Article ready..
Keith Tompkins
>Ellis has informed me that my handout can be viewed at http://www.woodcentral.com/articles/tompkins_design.pdf
Feel free to comment on it, I would appreciate the input.TIA,Keith
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Article ready..
Keith Tompkins
>Ellis has informed me that my handout can be viewed at http://www.woodcentral.com/articles/tompkins_design.pdf
Feel free to comment on it, I would appreciate the input.TIA,Keith
Well done!
e
>hi keith!
thanks for such a excellent, well-written article ... it gets a big WOW factor.
thank you
adrien
>
Thanks for sharing with all of us
Jake Niedling
>Nice professional looking handout. Thanks again.
Thanks! That is a fine article.
Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA.
>
Re: Article ready..
Lan Brady
>Keith,
Very informative. Thanks for sharing.
Lan
Great Article, Thanks!!
Ron in Drums PA
>
Re: Article ready..
George Van
>Thanks Keith, your article is very clear, un-cluttered, and understandable.
Re: Article ready..
Allen Neighbors
>Well written, and handy for those of us who are beginners in this field. Thanks for thinking of us. I would like to have attended, but there just wasn't any way.
I like your triangle best... and I copied it when you posted it once before. It makes sense.
Thanks again
Allen
Re: Article ready..
Keith Tompkins
>Thanks everyone for checking out and commenting on the handout!
Re: Article ready..
Jennifer@Indy.USA
>Keith thank you so much for this. I've printed and stapled!
Much appreciated....it was lovely to see you again and to meet your Mom and your wife too!
Jen
Re: Article ready..
Keith Tompkins
>Thanks Jen, good to see you as well. There was not enough time to spend with anyone, I would have enjoyed going over your pieces in the IG with you! Hope the handout is useful!
ThompkinsTriangles
Dinyar Chavda
>OK keith, I'll confess that my inability to visualize things strikes again.
I understand the concept of phi (the two Goldens in your article). It's a nice ancient mathematical number that I can use to measure the dimensions of my design, and ensure that they are in the right proportions.
However, I'm having difficulty understanding how to apply the Triangles. As I follow from your article, you draw a right-triangle and its mirror, and see if that "fits" the design. The part I'm having difficulty with is that I can draw 2 triangles such that they would "fit" any design, and, as such, from a practical viewpoint, I can't determine how to use this approach.
Could you provide a concrete practical example? What I think would really help me is if you started with a bad design, showed how it "violates" the triangles, and then showed how to use the triangles to salvage or improve the design.
TIA.
Re: ThompkinsTriangles
Keith Tompkins
>Hi Dinyar, In my demo I took a bowl with a very poor form, and re-turned it, visualizing how it would fit into a triangle. For example, a bowl with a very large foot would not fit into the triangle model, nor would a form with straight sides...
Try this...on construction paper, draw a series of triangles, similar to my "Tompkins Triangle" page. Then, using a fine chain, suspend the chain to fill each triangle.(represented by the red lines on that page.) The triangle also helps in sizing the foot. You will find that, by using my method, pleasing forms can be developed that do not fit the "golden" formulas. A shallow bowl or platter is a good example. I find making sketches in this way really helps people "see" how the piece will look in advance.
In other words, generally speaking, if a bowl (or hollow form) visually fits the triangle, the result will be very pleasing.
Hope this helps, Keith
An oooooogly bowl!
Dinyar Chavda
>I still don't get it, Keith, so let me try to explain it using one of the examples you quoted, i.e., a bowl with a large foot.
Here is one, at the bottom of this page. Obviously, it has a foot that is way out of proportion to the body of the bowl, being almost half-way up the side of the bowl.
Fitting a triangle to the bowl
Dinyar Chavda
>Now I take the same bowl, and I can fit a triangle to it quite easily.
So, hopefully this explains the difficulty I'm having in understanding how to use these triangles. I have chosen a rather extreme case to make it easier for me to understand your explanation re how the triangles show that it is a bad design, and how to improve it.
Thanks.
Re: Fitting a triangle to the bowl
Gary in Zirconia, NC
>Dinyar,
That's the way I see it also.
Re: Fitting a triangle to the bowl
Ken Grunke from SW WI
>Dinyar,
In my opinion, your form does NOT conform to the triangle, because of the big empty space below the form. To be useful, Kieth's triangle concept should start with a pair of triangles whose combined proportions are fairly close to the desired dimensions of your form. In the pic below, I've taken your form and fitted a triangle that is closer to the form's dimensions to illustrate my opinion:
Re: Fitting a triangle to the bowl
Ken Grunke from SW WI
>Then, I took your long, narrow, triangle and fitted a form to that which is fairly close to the triangle's proportions:
Re: Article ready.. *LINK*
Ken Grunke from SW WI
>Keith, you can also put your handout on the AAW website--see link below.
Very well done, thanks!
AAW Forums: AAW demonstrators' handouts
Re: Article ready..
Keith Tompkins
>Thanks, Ken. If you will look at new posts, you will discover my reply to Dinyar is very similar to yours! The surprising thing is how many e-mails I received after the article in Woodturning Design from teachers...who now are using the triangle method to teach design. Several people in L'ville mentioned the same thing.
Thanks for the heads-up to the AAW site, Keith