Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Videography at the Symposium??

Posts

Videography at the Symposium??

#1

Videography at the Symposium??

Russ Fairfield

>All of the comments about the recent AAW Symposium have been critical of the video in the demonstration rooms. Many have suggested bigger and better camera equipment, bigger screens, better sound, and experienced camera operators. Is bigger and better video really the way we want to go? Do we really want the AAW to emphasize video theater over the personal demonstration?

It seems to me that the folks at the AAW should be looking at what role they want the video camera to play in the demonstration. Should they be looking for ways to reduce the emphasis on the video by reducing the size of the audience, or should they be looking for ways to increase the capability of the video equipment so they can pack more people into the a larger room??

The video camera was introduced into the demonstration room as an enhancement to the demonstration. It was a way for the audience to see what was happening on the other side of the wood. That was a good thing, even for a small audience. The quality of the camera, the size of the screen, and the skill of its operator were not issues. Most of the time, the camera was set in one position, turned on, and forgotten about unless it was knocked over.

Over time, the video has become a means to pack more people into bigger demonstration rooms. We are now at the point where watching the video screen has replaced watching the demonstrator for most of the audience. Only the people in the first two rows are aware that the demonstrator is there. The rest of the audience is watching the video screen, and for them, the demonstrator might as well not even be in the same room. We are only one step away from having one demonstrator being seen by more than one audience, and the size of each audience being limited only by the size of the screen. In this theater setting, the production of the video, the video equipment, and the size of the screen becomes more important than the demonstrator.

The question for the AAW should be one of whether the emphasis is on more personal demonstrations to a smaller audience, or the production of video theater to a larger group. There is nothing wrong with going in either direction. But, it would appear that we are at the point of having neither.

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

#2

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

Craig Daymon

>One problem I saw with the video was that even where the person operating the video was competent with the equipment (not always the case) they frequently were were watching the demonstration and NOT watching what was actually being viewed by the camera. Several demostrations I attended suffered from large portions of the demostration missed because the camera operator was watching the demostrator first hand without looking through the camera.

I don't think bigger screens or better cameras was the issue, it was more a matter of execution. Though, the overhead camera could benefit from some remote motion control.

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

#3

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

eliot

>Russ is clearly bringing up the larger issue of watching live vs. watching a video. Certainly, watching live in a small group would be superior. but what are we to do with so many people? If I can't be in a small group watching live, I'd at least want to see as best that I can via a video.

The problem at the AAW was that some of the video operators just weren't very good or , as has been said, weren't paying sufficient attention. Or, in some cases the equipment wasn't good: the video during the Instant Gallery Critique was a disaster!

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

#4

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

Russell L. Babbitt Jr.

>One Russ to another. I find video very beneficial to show more of what the demonstrator is doing. My last demonstration was Kansas City and the biggest problem I thought was the videographer watching the demo and not working the camera. A polite gentle reminder might be in order. At demos of the Channel Islands Woodturners I am the videographer. I have received complements from members and professional demonstrators on the job I do. I have also received reminders to pay attention to the camera. The benefit of having the camera their is attendees get to see detail they cannot see from their seats. We also use an overhead mirror system. I can show closeups of the tool work, how the turner moves and closeup of turned details. Very important to learn techniques.

A suggestion I would make to the AAW is to try to give the volunteers more training. Perhaps first thing in the morning get them together. This may not be as easy as it sounds as there are many models of cameras being used. Remind them that they are there to operate the camera first and then enjoy the demo. Also a reminder during the opening introduction that these people are volunteers and need to be treated politely with gentle reminders to get the camera back on track.

Wow....my 2 cents worth and then some...

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

#5

Logistics are driving it.

Mike Brazeau

>This was my first symposium and even though there were some shortcomings, in no way can I be critical of any of the many people that volunteered. I agree with Russ (2) that additional training of the camera operators would improve the situation. My wife and I sat in on 10 demonstrations of a possible 11. Without the video, there would have been no point in being in the room for most of them.

At our Golden Horseshoe Woodturners Guild, we have been using a single camera since forever and added mini-cams from Woodchuckers in the fall of '02. The mini cams are excellent to see from overhead tool positions etc or aim at a flip chart. About a year ago we added a relatively inexpensive digital camcorder with image stabilization and about three months ago went from two 27" TVs to a rear projection video projector system. It can zoom in on a few inches and blow up to a sharp image several feet wide. One additional benefit of the projection system is tha the camera operator can usually see the image, where with the TV it was more difficult. With rear projection, you eliminate the problem of people walking through the light beam. All of these progressions have enhanced our meetings and as past president can say that numerous people came forward and commented on the fact that they could now see what the demonstrator was doing. We have between 100 and 110 at almost every meeting and part of the reason is the success of the video system, where as in the past a good meeting was 50 people. It is a lot of work to set up, but worth every bit of it. It is not something learned in a 10 minute conversation and walkthrough, but something that steadily improves. Our local experience is a bit off topic, but I just do not agree with some of the threads that have suggested limiting numbers etc at the meeting or demonstrations. We are now over 250 chapters and 12,000 members and have to expect and deal with larger attendances all around. One major goal of the AAW is to promote wood turning and by limiting attendance that goal is not achieved.

My thoughts, Mike

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

#6

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

Russ Fairfield

>Russell,

I agree that using the video to enhance the demonstration and give us a better view of what they are doing is a good thing. What I am questioning is the trend towards the video replacing the demonstrator as the only thing we can see.

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

#7

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>The video should be better than what you actually see. That's why we have video. Cameras can zoom in or out and capture what one person seeing at one location can't.

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

#8

2 suggestions:

TDaniel

>1. Limit class size and add more demonstrations. I would like to see a lot more fundamentals taught. There are a lot of good turners who could teach smaller classes for a fraction of the cost of a nationally known teacher. Then let the big names do a lecture rather than a demo. A lot can be learned in a lecture if the attendees already have basic skills.

2. Keep it simple. Insure adequate sound proofing between demos so the demonstrator can be easily understood. Use still shots (slides) where emphasis is needed on a technique.

There will still be some demos that have to be done as they now are but I think the lecture type demo has it's place.

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

#9

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

john lucas

>Russ I think the videos are necessary even with a small group. We only have about 18 or so in our local club no one can see what's going on even that close. Even when I run the camera I can't really see the cut from 6 away. By zooming in I can see the cut very well and so can every other person in the room.

I agree with you the personal demo is nice but even with only 30 people in the room it's difficult or impossible to really see what's going on. Take for example Molly's demo. How can more than the front 5 people see what she's doing with the pyrography.

I remember when we used to use a mirror above the lathe so people could see. This was better than nothing but you were still too far away to really see anything but the largest movements.

If the demonstator and photographer are communicating with each other we could really present the skills to the audience.

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

#10

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

Russell L. Babbitt Jr.

>Agreed, video should enhance not replace.

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

#11

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

Buddy Riley

>remember, the key word here is volunteers. that is what the people are that run the cameras. Volunteer your time and try to do it. These people want to watch the demo also. The only way it will ever get done is if you hire someone like college students who are taking video clases and have no interest in turning. Therefore the only interest is filming the demonstrator and showcasing it to the audience.

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

#12

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

Duane C.Leach

>The videos, moniors, and screens during demos are a must have. I don't see a way around it. At our club (40 people) rather than relying on someone to run a video camera we bought the small match box cameras (2) and mounted them on an overhead boom. Everyone can see just fine. But nothing is going to work well with 300 to 400 people in a room that wasn't designed for this kind of show. The demonstrator and screens should be UP on a stage so you can see over the big guy in front of you.

More demonstrators should mean fewer people in most rooms. And that would have been a big help last week. I think the AAW is having trouble getting GOOD QUAILFIED demonstrators.

Just some of my thougts.

Duane

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

#13

My Take....

W.C. Turner

>"hire someone like college students who are taking video clases and have no interest in turning. Therefore the only interest is filming the demonstrator and showcasing it to the audience."

This sounds like the best solution. If they're taking video classes anyway, they might be persuaded, in lieu of payment, to run the cameras for free, just to gain experience.

The best way to enhance a demo, is to have the Artist, give directions to the camera person, especially, if they do not turn. For example, now zoom in here for this, or let's get a different angle here now, back the camera off and Let's show, etc. I'm telling you, that'll make all the difference in the world, in enhancing the show for the audience.

Just my 2 pennies.

Email: Remove 2

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

#14

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

Steve Mushinski

>This is to everyone but I hope John L reads this.

First, hiring people that have never turned will do little to fix things. They will have no idea what to feature and what to look for. By the end of the weekend they will be experts but that will not help us. Can you imagine a young person taking all the words of wisdom from the crowd and trying to film. Now if they are trained on what to feature before the symposium then it might work extremely well.

Expecting volunteers to spend countless hours in training before the the demo's is unrealalistic. This year I found I had no spare time what so ever. Days were 6:30am till very late at night. Going to video training sessions would have been very low on my list. I did go to the 1 hour as everyone else did. Asking for experienced camera operators only on the camera might help.

Some of the equipment needs to be updated. I have seen countless comments about the little cameras. I found they worked fine for the job they are intended for. Once they are moved they must be refocused by turning the ring on the front. Often this was not done as most of the operators did not know about it. Now the hand/tripod cameras that I used were not very good. They really did not like any extra light and did not like low light. The tripods are almost useless except for just using them for a stationary cameras. They are just to jerky to use smoothly. Lighting is a problem but I would not try and inform John on this subject. He has forgot more than I might ever learn.

Switcher need updating also as most of the demonstrators have Power Point presentation on laptops. We need something that will accept s-video which the present switchers do not have.

Hopefully with the write up John will do, a better direction will be taken in the future. Many of the more vocal members of the audience want to see the over head featuring the shape. For me I am more interested in seeing the flute angle and the body language of the turner, then the shape. Hand grips and techniques are more informative to the turner wishing to learn. But as I see in our club, shavings and action seem to be what captures the audience attention.

The best demo I worked was with Michael Mocho. He was outstanding at getting his message across to the audience. I would just whisper to him we missed that shot and he would say " I will do that cut again so you can get a better view". I think, for it to come together the demonstrator, the camera person and switch operator (hopefully next year) must work in tandem. Hard to do unless you are a professional or you have all worked together before. Video teams might be the best solution in the future. At least after the first demo the team would be on the same page the rest of the weekend.

Not moving the symposium I doubt is a option as that is not what the AAW is trying to do. Expose turning to everyone from all over North American not just the middle of the United States.

I think for the most part everything went OK. As with everything we can always do better. These threads go a long way to doing just that.

-Steve

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

#15

Re: My Take....

john lucas

>W.C. That's my point exactly. If the demonstrator takes charge and works with the camera person we could have one heck of a demo with everyone being able to see. Then it would also be easier to tape the session and have these for later.

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

#16

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

john lucas

>Steve what an excellent response. Mostly I'm just throwing out ideas and listening to see if there is anything we can really do. I'm going to sit down tonight and make some more notes on the ideas mentioned to see if I can make this aricle useful. Obviously the best way is to have one or two people run the camera and switcher who are knowledgeable and intersted in helping the demo, along with a demonstrator who understands the power of the medium and can work with it. That's the perfect scenario and I'm sure we won't get there, at least for the bulk of the demo's. However with a little help and coaching maybe we can make some progress.

As a lighting person I am constantly frustrated with that part, especially with cameras that don't have manual focus and manual aperture control. I remember one time I was running the camera for Rude Osolnik (who was good at working with the photographer and like to badger them as well). From my viewpoint there was a large window over his shoulder. Anytime I zoomed back to see him the window would overpower the exposure and Rude would be a shadow. There wasn't anything I could do and I cussed that camera the whole day.

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

#17

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

Russ Fairfield

>This is not what anyone wants to hear, but "WATCH THE DEMONSTRATOR OF YOUR CHOICE FROM THE BEST SEAT IN THE HOUSE." is not the way to get qualified camera operators.

AAW Directors and others have come on this and other forums to solicit volunteers with those words, they have been published in the Journal, and I have said them myself. And now everybody wonders why so many of the camera operators showed more interest in the demonstrator than in the camera.

We definitely need to change the message if some level of proficiency is required for a camera operator. There needs to be some level of enticement for those who already have the skills, and some means of training for those who don't. This not an easy task.

I agree with everybody who says video is important. Good video is not only important, it is essential when we charge several hundred dollars for the priviledge of watching demonstrations that are performed in front of a large audience. The problem is that nobody is getting what they are paying for.

Blaming the volunteers, and saying we will try harder next year isn't going to get it done. Someone at the AAW has to sit down and determine where they are now and what video capabilities they have, where they want to go, and lay out a plan for getting there. This has to be done by someone with experience in making video presentations to large groups. I may be wrong, but I don't see that experience in any of the AAW staff or Directors.

Somebody needs to start thinking outside of the box that has a bunch of folks gathered around the lathe to watch somebody turn something. The Symposium has reached the status of an "event", and growth demands that it be treated as one. That requires someone to start planning for production techniques to be added to the demonstration room. This is more than just picking a popular demonstrator, sticking them in front of a room full of people, finding someone to operate a camera, and hoping for the best. This will require the demonstrator, the camera operator, and a director all working together to make a good presentation, and that can require a rehearsal before the scheduled demonstration. We owe this to those who are paying to sit in that seat.

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Russ,

Some demonstrations were videotaped for inclusion in the AAW video. This was scheduled in advance of the event. Naturally, a better job was done in these presentations, as the equipment was run by professionals. I think all demonstrations should receive the same treatment...a big name does not guarantee a well prepared demo, and many gems go completely unnoticed.

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

#19

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

Bob Fawcett

>I was not able to attend the Symposium so none of my comments apply directly. I have seen a number of woodturnig presentations on video tape and DVD. Most of these are done by professionals. There are also some that are obviously better than others. One that stands out to me is Jimmy Clewes new 3 DVD set "Turn it On". The video in these is a cut above all the others I have seen. This is what AAW should strive for.

I wonder if including examples of very good results would help instruct potential future operators.

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

#20

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

john lucas

>Russ I was thinking exactly the same thing this morning. It's not just a job it's an adventure,I think I heard that somewhere. It should be approaches as using your skill to help the demonstrator or something like that. I agree with everything you say. There actually are some experienced people helping the AAW with video's. We need thier input as well and I will ask them for thier opinions as well.

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

#21

AAW has Phil Pratt

Bob Elliott

>Russ stated earlier, "This has to be done by someone with experience in making video presentations to large groups. I may be wrong, but I don't see that experience in any of the AAW staff or Directors."

The AAW has Phil Pratt working in the background filming and producing Symposium DVD's / videos. He certainly knows what he is doing and could impart his knowledge and skills. Seems they only use him when there is a chance to make a $buck$.

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

#22

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

Clay Foster

>A small monitor for the demonstrator would be really helpful. Carolina Mountain Woodturners had one when I was demoing there recently. It really helped me know what the audience was seeing.

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

#23

Re: Videography at the Symposium??

Pascal Oudet

>Russ,

I was one of the volunteers, and we had been trained. actually there were 3 sessions so everyone could find a suitable one with his agenda.

and taking care to watch what was shown on the screen, instead of taking notes from the demos, was clearly part of the training.

now if people don't go to this mandatory training, or forget everything once they're in front of the camera, that's another point.

Pascal