys 196. I actually did a hand held pan and scan overlooking the Bryce Amphitheater in this image. I can tell you that for $6, there is a service that will scan my slide and send me the file, and another digital prinitng service that produced very good affordable output for under $30.

That being said, with the lights off and my Ebay-puchased Lindemann 2 1/4 projector (mint, in the box, Schneider lenses, under $150- SCORE!), I have filled the back wall of my living room (8'x8') with the images, and they can be stunning. While not a Cibachrome, digital printing continues to get better and cheaper than it's chemical/paper equivalent.

My darkroom is dormant...

Steve

P.S. Attached is a digital stitch from Zion- Need to mess with the sky, but the first print was 17"x 48" and $25. Framing is another story...


img

Re: OT: More Digital Photography questions

#10

Re: Have a scanner-

Dinyar Chavda

>John & Steve:

I don't know much about the scanners you want, but I can point you towards some good stores.

You can find scanners of the specs that John was talking about at several sites for a lot less money (this is the flatbed scanners). One place where I have had good luck is Tigerdirect.com, including their refurbished items---however, be careful. They have a very restrictive return policy, so make sure you want to buy something before ordering it. But, I took a quick look at their scanners, and there are several with the resolution John mentioned at very low prices (some in the low $100 range).

Other sites that you can try are fatwallet.com and newegg.com.

Unfortunately, the prices of slide scanners are high--in the 600 + range.

Good luck.

Oh yes, the other thing that you can try, if you have a specific model in mind is to froogle it, at http://froogle.google.com/. Occasionally, that does point you in the right direction.

Hope this helps.

Re: OT: More Digital Photography questions

#11

Framing photos

Scott Longberry

>Hi again Steve,

I had to chime in again when I read your comment about the cost of framing vs. printing. Having recently taken a 13 x 19 photo print to get a custom frame made for it, I've come up with the following solution. I'm going to take the $200+ that it was going to cost me for the frame down to Woodcraft and buy all the tools (glaser point setters and such) to build my own frames. That way I can explain to the Mrs. that every frame after the first will be "almost freee!" :)

Scott

Re: OT: More Digital Photography questions

#12

Steven Antonucci

Minus the point setter...

steve antonucci

>I already have all of the tools I'd need for a wooden frame...

The kick in the head is that I need to add that to the list of projects I've already started. Vs. spending $220 on a custom framing solution, I am perfectly willing to leave the print in the mailing tube until I get to making that frame... :-)

steve

Re: OT: More Digital Photography questions

#13

Steven Antonucci

OT:Tiger Direct

steve antonucci

>As it turns out, Tiger is based in Long Island (they own a few "catalog/website companies"). In my comings and goings, I have made sales calls on them, and they have never bought from me.

Can you guess where this is going?

While I certain appreciate your input, I don't see me being supportive of their business when they weren't supportive of mine.

Steve

Re: OT: More Digital Photography questions

#14

Re: Minus the point setter...

John Lucas

>Steve I built the frame for out big print. We had to put plexiglass in it and I was afraid it would warp with the weight of the plexi so I built a wire torsion system on the back. Sort of a big W. It's been hanging for over a year and no sagging at all.

Re: OT: More Digital Photography questions

#15

Re: OT: More Digital Photography questions *LINK*

Juergen

>If your going to do this right you need a slide scanner like the the one at the link below. Now to scan a 2 1/4 slide @ 4,000 DPI, well you do the math. While waiting 10-20 minutes for the scan to be saved to the hard drive, you can try to figure out how you're going to look at it on your 1024x768 or at best 1280x1024 DPI monitor. If you're lucky you might be able so see all of the a few square inches of the top left hand corner.

My guess to get it all to work you'd have to invest $7,000-10,000 in hardware to run your free copy of Gimp. How do I know I've built a few of these system for professional photographers who wanted the leverage their inventory of slides for poster and other work which required high resolution source files.


Mikon Slide Scanner.

Re: OT: More Digital Photography questions

#16

Steven Antonucci

Thanks-

steve antonucci

>I assumed it wasn't going to be "cheap". @$6/ea, the service bureau I found seems like a bargain...

Steve