Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Random thoughts on AAW symposium

Posts

Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#1

Keith Tompkins

Random thoughts on AAW symposium

Keith Tompkins

>After a few days to catch my breath, here are some of my thoughts concerning the symposium:

1.Instant gallery. There was some tremendous work this year. I overheard one "bigname" turner remark.."not many turned dog dishes this year!". Many turnings were highly decorated or carved (as usual), but the shapes and forms were very, very good. Much better than in previous years. The finishes were also very good. I mentioned in the chat that my favorite piece was Chris Ramsay's walnut nat. edge bowl. Beautiful shape, contrast between the sapwood and heartwood was great, and the bark,which contained voids, seemed to bridge the negative spaces in the piece. It was fairly large, yet it was obvious how much effort went into the details. Maybe someone can post a pic of this piece for discussion. Why they chose NOT to critique this piece is beyond me.

2. Demos: I think demonstrators at the national level really need to put a lot of effort into the presentations, especially subject matter. Tool handling, sharpening, etc. are better covered at smaller venues, esp. at the local club level...where the audience can SEE and participate. I think the demos at the AAW should be something special; something to savor for a long time. I despise long, boring slide presentations. I prefer talks that inspire me to try harder.

3. Nightlife: A good way to learn about the demos the easy way. Many turners sit around at the bar after hours, the topic is often what demos they attended, and plan to attend the next day. You may hear "So and so was great.. do NOT miss it!". Sometimes the demo you are dying to see gets terrible reviews. You can really see the results of a demo the following day...the better demos are packed!

4. Meeting people...I love meeting new friends, and seeing old ones again. I met a guy from KY who makes banjos. He does custom inlay work for Gibson! We really hit it off while standing in line at Packard's booth, and exchanged addresses, etc. That was a little bonus. The symposium is also a great way to make contacts for new demos, etc.

5. The crowd. I usually hate crowds. This year, it didn't bother me. You could feel the excitement in the air. Everyone was rushing to the next demo a little quicker than usual.Lots of impromtu demos, etc. It was fun just to watch everyone in the hallways.

Anybody else have a few comments?

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#2

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

john lucas

>You covered it pretty well. My only real complaint is the video operators and working with the demonstrators. Some (not all) of the camera operators try to show the demo as best the can. I won't discuss the operators who watch the demo and don't care about the camera. The problem I ran into is the demonstrators don't work with the camera. The often talk to the 10 or so people sitting in the front and it's difficult for the camera person to follow everything. If they show a tool grind they wave the tool around, the cameraman can't follow this. They stand in front of the easel or blackboard so the video camera can't see it. They move from one cut to the next too fast for the camera person to shift the camera.

Then thier the crowd. If you move in front of the crowd to better show the cut someone in the front row fusses at you. The other 200 people can't see if you don't do this. Then one person will holler for you to zooom out and someone else want's you to zoom in. You can't win. Add to all of this the intimidation factor of a fairly new turner running the camera for a very big name turner and you can see that they will be leary of asking the demonstrator to slow down, hold still or whatever. Every demonstrator I've met will gladly do this if asked but the new person who's never met this guy or gal will be intimidated.

Demonstrators aren't professional actors so working with the camera is new to most of them. Some have learned, John Jordan, and Stewart Batty come to mind. they know the crowd needs to see and always look at the camera person and ask if they can see this cut or whatever.

I know we need better cameras and camera operators but paying a group to do it would be way too expensive so we need volunteers. I'm working on an article to address these problems both camera volunteers and demonstrator awareness. If you have any ideas on how to improve the demonstrations from this point of view please e-mail me. One thought I have is to have the crowd a little further away so everyone needs to see the screens, then the demonstrator will work exclusively with the camera person and you should get some really great images that everyone can see.

Gosh I didn't mean to sound like I'm on a soap box but I hear a lot of comments on camera operators and it wasn't always thier fault. With groups this size the video becomes very important and we need to look and see what can be done to improve it.

By the way Keith did pretty good except for standing in front of the easel a few times. It's tough being a TV personality.

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#3

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I have a few thoughts about this symposium, Keith.

This was my first symposium, and as a fairly new turner, just in my 3rd year, I decided early on that I was going to concentrate on the intellectual side of turning; design, form, and presentation.

With that in mind, I will make a statement on each item you talked about.

1. Instant Gallery - Overwhelming at first. I walked through the IG at least 4 times. Each time I saw something different. I took many photos of pieces that interested me, not really paying attention to who made it. I tried to get the label card into the photo each time. All in all, the IG was fantastically inspiring.

2. Demos - As I looked over the rotation schedule, I had no idea what I was reading. After reading the description of each demo and was able to make decisions. I found that I wound up changing my direction as the symposium went on, but I was able to see all the demos I desired to see. The worst part of it all was those chairs. They just got too hard to sit in after a time.

3. Nightlife - We found a great restaurant for dinner on Wednesday. We actually ate there twice. Each night, we had different people at our table. The banquet was remarkable in the quality of the service. I also was fortunate to spend lots of social time in the lounge and at the restaurant. Loads of fun every night.

4. Meeting people - I thoroughly enjoyed meeting old friends and making new friends. I am not a great person for meeting new people, but it was really easy here. I dined with someone new at least three times.

5. Crowds - It was extremely crowded and I found that patience was truly a virtue at the symposium...to a point. If I was too patient, it was very to miss out. The funniest thing about the size of the crowd. I still ran into friends in the halls and demo rooms all the time. I agree with the observation about the excitement in the air. I felt it as soon as I walked in the door of the hotel.

By the way, I loved the Trade Show.

Keith

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#4

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

RK in Milw

>Catch your breath is a good way to put it. This my first symposium so here are my thoughts:

Demos - Couldn't get in to a few on my list as rooms were full. Alternate choices were good. Seems total attendance may have taken AAW by surprise but I think they did well under the circumstances. Many camera operators seemed unfamiliar with the equipment they were using; cameras constantly out of focus were distracting. Maybe a brief training session would help, or John Lucas' article might do the trick.

WoodCentral Lunch - Fantastic. Got to meet Bill Neddow, Stephen Mushinski, Keith Tompkins, John Lucas, Jennifer Shirley and Al Crandall. Al Crandall is a seminar in his own right. What an incredibly knowledgable guy.

Trade Show was great. I spent a small fortune on wood and picked up a few tools as well.

Hotel - Already discussed. They should be embarassed. Nuff said.

Instant gallery - Awesome, inspiring. IG alone was worth the trip.

My wife had a ball going through the gallery and the trade show. We both had a great time.

Ron Nelson

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#5

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

john lucas

>I guess I should have also mentioned that I had a really good time meeting people. I skipped a bunch of demos because I was talking to people I had see on WC or WOW and never met. Between that and meeting all the people I see at various demos around the south I had a really good time.

I spent a lot of time in the vendor area because I not only got to ask questions about tools I've been looking at but in some cases got to use the tool. Of course there were more people to meet in there.

I always love the instant gallery and I will second what keith said about the improved quality of the work. I looked very closely at the pieces that interested me and the finish and detail work was excellent. When you live in a small town like I do you constantly hear everyone tell you how great yourwork is. It's easy to get a big head. Then you put your stuff in the IG at the AAW symposium and it blends right in. Everything around your piece is so high in quality you don't stand out at all. Keeps you in touch with reality.

The demo's I did see were good especially the Mike Mahoney demo on cutting edges. He had Stewart Batty and Mark Baker in there so they all talked about each cut. I learned a lot from that demo and found it quite interesting.

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#6

I Agree...

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont

>Hi Keith,

I agree with what you have posted and what others have said.

The one thing I am going to add is that the vendor section was amazing for a person like myself, this was my first US wood show. What I really noticed more than anything was that the booths through the sales areas had most people I have only even just seen on video's etc (Alan Lacer, John Jordan etc..). That was exciting for me.

I also watched and looked more than I bought, turning tools can easily break the budget. It was wild to watch how people digested the booths and the tools. My only purchase was a chunk of Gabon Ebony that I will use for my furniture work.

A sales rep from Glaser left a business card in the IG on my pens and was looking to do a trade for a tool...I really did not want anything they had.

I can imagine that many here who make it to these shows frequently can see a change in what is being sold over the years, I wonder what we will all be craving 5-10 years from now!!

The best part of the symposium for me was meeting people, at times I even forgot there were demo's and a rotation going on... it all was overwhelming.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#7

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>I agree John, the camera operators were the biggest problem of the symposium. But I think they were much better than last year. I think an artical is a great idea. The demonstrators need to know how to hold a tool still and near a background that is in the same plane for focusing. A background 10 feet behind and the focus is on the background not the tool.

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#8

Suggestion...

Peter Teubel

>Couple suggestions concerning camera operators. If they had a training session held a day BEFORE the symposium started, they could at least get some idea of what to do. Have a real demonstrator do a real demo while a "director" shows (and has the operators participate) in what makes a good shot and what is expected of them.

Add some incentive like a %50 discount on admission if they agree to do one day's worth of DEDICATED camera work.

Just some ideas...

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#9

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

Russell L. Babbitt Jr.

>I agree that the camera work needs improvement. However I must say that the focus problem can sometimes be blamed on the camera autofocus. The volunteer could switch to manual focus, but he would have to be quite familiar with camera to do this quickly and then switch back when needed. The quickest solution is to use autofocus and zoom back a little. From all the complaints at this symposium the camera work seems like one of the minor issues that requires a fair amount of work to resolve. I would like to see the AAW record all the rotations and offer them on DVD. My guess there is probably some kind of copyright issue or something preventing that.

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#10

Re: Suggestion...

john lucas

>Good idea peter, I'll throw that out the AAW. The real problem will still be getting the volunteers but your idea may help.

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#11

meeting people.

john lucas

>I think this is something the AAW should persue, to actively find a way for people to meet each other. Everything except the banquet seems to be set up as demos. Rush here, rush there. We need a congregational area. The bar in the tunnel sort of worked but only after hours. Ideally I think something near the vendor, instant gallery area where peole could get something to eat and drink and hang out with each other. We always end up talking turning anyway.

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#12

Re: Suggestion...

Ron in Drums PA

>I'm the type of person who would volunteer for camera work regardless if there was any type of discount or not.

But to me, a 50% discount for one day's work for a two day symposium doesn't really add up. I think full paid admission for one day's work makes more sense. Maybe even throw in a critique or two

JMO.

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

Keith Tompkins

>You're right John...it's not easy being a TV celebrity..AND they couldn't get my makeup right! LOL. My camera operator in Orlando was totally inept...we had to replace him and take valuable time to fix the equipment. I am so glad you were able to help me..it's great to work with the best.!

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: I Agree...

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Jim, it was great to finally meet you, as well as many others!

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: Suggestion...

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Peter, I believe the training starts a day before the demos start...however, how much is retained is another question. I had good helpers on my rotations, luckily!

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Ron, great to meet you as well.....Yes, Al Crandall should be recognized as a national treasure! How 'bout a Duane Leach and Al Crandall show? THAT would be good!

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#17

Re: I Agree...

Jim Shaver , Happy Canada Day

>Same Here Keith,

Next time we may even get a chance to talk a bit more I hope.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#18

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

DavePowers

>I was real disappointed in the rotations I went to the first day. It looked like nobody was ready for anything except looking for equipment or tools. The second day was much better.

The vendor area.

Went by the the Jet area several times I can only guess the reps liked talking to each other and did not want to speak about there products. The person turning bowls there did speak about the bowls.

The people at the delta booth really liked to talk. They were very helpful and nice to speak with. Other boths were good also.

The IG was great.

Just my thoughts I should mention I am very new to turning so this might have biased me.

Dave

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#19

Keith Tompkins

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

Keith Tompkins

>HI John, to me, one of the most fun things to do is study the IG, then decide which pieces are the ones I would select for the critique. Imagining I am the one who will do the critique (Hey, it COULD happen) I study pieces to find my likes and dislikes. I especially enjoy pieces that I WISH I HAD THOUGHT OF!

I also enjoy seeing the influence of well known turners on the pieces in an instant gallery. Bin Pho, Betty Scarpino, etc. influences could be recognized fairly regularly. I like finding unique pieces that show unique qualities; especially if they are really well executed.

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#20

Re: Suggestion...

n2wood

>Thanks Kieth since I was one of your camera men during your demo of turning the rose. We did have a one hour session that you had to take before you helped out at a deme. I did one each day plus helped out with two rotations in the youth turnning sessions. Yes I did pay for three days and if i had it to do over again I would. The guys and gals in the crowd did help with sugestions of wich camera to have on. It was tough on me since I was in a position where it was hard for me to see the screens. All in all I had a good time. I worked Kieth's demo for two reasons. One I wanted to meet Keith and two wanted to see him do the rose. Thanks Kieth your a top notch turner!!!

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#21

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

eliot

>With respect to pieces chosen from the Instant Gallery for critique , they are clearly not necessarily the best pieces. Some are obviously excellent, but often they are chosen because of some novel or unusual feature. So it's probably fair to say that those selected are inventive and, perhaps even can be said to advance the field. In this sense, I suppose you could could say "best" ; but these pieces may not be terribly beautiful or even well done.

Last year in Kansas, one of mine was chosen. My brother, 81 years old, a writer of art books and an art critic with twelve books in print -- the real thing -- looked at it and asked if I had a chipper.

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#22

Keith Tompkins

Re: Suggestion...

Keith Tompkins

>It was great to meet you, AND you did a tremendous job. Thank you for helping me!

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#23

Keith Tompkins

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

Keith Tompkins

>HI Elliot, wow, your brother doesn't beat around the bush!ONe of my pieces made the critique, but I think there was something "fishy" about it. LOL

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#24

A little different perspective.

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>Having planned and oganized large scale events in a past life I put my critics hat on as I crossed the river. I tried not to but old habits die hard. I went to only attend the IG and trade show but did poke my head in a couple of demos just to see size, lighting, seating, yada yada. My overall impression was that the event was much to large for the venue. Abysmal lunch facilities, overcrowded demos, small trade show area, narrow isles in the IG, etc. I don't say this to cast stones at the AAW or the host hotel, these things happen when the event overwhelms those involved. I think the AAW would be better served to select a permanent mid country site, it makes the year to year planning and logistics much better for everyone. Going to a different site each year means working with folks who do not have a lot of experience with large scale events, and I doubt the AAW has the manpower or financial wherewhithall to send in a team to babysit the event for the months it takes to put together an event of this size.

I would also like to see a meet and greet area since a lot of folks know each other through internet connections and rarely get to visit face to face. Maybe a Sawdust Cafe thing, hmm I think I heard that name before.

It was certainly a treat to meet see some old friends the short time I was there, wish I could have stayed for a couple of days.

Ray

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

#25

Re: Random thoughts on AAW symposium

Jerry from Lapel In.

>It took General Motors 34 + years ,7 days a week, 8 to 10 hours per day to get him that knowledgeable?