Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Sticking Aluminum

Posts

Sticking Aluminum

#1

Sticking Aluminum

Stuart Johnson

>I use a tailstock chuck adaptor to align segmented rings. The threaded portion is aluminum. When I try to use it with an anodized aluminum face plate it will screw on maybe 2/3 of the way and then sticks. If I use it on a steel faceplate there is no problem. Both faceplates screw onto the lathe just fine. It seems like the aluminum against aluminum is the problem. Any ideas on how I can fix the issue? Would some type of lubricant work?

Re: Sticking Aluminum

#2

Re: Sticking Aluminum

John Lucas

>Stuart You may have a problem with tolerances. Try the lubricant at first, it won't hurt anything and you can remove it easy enough with mineral spirits if you don't want it there. I've run into this problem with steel chucks and faceplates, where it will work on one lathe and not the other or this combination will work with this one but not that one etc. When they make the threads they have a certain amount of slop +or- that they allow in machining and that's called tolerance. Actually slop isn't a good word but you get the point. If you get a male thread that is off on the positive side and female that is off on the negative side you can get some binding. I took a wild guess on mine and filed the top of the teeth on the male thread and it solved the problem. Ideally you would measure everything very closely and find out where the problem is. In most cases your only talking about no more than .001" or so and when you hit the right area one swipe with the file and it works. The problem is knowing where to hit.

Re: Sticking Aluminum

#3

Soap

TDaniel

>can be used to lubricate aluminum. Try that first but I suspect the problem is that the threads on each part are not cut identically; one being to one side of the tolerance and the other to the other side. I would pass a die or tap thru each piece.

TD

Re: Sticking Aluminum

#4

2 of us typing at the same time

TDaniel

>but at least you have a consensus this time.

Re: Sticking Aluminum

#5

High 5 at ya TD

John Lucas

>

Re: Sticking Aluminum

#6

Thanks,

Stuart Johnson

>I'll try some soap and see if that works. I thought it was something to do with aluminium sticking to itself. Something along the lines of an aluminium canoe sticking to gravel bottom and a fiberglass sliding along. I had the same problem with a differnt faceplate and adaptor. Both work fine as long as one or the other was used with steel.

Re: Sticking Aluminum

#7

Re:Candle wax makes a better....

JamieDonaldson

>....temporary lubricant than soap which sometimes absorbs moisture and can cause oxidation.

Re: Sticking Aluminum

#8

Re: Soap

Jim

>I'm wondering if soap is a good idea with aluminum.

Doesn't aluminum oxidize pretty easily? And won't soap (a base) increase the possibility? I would think that an oil would be better, but that's just my opinion.

Re: Sticking Aluminum

#9

Aluminum Oxidation

Jake Niedling

>All solid aluminum has an aluminum oxide surface. When the molten metal solidifies, the surface which is exposed to air will immediately oxidize. This thin oxide layer provides protection to the aluminum underneath and prevents further oxidation. Aluminum oxide is the natural state aluminum wants to be. We all know that grinding wheels and sandpaper is made with aluminum oxide. So it is tough stuff. If you put something on the aluminum which will react with the aluminum oxide, then further oxidation can take place resulting in corrosion. Soap or wax will have not effect on the aluminum. It is possible, if the fit between the two pieces is bad, when they tighten against each other you could get some galling of the surfaces. This will make it difficult to screw together. Stainless steel against stainless steel will gall easily.

Re: Sticking Aluminum

#10

Re: Thanks,

Jim Pugh, Ohio

>Steve, you are pretty close to being right. As it was explained to me - the surface of machined aluminum looks like fish scales under a microscope. When rubbing against a harder surface, i.e. steel, there isn't any problem. When rubbing against itself it wants to lock up.

We were allowed to use aluminum housings for our product but the mating fittings had to be brass or steel - never aluminum.

Re: Sticking Aluminum

#11

STP Smoke Treatment or Slick 50

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>Either of these two products will work better than soap and will not fling off or attack the metal. We used to use STP on fine pitched microscope threads on anodized aluminum pieces becasue it stayed on the metal and didn't outgas and coat the lenses. It really only takes a "lil" 1/10 dab of this stuff to do the trick and it will stay on the parts for a long time. Either will also stay on your fingers for a long time too.