Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Symposia and vendors - a view

Posts

Symposia and vendors - a view

#1

Symposia and vendors - a view

Ed Moore

>I think that some of the rhetoric about symposia organizers and vendors needs to be reined in a little. Until recently I was one of sixteen board members of the Virginia Symposia and I have had a fabulous time at two OVWG symposia and at Louisville. Yes, things can be improved, but these events are run by volunteers and the operational aspects are NOT understood by the general populace.

There were comments about which lathes could be sold by a vendor at some symposium. Let's look at things from the viewpoint of the vendor who very kindly supplies a large Brand X lathe for use at a symposium. That vendor has done a great service, so I think he deserves a little slack and has earned the right to be the only vendor there selling Brand X and if he puts a sign on the lathe pointing out that this Brand X lathe is for sale, SO WHAT! Vendors make their living by selling their products, should we expect them to be nothing but charities and never grant them some reciprocity? Understandably, another Brand X supplier would be shut out of that symposium and I don't see that as politics, but as a consequence of loyalty to the vendor who supplied the Brand X lathe for demonstrations at no cost to the symposium.

In Louisville a demonstrator could not find his keyless chuck and had no cash with him, so he went to a vendor and asked him to trust him to pay for it later. The vendor did, the demonstrator's audience was told where to get a great deal on keyless chucks, the vendor sold out of the chucks as a result, and the vendor would not let the demonstrator pay for his chuck when he went back later to settle up. And you say "What's your point?" Simply, the vendors provide more than an opportunity to spend money, they actively support the symposia and its operation.

The AAW board and associated volunteers are honorable folks who by and large work their fannies off trying to produce good symposia. And I thank and applaud them. I think they learned this time that as the number of attendees increases linearly the associated problems increase exponentially - so that doubling a crowd doesn't just double the problems, the problems may increase by a factor of 6 or 7.

Frankly, I appreciate the contributions the vendors make to help the symposium be a success. And I don't see politics as the villain here.

Just a point of view.

Ed

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

#2

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

Wilford Bickel

>Ed,

You did a much better job of making this point then I did - thanks! I totally agree that a vendor that goes to the effort of supplying lathes for demo's should be rewarded by the syposium. It is after all a business and that business has encountered costs associated with hauling, setting up lathe, etc. and should be allowed a good chance to recoup those costs!

One final suggestion I would make to vendors as a customer - make it easy for me to reorder from you! With the ease of internet store fronts most of us will not take the time and hassle to hunt up a business card, wait days for emails to be answered or try to "catch" you on the phone just to reorder a piece of wood or tool. Take your company name you sell under and do a Yahoo or google search for it - can a customer do this and "find" you?? Just words of advice from a "CUSTOMER" that is presently involved in the email tag game trying to locate and repurchase from a vendor at this very time!!

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

#3

Put it in writing

TDaniel

>Ed, any symp can make any rules that it wants and that is ok. The problem is when a vendor arrives at a symp with a truck load of turning related items and is told at the unloading dock that he cannot put 3/4 of what he brought into his booth because "so and so has that already". It takes several months to find merchandise and receive it to prepare for a show. Having someone tell you at the dock or call you 2 weeks before the show to tell you that you cannot bring certain brands of merchandise is not right. After some very frustrating incidents along this line I started asking up front if there are protected vendors; if the answer is "yes" I do not rent a booth. There is very little profit to be made at smaller shows, certainly not enough to justify bad feelings or confrontations. Attendees go to the events as much for the vendor area as for the demos and they are looking for deals. If you cannot buy items and sell them for a price that is less than the catalogs then why have a booth?

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

#4

Part of the Game

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>But there's a benefit to all the vendors as well. If you had six guys selling the same stuff, it would be easy to get into a "gas-war" ('member those) with the customers either playing one guy off against the other or screaming "price fixing!" Either way it's a formula for the smaller vendors to lose a lot of money. I would think the prudent vendor, knowing how the game is played at these things, would confirm, in writing with the organizers, all restrictions with a particular show well in advance and then decide on participation and product line with that information.

Just showing up with a truckload of stuff to sell is not good business practice.

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

#5

Re: Part of the Game

TDaniel

>Mark, as I stated, any rule is ok so long as it is announced well in advance and applied equally. If I don't like the restrictions then I can just make the decision to go or not go. The problem comes when rules are made at the door.

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

#6

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

Allen Neighbors

>As a person who has been a vendor for years at craft shows, I agree with TD. When you go to set up, and are told you can't sell what you brought it is wrong. Period. Free Country. If you sell the same product as me, you're going to have to compete with me for the sale. Your quality or mine. Your price or mine.

If your product is manufactured tools and equipment, rather than crafted bandsaw boxes or turnings, the price, and service after the sale, are the competition points. Keeping others from competing isn't right... it's socialism, or very close.

The powers that be are free to make their own rules, I guess, but I'm free to make the decision to not participate.

I wish I knew the correct words to use to say what I mean... but this is close enough I guess.

Just my opinion.

Allen

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

#7

Re: Part of the Game

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Understand your point, Terry. But since restrictions or protection seem to be fairly common, it's easier to assume them and then contact the organizers ahead of time to confirm what they will be. I wouldn't depend on volunteers to structure and publish that kind of information. Having written confirmation of your prior contact with a person of authority taped to your forehead on arrival at the loading dock, the Katie-Bar-The-Door routine should get blown off. Once they confirm the restrictions or lack thereof, they have the affirmative obligation to notify you of any change. No news is then good news for your planning.

Just a suggestion to stay out of trouble and save money on antacids.

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

Keith Tompkins

>MY take, for what it's worth:

ONLY the equipment manufacturers should be allowed to supply demo equipment, it would help alleviate a conflict of interest. A "licensed dealer" would not be allowed to supply equipment. After all, the EXPOSURE at a big symposium is far more beneficial to a manufacturer than a few sales...I would bet some companies would PAY for exclusive rights to supply demo machines to the AAW symposium! (written off as advertising expense) BTW, the AAW gave away 5 oneway lathes....why not just give away the demo machines instead?

Then,if the equipment in the demo interests you, feel free to seek out a dealer in the trade show. Any dealer. In a free market, competition is crucial; I cannot see how benefitting just one company can be interpreted as free or fair trade.

One of the very important reasons for attending a symposium is to compare equipment. If I can observe (or better yet, try out) A Stubby, then a Vicmarc, then a Oneway, Robust, etc...I would be in Turner's paradise. Costs, features, warranties,fit and finish, and dealer service. Eliminating this important element cannot be interpreted as a good thing, from my point of view.

The AAW exists for the benefit of ALL. All vendors, all turners, all demonstrators. WE all pay our dues, and should be treated equally. An inclusive policy rather than exclusive.

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

#9

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

Wilford Bickel

>Keith,

Except in a case of the large AAW symposium the lathe manufacturers are going to leave the support of the other small regional symposiums to their licensed dealer in that area. They look to the licensed dealers to represent them in these cases.

Wilford

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

#10

I agree Wilford

TDaniel

>The question that started this thread was "how do small shows get more vendors?". Obviously the manufacturers cannot go to every event because there just isn't enough sales volume to justify the cost. Local reps or individuals have to supply the lathes. Whether or not a sponsoring club wants to allow one company the exclusive right to sell lathes at the event is that club's right. I have no problem with this as long as I am told well ahead of time that it will be done that way. Finding out at the unloading dock that there is a restriction is not the way things should be done. We must all remember that any restriction is in one person's favor and is against another. The person who benefits will be back and the person who does not will not be back. When there are too few vendors it is because not enough have benefitted. When the vendor area gets smaller the show also gets smaller.

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

#11

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view *LINK*

Ed Moore

>TD, I totally agree that what a vendor can or cannot sell should not be decided on the loading dock. That's poor planning on the part of the symposium board and the board member in charge was probably inexperienced and clueless about how things work. As you said, the symposium is responsible for setting things up ahead of time. They were obviously remiss.

At the first Virginia Symposium two years ago a vendor promised to bring a Brand Y lathe for demos. And this vendor had a very good association with the symposium president. When the vendor arrived and did not bring a demo lathe the president made a quick call to the "main man" and the phone was probably too hot to handle. Another vendor bent over backwards and helped out. Oddly enough, this comming fall will not see that vendor at the VA Symposium.

I hope that more out-of-state folk will consider the Virginia Symposium. Check out the website.


Virginia Symposium

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

#12

Thanks for the Invite, Ed.

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>But 10 hours is a bit much to drive.

mm

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

#13

Re: Symposia and vendors - a long view

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Ed,

I plan to do the VA show this year. I hope to see you there.

I haven't run into the same restrictions that Terry has, but that's primarily because my main product is wood. I do bring along whatever items I run across that I think a woodturner might be interested in, but wood is my primary merchandise, and there are typically 3 or 4 wood vendors at a particular show.

I did run into a problem with the vendor rep for the Ohio Valley symposium last year. He didn't like the idea that I wanted to sell used tools and provide space for a Tool Trade where attendees could bring whatever turning related items they wanted and I would provide the liason between buyers and sellers. I've done this at other shows and got lots of positive feedback from customers as well as the symposium boards. The guy from Ohio Valley informed me that the symposium was only interested in providing their attendees with the latest technology in woodturning tools and equipment. He wouldn't even sell me space just for my wood. Needless to say, I was a little put off.

But, it's their game on their playground with their ball. I guess they can set whatever rules they like. I'll just choose not to play. The one who loses in the deal is the customer. I agree with Terry that everyone needs a copy of the rules up front so that everyone knows the game.

I haven't found competition in the same product category to be a big problem unless the show is just too small. I think you have to have at least 150 people or more at the small shows for all the vendors to have a decent weekend. I had a guy right next to me at the FL show who also sold primarily domestic hardwoods. When I got to the show, I was a little irritated that the set-up had us next to each other, but it turned out that I still had a good weekend of sales. Plus, he was handicapped, and I was able to watch his booth for him when he was away from it.

I expect to keep doing as many shows as I can afford to do. I hope to make the Texas show next year and perhaps the next show in NY. I'm sitting here now looking at the vendor application. A lot depends on how I end up upgrading my transportation situation.

Gary Evans

Talasi Hardwoods

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

#14

not inexperienced

TDaniel

>in fact he has been a club president and an AAW board member.

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

#15

Mark, I just ask now

TDaniel

>I simply ask "are there protected vendors?" If the answer to that question is "yes" then I do not go, period. As far as I am concerned it is unamerican. We are a nation of free trade. As I have said in other posts, every club can have any rules they wish. I can also have my own rules. It is MY policy to not participate as a vendor in shows that have protected vendors. It is not a right or wrong thing here; just how I decide whether or not I want to spend my time and money. This is not how it should be done; it is how I do it; other vendors do it as they wish. I think there are fewer problems when the event is totally open.

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

#16

Re: not inexperienced

Ed Moore

>Well, TD, there is no shortage of jerks in this world and the AAW Board is not immune from such. Fortunately I know some past and present Board members pretty well and they would help keep the "average up.

Ed

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

#17

Yup

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Your choice, Terry, of course. My suggestion were only to prevent the Nasty Confrontation At The Dock situation you described.

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

#18

me too Ed

TDaniel

>I hope I have not been too negative. You are correct, there are a lot of good people in the AAW and on its board. It is a shame that a couple can ruin the image of so many good ones. Woodturning for many is just a hobby and it should be fun; there isn't a place for the competitiveness that I often see. Let's just have fun!

TD

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

#19

I understand

TDaniel

>Mark, I learn quickly. Your words are not taken lightly. I do ask now, long before sending my check. Hopefully others also will.

TD

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

#20

Keith Tompkins

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

Keith Tompkins

>Thanks Wilford, I think since I just got back from a big one, that was what I was thinking of....oops.

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

#21

Welcome Gary!

Bert Smith

>Gary,

Do you have a website that I can post on the Symposium site? Looking forward to seeing you again in November!

Bert

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

#22

Re: Symposia and vendors - a view

George (Oxford, NC)

>It appears that with the comments on this thread that my feelings, as a manager (before I retired) and as president of various clubs over the years and chair of various committees over the years, is being shown here. You can't please everyone so just make the decision that you feel best for the group and the situation and go with it. You can never set a meeting date that someone won't have a conflict with, you can never set a ticket price that someone won't say is too high or another say that it is too low and you either loose money with less attendance or loose money with lower ticket prices. You can never include, nor exclude someone or something with out some member being offended. The manager, or organizer in this case, made the decision and what ever the decision, someone was going to be upset. This is one event out of probably hundred plus that most of us partcipate in over the course of a lifetime, so it works out to less that 1% of those events. Accept the decision and get on with life.

George