Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

An Idea For The Future

Posts

An Idea For The Future

#1

An Idea For The Future

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>With the discussion about the elm which went down on the lawn of the Whit House came an idea. Don't you hate it when people have ideas for other people to implement?

Maybe the D.C. turning club can make arrangements prior to the next tree event. It is possible that one or more members might know someone of influence. Since the club up there represents the city, they might have a better chance of getting some wood. If pieces are turned for the city or National interests and the extra is used to improve the club maybe they will have a chance of getting historic wood in the future. Some of the preservation organizations might have influence also.

Of course this approach could be used anywhere.

Re: An Idea For The Future

#2

Re: An Idea For The Future

Mark Wollschlager

>The Cap Area Woodturners had the opportunity a year or so ago to get some wood from Mt. Vernon. An Ash planted by G. Washington lost some large branches. The club was allowed to use some wood to turn pieces that were given to contributors/donors to the estate.

Any wood had to be identified in a specific way, could be signed by the turner. The turner could keep an incidental piece of wood to turn for their personal collection, not for sale. It was restrictive. And not everyone haad a chance to turn ( or even touch raw wood). There were some hurt feelings.

I was not part of the negotiations, but I understand they were extensive. ( I probably missed something....but thats it in a nutshell).

It might be better if the Renwick Gallery was part of the process of getting wood from the White House. They are right across the street and support American crafts. They might be better at dealing with the competing interests that would be involved.

mark.

Re: An Idea For The Future

#3

Re: An Idea For The Future *LINK*

Rick Allen

>Hi Barbara

We have been trying to get historic wood for many years. Wood from the Capitol, wood from the Mall, wood from the White house, wood from Mount Vernon. It was the persistent efforts of one of our club members who made the Mount Vernon opportunity possible. You would think it would be a fairly simple matter to acquire wood from these sources. But you have to put in a considerable amount of effort and participate in several meetings. The folks at the Capitol have refused to give us a meeting on the several occasions which were tried. The Park Service which maintains the trees on the Mall (between the Lincoln Memorial and the Capitol) express a "policy" which eliminates the possibility.

There were liberty Poplars in Annapolis which went out to lottery. I recall a tree in MD being taken down years ago that made the news for some desk that was made out of the tree that the governor sat behind.

Here is the real rub of the whole thing. The Mount Vernon Ash I turned was just like any other green ash I have turned. If I can't sell it as a George Washington planted wood then why go through all the grief and restrictions getting the wood.

At the same time, if the club I belong to was able to get any historical wood I would be happy to participate.

Below is a link to the web pages I made for the Mount Vernon Project I spoke of. BTW we kinda thought that we would get a LOT more wood from Mount Vernon as trees and branches come down their all the time. We have not been able to acquire any more Mount Vernon wood.

Just because we have not had sucess in the past doesn't mean that we won't have sucess in the future. We should, as a club, continue to pursue historical wood.


Mount Vernon Project

Re: An Idea For The Future

#4

Ric Taylor

Re: An Idea For The Future

Ric Taylor

>Rick,

Being a federal government worker myself, I have a feeling that you might be the recipient of a bluff. Ask the Park Service for a copy of the "policy". If there really is a policy, they have to have it published in writing. I'm not suggesting creating a big beaurocratic mess here, but if they don't provide you with a copy of the policy, tell them you will file a request through the Freedom of Information Act, which isn't that hard to do. Then they are forced to respond to you by law. Or, you might find out they really were bluffing, which opens the door to negotiations.

Failing that, having a senator or congressman on your side often opens those bolted doors. Are there any senators or congressmen who are turners or woodworkers? Probably.

When dealing with the government, ya gotta play the game by their rules, or they won't respond. They'll just ignore you with a brush-off.

I hope you have some success. It shouldn't be this hard.

Ric

Re: An Idea For The Future

#5

I moved this up from below if you missed it.

Keith Newton

>I went through this with the State of Arkansas a few years ago. There was a storm that went through a historic site, and I was trying every thing that I could think of to get some, and they were just crazy about not giving anyone some valuable asset that belonged to the state that I might profit from.

After about 50 phone calls to every connection that I had within other state agencies, and getting them to make calls on my behalf, I finally got them to let me have a few burls and stumps before they were shredded, by comparing it to the adopt a highway plan. If the state highway department can accept a person's or business help in picking up trash from alongside the highway. What is the difference if someone offers to help clean up after a storm? Anyone have a friend with the ACLU. Maybe the government needs to weigh the benefits of having free trash removal vs giving up broken vegetation. Perhaps it is time to weigh this on the scales of justice?

If I could have gotten two cubic feet of this elm tree, with the expectation that I had to produce two works from those two feet, and someone say from the Renwick could choose one for a fund-raiser auction, and I could keep the other. I would not have to think about it for a second. I am sure that there are others whose work is more cherished than mine who would match my offer.

How can such a travesty continue? The way I see it the groundskeeper just mulched a million dollar bill that could have gone to charity or the Renwick.

My two cents, Keith Newton

Re: An Idea For The Future

#6

Re: An Idea For The Future

John Lucas

>I agree with you guys 100 percent but can you see the visual image of 10 hungry woodturners showing up at the white House gates with chainsaws in hand trying to get past the guard shack. I'm sure the guys with sniper rifles would have a bead on them. I would pay to see that.

When the tornado came through here in Nashville and tore up a bunch of trees at the Hermitage(home of Pres Andres jackson) they did give the wood to some local turners who requested it. I don't know who actually did the harvesting. My friend Pat Matranga has made some good money from it. I don't know if she gave anything to the hermitage in return. I'm sure she would have volunteered to do so.

Re: An Idea For The Future

#7

Pat Matranga!

Rick Allen

>Pat Matranga!

I saw her demo in Akron back in 1998 and was very impressed with the depth of her knowledge and her gentle nature. I saw her again demo at Providence in 2002 and my impression of her was reinforced.

She is most definitely one of the top woodturners I have ever had the pleasure to see. I noticed her a couple of times in Louisville but she was just a little to far away to catch-up with and say Hi (not that she has any reason to remember me but I would have liked to thank her for the calm she helps to me achive while turning).

Re: An Idea For The Future

#8

Re: Pat Matranga!

John Lucas

>Rick I like Pat. I did see her for a short time in Louisville but apparently we didn't run into each other later. I live about 90 miles from her and see quite often when we go to the TAW meetings. I don't go much anymore because of gas prices. We have learned a lot from each other over the years and still own her old Carbo-tec.

Re: An Idea For The Future

#9

Re: Pat Matranga!

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Rick and John,

I agree a hundred percent about what a wonderful demonstrator and person that Pat is. Here's my Pat Matranga story.

I met her at the the Florida Symposium where she was a demonstrator. Somewhere I have a picture that Bob Elliot took of the two of us. Not surprisingly I have quite a silly looking grin on my face.

Someone had brought her a whole load of grapefruit wood, but she had flown in for the show. I was so enthralled by the lady that I offered to haul it back to TN for her and bring it to her in Nashville.

The end result was that I got to spend a good part of a day with her at her house. She took me out to lunch and graciously shared a number of ideas about how she markets her turnings, historical recycling being only one. She is a very nice person.

Gary