Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

PM 3520A Concern (a little long)

Posts

PM 3520A Concern (a little long)

#1

PM 3520A Concern (a little long)

Black Bear

>A couple weeks ago, my PM 3520 A started to make a clicking sound inside the headstock. The sound is tied to spindle speed (one click per spindle revolution). I am a former product support engineer so I did your basic diagnostic evaluation. It is louder when I really tighten the drive belt by pushing down on the motor mount lock. No additional heating in the headstock casting at either bearing location. All screws are properly set and all pullies are aligned. Louder when I have an out of round bowl blank than doing a spindle or a once-turned rough bowl.

Thought I had contact problems between the locking pin and the spindle lock collar. Actually pulled the locking pin out and still had the noise.

Thought I had a flat spot on the belt but after multiple repositioning of the belt, still had the noise.

Went to Louisville and asked "Barry" at the Jet Powermatic booth about it. He said he thought my set screws on the spindle pulley had backed out and the clicking (which happens somewhere as the spindle key goes over the top from about the 3 to 6 on the clock). I removed the set screws, and then retightened starting with the set screw on the spindle key. Also did the same thing with the spindle lock collar. Really put a good torque on the set screws. Still had the noise.

I am frustrated as I pride myself on taking good care of my tools. I have mostly built my shop on rebuilding tools I bought second hand but this one I coughed up the full new price just 8 months ago.

Any ideas?

Re: PM 3520A Concern (a little long)

#2

Re: PM 3520A Concern (a little long)

Rick Allen

>8 Months should have the lathe under warenty. To me it sounds like a flat spot in the race of the bearing (maybe a a failed ball in the bearing). I have been told that the worst thing you can do to Headstock bearings is to bang on a stationary workpiece on the lathe. As long as the piece is spinning everything is fine. But stoping the lathe and carving wears out the bearing very fast. Powermatic should be happy to put things right whatever the problem turns out to be.

I recall a Oneway 1018, one of the first made, had a tick tick tick sound. That turned out to be the joint in the belt. After a little wear the noise faded away. Berhaps your belt has worn into a bad spot.

A regular noise that can be traced to a rotation of the spindle (1 for 1) is likely as Barry said or a bad inner race on one of the bearings. If the noise is directly tied to the belt going round (1 for 1) then it is likely the belt. If the noise is regular but at some other frequency then it is likely a bad bearing or the pulley on the motor shaft is the problem.

Good Luck, I hope you have it fixed soon!

Re: PM 3520A Concern (a little long)

#3

Re: PM 3520A Concern (a little long)

Bill Hale / Woodspinner

>Try taking the belt loose. Chuck something you can mount in a hand drill and use the drill motor to turn the shaft. This may isolate shaft bearing noise.

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: PM 3520A Concern (a little long)

#4

Re: PM 3520A Concern (a little long)

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>I had a noise like that in mine. It was a bearing. Powermatic replaced it. Mine went at 1 year.

Re: PM 3520A Concern (a little long)

#5

Re: PM 3520A Concern (a little long)

robo hippy

>I had that noise too, and traced it to a burr on the shaft from the spindle lock. I filed it off, and it stopped. On occasion, the noise or a similar one comes back but never stays.

robo hippy

Re: PM 3520A Concern (a little long)

#6

Re: PM 3520A Concern (a little long)

John Lucas

>Mine is about 2 years old and hasn't had any problems but I did have an old lathe that had a clicking noise. It turned out to be the bearings weren't parallel to each other. Don't know if you can even do that with a Powermatic but it is one possibility. The way they were pressed into my old lathe I didn't think it was possible but a machinist told be about that kind of problem so I took a chunk of wood and tapped on the edge of the bearings all the way around and the clicking went away. I was worried about damaging the bearing but it didn't happen. I would call powermatic and discuss it with them.

Re: PM 3520A Concern (a little long)

#7

Try this

DaveZ

>Look on your upper pulleys for drilled holes. Inside those there are set screws, tighten them.

I had a similar problem with my 4224, and that ended up being the culprit, hth

Re: PM 3520A Concern (a little long)

#8

Re: Try this

Gerry Meekins

>Yup, had the same problem. The soultion was the same as DaveZ's.

Tighetened up the set screws and the noise went away. (Boy it sure was annoying when I had it though.)

Gerry

Re: PM 3520A Concern (a little long)

#9

Re: PM 3520A Concern (a little long)

Roland B. Kuehn

>I also have a 3520A with a clicking problem in the headstock area. I am also and engineer and do a lot of maintenance on my own equipment of all kinds. The problem I ultimately diagnosed solved the problem. I know of 4 other people with 3520A's with the same problem and my solution corrected their problem as well. The symptoms were a click, click usually only when I was on the slow speed pulley and at fairly slow speed or when I rotated the spindle by hand. When I originally couln't find the problem I called Powermatic (WHM Tool GRoup) and recieved very good response from them. They sent a local repair man out to my house who with me checked all the things that others have mentioned, belts, alignment, set screws, bearings etc. He even filed (carefully) irregular spots on the pulleys. All to no avail. I wouldn't let him leave without a solution. I then took the lead in the trouble shooting. He maintained that it was every revolution of the spindle but we carefully checked and I proved it was every revolution of the motor shaft. We disassembled the motor and pulley and found the following. On the 3520A the motor shaft is quite long. The motor pulley has a keyway its full length but the motor shaft only has a keyway long enough for half the pulley width under the high speed half of the pulley which is also where the set screws are, so there is no support on the slow speed half of the pulley. Also the fit between the pulley and the shaft is a bit loose (maybe only a thousanth or two and not enough for a shim). So every revolution of the motor the pully clicks (moves) when on the slow speed section since there is no support where the key should be. This a poor design in that the key in the shaft does not cover the entire length of the pulley. When the belt is on the high speed section close to the motor itself the key and set screws support it so it doesn't move. The service man called the factory and had them send me a new motor pulley and belt in hopes that it would fix the problem. They also offered to come back and do the installation if I couldn't do it myself, which of course requires removing the entire spindle to get the belt on. I felt that the new pulley and belt would not solve the basic problem that there was no key under the entire width of the pulley.

So using my engineering knowledge, I concluded the solution is to provide a Key under the slow speed section of the motor pulley that didn't have one even though there was not a keyway in the motor shaft. So I took a peice of brass stock and filed it down so it would fit into the keyway of the slow speed section of the pulley. Actually this would be only a half key as there is no keyway in the shaft in this area. I made a slight taper on the brass key so when I placed it in the pulley keyway I could tap it in to take up any slack and stay in place. It has solved the problem and no more click. Therefore I have not replaced the belt or the pulley. Several other people with the same problem have solved it doing the same thing.

I know that you say that the click is every revolution of the spindle. The service man thought the same thing as did I but when we really checked it, it was every rotation of the motor shaft. There are several ways to check it. 1. rotate the spindle with the belt on the slow speed pulley tightened up good and check the click to the motor rotation. 2. loosen the belt or slide it off the pulleys and see if the click goes away if it does it is probably what I am describing. If not it may be bearings or something else. 3. Again with belt removed or loose run the motor if no click most likely it is the problem I describe. 4. place the belt on the high speed pulley section with tension on the belt, and either rotate by hand or run the motor at slow speed. If the click is not there it is most likely agian the problem I describe.

Good luck! Hope this solves your problem. I would be interested if it does. You can either post it or e-mail me at rkuehn@hargray.com