Any Negative Opinions of the Laguna Bandsaw
Tom Colligan, Peoria
>I'm considering upgrading from a Jet 14" BS. It's down to the Laguna 16"HD vs. the Rikon 18"
Would anyone have advice or opinions on either to offer? TIA, Tom.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Any Negative Opinions of the Laguna Bandsaw
Tom Colligan, Peoria
>I'm considering upgrading from a Jet 14" BS. It's down to the Laguna 16"HD vs. the Rikon 18"
Would anyone have advice or opinions on either to offer? TIA, Tom.
Re: Any Negative Opinions of the Laguna Bandsaw
Buddy Riley
>that's like comparing a Cadallic and an old chevy Vega, with the Rikkon being the Vega. One of the sellers said it was very cheap.
Re: Any Negative Opinions of the Laguna Bandsaw
Fog Tanner
>Tom, I went through the same thing. I started out with a Jet 14" with a riser block. I decided to get a larger bandsaw for the larger pieces of wood I have started acquiring. I got the video from Laguna and MiniMax on their respective saws. Both look good on tape, and they both have some nice features. The tapes were a lot better than the glossy pics in the literature or web site. And you get a walk through on all the features of their popular saws, which happens to be the 16".
The next thing I did was spend quite a bit of time looking for experieces from people that had both. I read quite a few good comments about the Minimax and a copuple about Laguna. I also found some information about the saws outside the sales literature. Both are made in Italy by good companies. The main difference is the saw that Laguna imports and brands as theirs is the "comsumer" line. The Minimax is the industrial version from the other company. I always go for the industrial version, as they are designed for more abuse.
Both are good saws, and both have a number of good features. I picked up my Minimax at a wood show in Houston and saved the delivery cost and got a good deal too. Plus I got three blades with the saw. One was a $200 carbide blade, which is hanging on the wall - its stricly for resawing and not cutting bowl blanks. I ordered four or five blades from Suffolk (Timberwolf) for cutting green wood and resawing. My only regret is having not gotten the saw sooner.
Re: Any Negative Opinions of the Laguna Bandsaw
Keith Tompkins
>Tom, check out the General 20" bandsaw. A heavy, industrial duty bandsaw. We have one at Brookfield Craft Center; reliable as an anvil. Fancy features..? No. That's a plus for me.
Get an electric chain saw for turning blanks.
Jerry Hall
>I have had a LT16HD for four years. No complaints and very satisfied. I like the ceramic guides, but some don't. They may have an advantage (over conventional guide wheels) for cutting bowl blanks especially green blanks in helping to keep the blade clear. I don't like the fact that I have to remove the blade to remove the fence. But I could fix that rare problem by metal cutting an inch off the guide-to-bar casting. I believe they have recently upgraded the LT16HD and it looks like they have a different fence system. There have been knocks on their service over the years, but I have been served VERY well and believe any customer who approaches them with a positive, lets get it solved attitude will be well served as also. I don't believe an 18" throat offers any special advantages to cutting turning rounds- you can work from the outside for larger diameters.
The most serious competition to a bandsaw for turners is a good electric chainsaw. It is safer, and easier to deal with heavy blanks. D. Ellsworth advises on his videos that he has not owned a bandsaw for years. But that is another subject.
The MiniMax line is a comparable quality alternative that you should also consider if you are considering a Laguna. I have a hunch that for the rough work of preparing turning blanks that any large band saw with good continuous rated HP would do the job and you might save yourself hundreds of $'s. Also don't spend an arm and a leg on bands. Just get inexpensive carbon steel 3/8" 3tpi skip tooth blades for cutting blanks.
Just be clear with yourself what you are going to use it for over time. But do consider an electric chain saw and a good home made horse.
A bunch of opinions FWIW!
Re: Any Negative Opinions of the Laguna Bandsaw
Jerry from Lapel In.
>I have a 18" Rikon with a Timber Wolf 3/4 3 skip tooth blade. I used the saw and same blade for over a year to saw many blanks NO PROBLEMS yet. I would buy the Rikon again.
Re: Any Negative Opinions of the Laguna Bandsaw
Russ Fairfield
>Like everyone else, I can tell you about the good experiences I had with an 18" Laguna bandsaw during the one year that I owned one of them. I enjoyed having to replace a bad motor - three (3) times. I was pleased when one of them smoked when it was new out of the box. I was happy to get a cussing out from their salesman. I was pleased when I received a personal call from the owner to tell me that he didn't understand why I was having so many problems with the bandsaw because it was the "perfect" bandsaw (his words), and that I was obviously doing something wrong because nobody else ever had a problem with their equipment. I was really happy to learn that mine was the first and only complaint they ever had, and that I was the worst and most unreasonable customer they ever had. They finally agreed to take the saw back, and I was glad that I had to pay the freight. Needless to say I am no longer on their mailing list, but I do get to tell this story many times every year.
Re: Any Negative Opinions of the Laguna Bandsaw
Kirk (KC) Constable
>Does this mean you didn't like it? :-)
I have a buddy with one, and he's never really been pleased with it. Even using good blades it's not dependable for a good cut. I suspect he hasn't spent a great deal of time tuning it up, but I also kinda think you maybe shouldn't have to.
I have the JET 18", which I got to replace a JET 14". I've never gotten 'comfortable' with the new one, and frankly, I wish I'd never made the swap.
KC
Re: Any Negative Opinions of the Laguna Bandsaw (
Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois
>Tom
I have owned a LT16 for about 10 years and the only thing I do not like is the miter slot is sized to European standards. That means it is wider and shallower than the U.S. and our miter gauges will not fit. I have had no problems with my saw.
Terry
Re: Any Negative Opinions of the Laguna Bandsaw
Rick Allen
>Come on Russ tell us what you really think(;->)
Re: Any Negative Opinions of the Laguna Bandsaw
Russ Fairfield
>I cut 3 bowl blanks and part of another on the first motor when the saw was new, none on the 2nd motot because it was DOA, I cut 4 blanks and a part of another on the 3rd motor, and I didn't get through the 1st blank with the 4th motor. From my limited experience over 10-months ownership, it was a fine saw, when it was running.
I did learn 2 things from that saw - the worst thing that can happen with a bandsaw is when the motor dies in the middle of a 12" deep cut, and it takes a month to get the smell of burning insulation out of a shop.
Re: Any Negative Opinions of the Laguna Bandsaw
Greg in Oshkosh
>I went through the comparison of the Laguna and the Minimax. I wanted a saw that could cut at least a 16" thick bowl blank on edge and these are the only two saws I could find. Most others just cut 12" deep and I can already do that with the Delta and riser block.
Prices for the two saws are similar. I chose the Minimax 20" saw because 20" is better than 16" for really thick cuts. I performs well. I did have some minor issues with the saw initially(parts missing) but they quickly got them to me. I think the Minimax saw is heavier built and is a better buy in this price range.
Re: Any Negative Opinions of the Laguna Bandsaw
robo hippy
>I have had my Laguna 16HD for about a year and a half, and it is the second best Christmas present I have given myself, the first being my PM3520. I use Lennox 1 1/4 resawing blade with teeth 3/4 apart (about $60. The only real problem I have is with the dust collection port. I cut my blanks on end, cutting parallel to the grain which results in lots of long shavings. The dust port comes with a metal cross hair grate to keep you from sticking your hand in there. This would instantly plug up. I cut it out, and that helped a bit, but the long shavings still plug up the bottom and go all through the saw, even around the post of the upper guide blocks which does interfere with the post movement. Some day, I will put in a 5 inch port for dust collection to see if that helps some more. It isn't my dust collectors fault, I have an Oneida 3hp system. I have thought about removing the upper wheel and seeing if I can put some sort of plate behind it to keep the shavings out. Any cuts on dry wood, and the sawdust all goes out easily.
robo hippy
Re: Any Negative Opinions of the Laguna Bandsaw
John Lucas
>Russ I have worked in the photo industry forever. We have very few problems with process or camera repairs getting lost of damaged or whatever. The odd part is it always happens to the same person. We would have maybe 5 lost rolls of film a year and 2 of them would be to the same person. This would be out of several thousand rolls.
we had the same thing happen on a lost camera sent in for repair. As far as I know we only had 2 in all the years I worked at that store and it was the same guy. I have a lady I work with now who ran her own photo store and she said they had noticed the same thing.
Hope your luck has been better with other things.
Funny you should mention it
Bill Howatt
>When I worked in administration in a company with about 2000 employees we used to say "how strange it was that some people always seemed to be the victims the of the screw-ups". It wasn't their fault either.
Bill
Re: Any Negative Opinions of the Laguna Bandsaw
Russ Fairfield
>John,
Luck has nothing to do with it. This is not a lottery. I pays my money, in this case $3000, and I expect to receive a machine that runs. Laguna couldn't make that happen. There are other manufacturers who can, and do.
The question was asked, "Any negative opinions of the Laguna bandsaw?" I apologize for answering the wrong question. The opinion I expressed was not of the saw, but of the personnel who run Laguna; and that question was not asked.
Re: Funny you should mention it
Mark Mandell - Gone Round in Jersey
>"Karma," Dudes!
Russ and others obviously need to get in touch with their Inner Alien, find a couch to jump on (and off of), and find a would-be actress to impregnate, all so that they can purge the "paybacks" being levied upon their current incarnations.
On the other hand, I didn't type this Response; you, Gentle Reader, only think I did.
Now where did I leave that damn blue feather?
mm
ps: Russ, 'tis not a conspiracy, "They" are not out to get you.
|;-}
Hey Russ
Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont
>You know I have looked at the Laguna's now for a number of years...and the same thing always happens....I hear your story in the back of my head and I walk away from the booth....
:-)
Take care,
Jim
Two of the most experienced guys in our club
Charlie Anderson
>have Lagunas and which they had gotten Grizzly's!
No Way
Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont
>Hey Keith,
A 20" General, whoo hoo, nice green colour too, eh! I have the 15" General 490, the only wish I have is greater resaw, it's less than 7" and I could really enjoy twice that.....but it's a cast body. What is the resaw on your 20" machine Keith?
Take Care,
Jim
Re: No Way
Keith Tompkins
>HI Jim, great to meet you at the symposium! the General is at the school, not here, so I can't measure. It's at least 12" though. That's my dream saw...would match the lathe, of course.
Re: Any Negative Opinions of the Laguna Bandsaw
john lucas
>Russ I was joking of course. For $3000 I would drive my car to the headquarters to get satisfaction. I certainly feel your agravation on that one.
Re: Two of the most experienced guys in our club
Steve Worcester
>I now own my second Laguna, an LT24 which was a custom to accomodate 24" resaw, standard on them now. I had an LT16HD for several years before that. (And two Deltas before that, all have been resold, and all were upgrades to the next)
In the past, Laguna by their own admission had horrible support. I have talked with several people at shows about how poor their support was, including Torbin. I have to say it has gotten way better. Perfect, probably not, but they do listen.
I burned up the import motor on my 24 after about a year and they replaced it with the Baldor they use now.
The LT16HD that you cut the center out of the port is exactly what I did. The 24 also has similar problems, especially with cutting big logs on end grain orientation. I put in an additional port under the table, and that helps, but not eleviates the problem.
No question in my mind........
Greg Deavers
>Check out the ad for a 4 year old Laguna 16hd, at a decent price.
Not sure what kind of motor it has. Or, for a new one you can spend $1000 more and get all the "current" goodies thrown in from Laguna.
So, if you are wanting a "general" all around saw, there are certainly less expensive investments.
Now, If you want a PRECISION 13" RESAW capacity for veneering, book matching, minimal wasted material - NO QUESTION. I personally would NOT take another saw for my 1 year old LT16HD!
Motor problems????
I do not trust ANY foreign motors....
My saw came with a Baldor Motor upgrade (SMART MONEY). You can't stop this saw in the thick hard stuff.... Mesquite, Purple Heart, Osage, dry Sycamore, Walnut, etc - at least I haven't, it has performed flawlessly.
Customer service: responded admirably with a new "sticker" and some paint to cover a "rub" from shipping.
Hope this info helps you out.
Greg
Mini Max Alternative
David L.
>Tom,
I just went through the same thing earlier this month. I started looking at the Rikon and the Jet 18" but after a lot of research, ringing, and imputs from forum members i decided to step up to either the Laguna 16HD or Mini Max MM16. Both are excellent saws and both are on sale for the month of June. When you start comparing the saws they are almost exactly the same in specifications so the decision was pretty tough. I finally decided on the Mini Max, for a couple of reasons:
1. I did not like the idea of the sparks produced by the Laguna guides, they say they are cold sparks but i just can't imagine sucking sparks up into my dust collector.
2. The MM16 is heavier, more cast iron.
3. The MM16 is a little cheaper this month.
4. Erik at MM seemed very honest about their saw, high points and low points. Other vendors sales staffs were quick to knock the competitor and hesitant to discuss shortcomings of their product.
The MM16 arrived and is cleaned and running. What a fantastic saw, i would have never believed the difference compared to my Jet 14 without actually experienceing it. Very solid, unbelievable power and excellent fit and finish.
If you have any detailed questions feel free to ask.
Dave