Segmented Bowl
steve lewis
>My latest project. 6 1/2" x 6 1/2", Bocote, Bloodwood, Maple, and Black Walnut.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Segmented Bowl
steve lewis
>My latest project. 6 1/2" x 6 1/2", Bocote, Bloodwood, Maple, and Black Walnut.
Re: Segmented Bowl
Pete in Holland, MI
>Love the "windows" with the wavy grain.
Re: Segmented Bowl
MountainMan
>Hey Steve
Did you happen to take any pix of your glue-up??
Regards
The MountainMan
Re: Segmented Bowl
Rick Davenport
>I agree with Pete.
The "window" grain just POPS!
Nice piece of work.
Rick
Re: Segmented Bowl
Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL
>Steve,
You did not say, but are you open to constructive Critique?
Mark
Re: Segmented Bowl
Steve Lewis
>I didn't take pictures of the glue-up. Mark, I'm always open to constructive critques, it's part of the improvement process. One thing that happened on this bowl was the bottom maple ring moved during the glue-up causing mis-alignment. I also think that the feature ring could have been bigger. Also, the bottom could have been rounded more. I welcome your comments. Steve
Re: Segmented Bowl - Critique - Long
Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL
>Steve,
First of all, let me say that you did a good job on this piece. My suggestions are just that - my suggestions.
1) Your explaination of the ring miss-alignment hits my first suggestion. Just remember, that unlike most other woodturning, we can correct our mistakes. You can always turn off an offending ring and re-do it to correct the problem. Remember in all your segmented work - we are an additive art - by that I mean, regular woodturning, just like stone carving is a subtractive art - remove material until your work is done. Segmented turning is like ceramics or glass - we add material until we get what we want. I have glued up whole bowls and been in the final turning process when I realized that I did not have enough wood in the bottom to get the shape I wanted. I parted the top off, glued up new rings for the bottom, and then put the top back on.
2) The curve on the bottom half appears to flatten from the bottom of the first ring under the feature ring and on to the botton. You could have made the bottom a little smaller, though it is not too big now.
3) The top is good shape and size, but I think your top ring should have been Maple, as it would set off your top feature ring better. Right now they kind of blend together. Or at least seperate the top feature ring from the Walnut with a small Maple veneer ring.
4) The middle feature ring: a) I could only blow up the picture so much, but it looks like your Bloodwood verticle spacers have the graing running vertially, against the other horizontal segments. If so, this is begging joint failure from wood movement. Just slice the wood off the board like cutting bread to make verticle spacers so that all the grain runs in basically the same direction. Veneer is one of the few exceptions, in that veneers are so thin, that they don't have enough mass to move much. b) The size of the middle ring is just fine - larger would not be better. Placement is my issue with it. I happen to think that middle feature rings should not be in the exact middle of the form. I like the wide point of a hollow form to be about 2/3 of the way up the bowl, with 1/3 of the feature ring below that line, and 2/3 above. It helps lift the overall appearance. To demonstrate that, pull up the picture, and take a piece of paper and slowly cover up the top and slide it down toward the feature ring. As you do, you will see how the feel of the bowl changes.
5) Overall - the basic shape is good. It meets one of my basic rules for segmented work - would it look good it was a solid piece of wood or you painted it black? Your'd does. When I demo, I stake that for the most part, Segmented Turners make some of the ugliest shapes. That is because most people are so impressed with the work involved with segmenting, that they are unlikely to comment on the shape. Besides, most of what they have seen in segmenting has been ugly shapes. Because the segmented turner does not receive critique on the shape, he keeps it up, and it is self perpetuating. Except for the slipped ring, your joints look very good and tight. This is no small feat with light colored wood like Maple or Holly.
Please remember - Overall this is a good piece - my suggestions are just MY suggestions.
Keep up the good work.
Mark
Re: Segmented Bowl - Critique - Long
Steve Lewis
>Mark, Thanks for the input. I always take "suggestions" and apply them to my next projects. When I first started segmenting, I had no idea what was the proper shape, construction, and wood combination. Thanks to experienced turners like you and others, I keep getting better with each piece. Thanks again, Steve