Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid boxes?

Posts

Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid boxes?

#1

Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid boxes?

Craig Daymon

>I attended Hans Weissflog's demo on pierced-lid boxes. He uses boxwood whenever making one of these because it is hard, dense and flexible. Boxwood (I have been told) is hard to come by in reasonable size pieces in the US, but it seems that Osage Orange has many, if not all, of the properties of boxwood necessary for a good pierced lid box.

Thoughts? Comments? Anyone tried it already?

-Craig

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid boxes?

#2

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid box

eliot

>I suppose I not really answering your question, but I attended his demo also and wanted to try something like it. So I bought some English boxwood at the vendors booth. they had lots of it.

They are called Tropical Exotic Hardwoods of Latin America. (www.anexotichardwood.com)

Tel:760.434.3030

Fax: 760.434.5423

2270-B Camino Vida Roble

Carlsbad,CA 92011

P.O. Box 1806 - Carlsbad,CA 92010

I paid something like $26 for half of a small log about 9 inch long and 3 inches around.

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid boxes?

#3

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid box

RobinCorell

>keep your eyes open for some Japanese box wood. It is commonly grown as a hedge and some of the older stuff can get up to 3" in diameter, 2' is probably more common though. It dries very well in the round with no preperation or special attention.

Robin

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid boxes?

#4

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid box

georgetroy

>Pear and dogwood might work they are a dense wood and take detail well. GT

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid boxes?

#5

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid box

dwfII

>I'm probably out of my league replying to this but I know that I have read that only a few woods are dense enough and hard enough to do threading in. Boxwood, and osage orange were among those mentioned. It would seem to me that if you can cut threads in the wood you could do your piecing as well.

Just 2� worth from the peanut gallery...

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid boxes?

#6

Part of the problem is durability

Craig Daymon

>The flexibility without breaking of Boxwood is one of the key reasons Hans uses it. He has seen boxes done by people who have seen his demo using other woods such as maple and the problem was not so much being able to make the cut but keeping the spider web pattern from breaking once completed.

When asked what other woods he used, he said, "Boxwood". But based on why he uses it, Osage seems like a good alternative (except for coloring). After all, it's flexible enough to make bows from and hard enough to make sparks when cutting on a tablesaw.

I'm just thinking Osage because it is relatively easy to find around here. If I end up going the Boxwood route, I'll check out Tropical Hardwoods of Latin American.

-Craig

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid boxes?

#7

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid box

john lucas

>I've turned a fair amount of Osage. I'm pretty sure it will replace boxwood for your project. I talked to the sorby rep one time about the spiraling tool. They always demo with boxwood. He had a piece of Osage and used it to show me the difference. The box wood did cut cleaner but it was pretty good. It's also a good wood to turn threads in. I looked at some boxwood at the symposium but it was well beyond my price range and have a fair amount of Osage now so I'll try that as soon as I get time.

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid boxes?

#8

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid box

Greg Jensen

>Osage orange will not work in this application it is to opened grained and it will break out. Black wood, Cocobola, Ebony will work.

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid boxes?

#9

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid box

Jim Swank

>I agree. A fine texture, as well as hard and strong wood is needed.

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid boxes?

#10

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid box

Dick Anderson

>Depends on the kind of piercing you intend to do. Binh Pho pierces maple and other medium soft woods using a high speed Powercrafter type tool. His bowls are turned to a 1/16-inch (or less) thickness and his piercing leaves very thin wood strips between the piercings. Using the same technique I have pierced maple, box elder, mesquite, rosewood and alder. The rosewood, because of its hardness and oily nature tended to burn quite a bit. The maple pierced very easy and the mesquite was so so.

Piercing with a Foredom or Dremel type tool is very difficult, because they lacks the speed and have too much torgue, which tends to make the cutter skate.

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid boxes?

#11

Wrong kind of piercing

Craig Daymon

>What Hans does is not like what Bin does. Bin's pieces are meant to sit on a shelf and look pretty. Han's pieces, although somewhat delicate (hence the need for a wood with some flex) are pierced by turning and are meant to function as a small box with a lid. The inside of the lid is turned with concentric rings and the outside of the lid is turned (actually before the inside) with multiple centers to offset sets of rings and partial rings. (The partial rings created where the full circumference of the cut between the rings extends beyond the outer edge of the top.) Inside and outside are both cut halfway (or just VERY slightly more) in so they meet and create voids/openings.

I think Ebony or Blackwood, even though very dense and fine grained, would be too brittle to use for a box that you would ever want to open. Hans does make a ball-shaped box with open rings that is Blackwood/Ebony on the outside, but he perfectly matches a boxwood ringed box to the inside which he carefully glues at every intersection, thereby giving strength to the outer half of the box.

I think he said something about the oiliness of rosewoods that would cause a problem, but I'm not certain. Maybe that the dust would cling to the tip of the tool creating the possibility of a break when cutting the rings.

-Craig

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid boxes?

#12

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid box

Chuck Engstrom

>Mike Mahoney threaded a piece of boxwood for the female part of the closure in his Saturday morning burial urn demo but mentioned holly as a usable alternative. Might that be a possibility for you? We get a few pieces around here from time to time, sometime up to 12" diameter. Let me know if you want to try a hunk.

Best--

Chuck Engstrom

Chestertonwn MD

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid boxes?

#13

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid box

Duane C.Leach

>I turned one of the Hans Weissflog off set box lids today out of curly Maple. Worked just fine.Cherry however didn't work so very good. Chipped out badly. The big problem was making a tool to make the cuts with.

This is one project that requires a lot of planing.

Ain't turnin fun

Duane

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid boxes?

#14

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid box

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Hey Duane....I'd love to see demo of this next Sunday....any chance of it?

Jen :)

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid boxes?

#15

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid box

Craig Daymon

>Hans mentioned a maple box someone made after seeing the demo and although he said it looked fine, it was very fragile and I think eventually broke. (The design itself appears quite fragile, so we may be talking levels of degree here.) Of course, if it came out well, good. I'd test one to see how strong it is before I turn 50 for craft show though.

You said figured maple? Does the figure compete with the design at all? Usually something with this intricate a design/pattern stands out better with a non-descript grain pattern. (I think Stuart Mortimer would back me on this. We had a discussion about grain competing with shape at one of the museum openings on Wednesday night.)

-Craig

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid boxes?

#16

Re: Try Olive

OB O'Brien

>Mahoney also mentioned Olive as an alternative to Box wood. I went looking for Boxwood after the demo and it was all sold out. So I opted for an expensive piece of Olive. I'm planning on using it for the female threaded hidden collar to accept a threaded blackwood finial on urns. Haven't tried it yet.

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid boxes?

#17

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid box

Stan Townsend

>You might like Crepe Myrtle it is close grain and flexible. Finding the larger pieces may be a problem but Texas Highway Dept. trims the C. M. from the divided highway median every year and welcomes anyone to haul it off. Stan Townsend

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid boxes?

#18

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid box

Duane C.Leach

>The curly maple I made the lid from worked fine. Almost no tear out, and what tear out there was was easily sanded out.

I left a small section un-grooved to show off some of the curly figure. And it extends through the grooves as well.

The fragility of the piece depends greatly on the thickness and overall strength of the wood used.

The real trick is to make and then learn how to use a bit small enough to cut the tiny grooves. The one I am useing now is just under a 1/6" wide and breaks easily. I will try to make the bit even smaller.

Just having fun turning.

Duane

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid boxes?

#19

Re: Osage - Boxwood substitute for pierced-lid box

Duane C.Leach

>hi Jennifer. Not sure I can make it to the meeting Sunday. But if I can I will show you how I turn those grooved lids. I think this Sunday's meeting is going to be at some guy's shop on Gasoline Ally.

Duane