We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I collected a few nice bits of birch, which the railway people had cut behind my house. Cut a few blanks (approx 7 by 2 inches). First bowl, turned green, warped so much that no re-turning would fix it. Second blank was dried in my microwave, following the prescribed procedure thoroughly, and it promptly cracked beyond repair. I left the third blank in my workshop (warm and dry) to dry in the air and it cracked after a few days. I was sick and tired of all this by now. Fourth blank: left it burried in a small pile of dry shavings for a month, during which time it lost half of its moisture. Then left it in open air for another two weeks and it was quite dry and ready to be turned. EASY. NO CRACKS! My question: has someone have any experience with this method of drying wood by leaving it burried in dry shavings for a while?
>Sure. However, you will greatly increase your chances of success if you rough-turn them first, leaving them thick (so you'll have enough wood to work with when they're oval), bevel the edges a bit, and avoiding the pith. Then dry them as slowly as you can. When I rough turn a batch of bowls, I just huck 'em into a cardboard box, probably 4 - 8 small ones per box, then I close up the box and check on them and stir them around once a week or so -- maybe once a month.
Even better results can be had by waxing the bowls, or at least the end grain, with either paste wax or a liquid wax solution like Anchorseal. This will slow, but not stop, the drying. Also, please keep in mind that there may be nothing you can do about the cracks already in the wood -- some you can't see without a very close look. Once cracks start, they will usually continue as the wood dries -- much better to turn away any cracks, or throw away any cracked wood.
One problem you have is a hot, DRY shop. This is a very bad environment for drying bowl blanks. If you can find a cooler spot, away from sunlight, heat, wind, etc... you'll have a better success rate. Often a bare concrete floor is significantly cooler and more moist than a higher shelf or level in a room. Some people dry stuff on the garage floor for a few weeks or months, then up on a low shelf for a spell, then up on a top shelf nearer the ceiling where its likely to be hotter and dryer.
>Brad gave you quite a good program to improve the "save" rate that you experience with your wood.
One reason some of us have so much trouble with the green wood that we collect is that we are exposing the wood to tremendous stress without really meaning to.
The measure of how much stress the wood is subjected to is the difference between the current Moisture Content of the wood and the Relative Humidity plus temperature that you are subjecting it to. The RH and Temp determine the Equilibrium Moisure Content. The greater the difference between the current MC and the EMC, the more stress that the wood is exposed to.
Now, some woods are more sensitive to stress than others. If you use the density of a particular wood as a measure of its relative strength, you can get a pretty good feel for which woods might be difficult. Since birch has a fairly low density, you could expect it to crack more rapidly when exposed to a given level of stress than, say, black locust, which is considerably denser.
Bottom line is get an idea of the moisture content of your wood and adjust the RH and temp where you store it so that you are being more friendly to your wood.
>I'm afraid I have not been clear enough about what I wanted to say. So I'll repeat:
- The first bowl deformed BEYOND re-turning, meaning that the difference between long and short diameter was much larger than the thickness of the walls of the bowl, which was approx 3/4 of an inch.
- I do not want to rough turn, dabble in god knows what chemistry, then wait months, then re-turn. All this is pain in the butt.
- I do not want to wait months: life is quite short.
- I do not want my workshop to look like a chemist's shop. It is WOODturning and not chemistry games; never mind the hazards associated with all those products.
- I don't care about all those acronyms (HR, EMC, MC, whatnot...): it sounds like a physics lesson. I want to turn wood and not have a degree in physics. All I want to know is whether the wood is dry enough to be turned without deforming afterwards.
- I was suggesting a method that is QUICK, EASY, DOES NOT REQUIRE ANY CHEMICAL PRODUCT, and WORKS IN A DRY WORKSHOP. The basic principle is that the dry shavings, in which the blank is buried, work as a barrier between the too dry air in the workshop and the wet blank.
Perhaps I got up on the wrong side of the bed this morning, but your response to Brad seems terribly rude. He was just trying to share the method that works for him.
To answer one point, you insist on a method that is QUICK, but in your first post, you stated that it took 6 weeks before the blank was ready to turn. I'm not sure I would put that in the quick category.
There is nothing wrong with the method you've outlined, but getting moisture out of wood without having it crack is, by nature, (no pun intended) a time consuming process. Be aware that other species, as well as thicker blanks will take longer than the birch to dry sufficiently. Calculating the moisture content when you first get the wood and then keeping track of the weight would at least give you a means of monitoring the progress of a particular blank.
I apologize for my earlier comment if you weren't intending to be rude to Brad.
>My purpose it to be clear, not to offend. If someone finds my texts rude, it maybe because I prefer to be blunt and to the point: I never saw the interest of beating around the bush.
Six weeks is OK with me, compared with the six MONTHS people speak of when the rough turned bowl is waxed.
>Let's keep this discussion in perspective, and remember what we are trying to do - dry wood with the minimum of degrade and cracking.
The secret to drying wood is to allow the moisture to evaporate at a rate that maintains a uniform moisture throughout the thickness of the wood, and everywhere throughout the piece of wood, while it is drying. There are three (3) ways that we can do this. We can provide a barrier that slows the evaporation from the surface of the wood. We can chemically form a solution with the moisture in the wood that has different properties from water, and then deal with that new material as something that is different from water. Still another is to provide an absorbtion medium around the wood.
There are a lot of ways to absorb the moisture out of the wood. We can use a disiccants that are recoverable or we can use materials that will absorb moisture. Burying the wet wood in wet sawdust or shavings and waiting for the sawdust to dry is one way to dry bowls with an absorbant material, and it works. It is probably the oldest known attempt to keep bowls from cracking, and it is described in woodturning texts from the 1800's. There is always a problem with mildew, and black stain on light colored woods is always a problem.
We can solve the staining problem with dry sawdust as the absorbant, but my experience has been that doing this allows the bowl to dry too fast and there is a signicantly greater loss than with the wet sawdust.
There are other things that can be used to accomplish the absorbtion of the moisture. We can use wheat, rolled oats, and cornmeal to do the same thing, and they all work fairly well. None of them are cheap unless you live on a farm. Burying the wood in the wheat bin works the best because of the uniform weight and contact of the grain against the wood. I have used Silica Gel for small things with good results. Dry sand works if we are willing to keep it turned over regularly, and the weight of the sand will reduce deformation during drying.
Some folks use barriers to slow the evaporation from the surface. We are all familiar with using paper bags as a barrier to the free evaporation of the moisture from the wood surface. There are others who seal the wood in a wax. Still others have built drying rooms or boxes (a dry kiln) where they can control the humidity, and therefore the rate of evaporation of moisture from the surface. And, there are those of us who live in a climate that allows us to throw the bowls in the corner of the shop and forget about them until they are dry.
Some folks like to experiment with chemically replacing the moisture in the wood with a solution that has properties that are different from the moisture that it replaces. Denatured Alcohol is the most recent of these. I am sure there will be others in the future.
Always remember what we are trying to do. The goal is a uniform moisture through the thickness of the wood as it dries. Rapid evaporation from the surface, means less moisture and more shrinkage on the surface or in some areas than others. That differential shrinkage causes a tensile stress in the wood, and wood under tension will either move or crack when it can't.
It is easy to get involved with "our" drying techniques, and forget that there is is no right or wrong way to dry wood. There are just different ways to do it. Some methods take longer than others, and some woods respond better to one drying method than another; but the result is the same. We choose the one that works for us, and sometimes we use just use the one that appeals to our way of thinking. Our decision is often influenced by the price we have to pay for our wood. My choice is throwing the bowls in the corner and forgetting about them until they are dry and accepting whatever losses I get, but I would consider doing something different if I were buying wood.
I have spent a fair amount of time drying bowls using various methods, most of which have already been listed. If you have the time read, the information I have put on my Alcohol Soaking blog. There is no chemistry knowledge required, and the process is simple. If you use shellac you are already exposed to the same chemical used in the drying process. I recently documented the drying of a white oak bowl that was dry in less than 2 weeks and can be returned to the lathe with wall thickness to spare. I will post final pictures tody.
There are hundreds of turners, that I know of, that are using this process with excellent results. It is nearly sailor proof. The bottom line is that there is nothing free in this world. You have to spend time learning or you can waste time roughing bowls that will be burned when they are dry.
Dave Smith
Still have haze gray memories, USS Enterprise CVAN-65, in Longview, WA.
I've copied your response below, and here are my responses, preceeded by asterisks (***), between your text:
-- Quote sarts here --
I'm afraid I have not been clear enough about what I wanted to say. So I'll repeat:
- The first bowl deformed BEYOND re-turning, meaning that the difference between long and short diameter was much larger than the thickness of the walls of the bowl, which was approx 3/4 of an inch.
*** That's some real movement ! The bowl just wasn't left thick enough. How thick depends on the type of wood. You can get much of this info from a chart of shrinkage for the more common species, or learn it by experience. Hint: Apple and Beech move a LOT.
- I do not want to rough turn, dabble in god knows what chemistry, then wait months, then re-turn. All this is pain in the butt.
*** Rough-turning is the best part (except maybe making tops for kids, or giving a piece as a gift), as green turning is, IMHO, a lot more pleasant that turning dry wood. No need to wait months when weeks will do -- however, be careful -- the faster you dry them, the more likely they are to crack. No chemistry involved in rough-turning and THEN packing in shavings, and that will take a LOT less time than drying a solid blank. That's what I meant to recommend if that works for you. Another however -- you will find that some methods will work very well for White Birch, or Black Walnut, but will fail miserably on Apple, Beech, Lilac, or a wood that's more difficult to dry.
- I do not want to wait months: life is quite short.
*** Well, the wait will depend on the species, the thickness, etc... There are tried and true methods that almost always work, and then there are all sorts of scattershot approaches that will sometimes work. Dry shavings seems to work well for the Birch you have in your shop, but it might not work for all woods.
- I do not want my workshop to look like a chemist's shop. It is WOODturning and not chemistry games; never mind the hazards associated with all those products.
*** I assume you are responding to someone else's post here, since I agree with you.
- I don't care about all those acronyms (HR, EMC, MC, whatnot...): it sounds like a physics lesson. I want to turn wood and not have a degree in physics. All I want to know is whether the wood is dry enough to be turned without deforming afterwards.
** Again, I didn't use any of these (though some are helpful to understand). Its very simple: when it stops losing weight, it's dry. With experience, you'll know how long to wait in your shop without weighing a thing.
- I was suggesting a method that is QUICK, EASY, DOES NOT REQUIRE ANY CHEMICAL PRODUCT, and WORKS IN A DRY WORKSHOP. The basic principle is that the dry shavings, in which the blank is buried, work as a barrier between the too dry air in the workshop and the wet blank.
*** I suppose this is the offensive part ... you started out asking for opinions on a bowl drying method, and now you seem to be yelling at all the experienced responses you got, and lecturing those who are trying to help. You seem you have climbed the steep learning curve very quckly, and have been imparted the wisdom of the ages. Here's some free advice you didn't ask for: some people on this list have successfully made thousands of bowls from fresh-cut wood, and I gather you have made just a few. You might do well to consider that a few of us have learned from some of our own mistakes and experiences, and simply want to help you learn without having to repeat our failures.
*** The best resource I know of for dealing with local log wood is an excellent book called "Turning Green Wood", by Michael O'Donnell, published by GMC. It has excellent instructions and illustrations, and has very good details about drying rough-turned bowls in the microwave (which does require a bit of trial and error for each species. If you are unwilling to invest a little time now that may save you a lot of grief later, you might consider that wood is not plastic, nor is it metal. You are now working with a medium that lacks a homogenous structure, sometimes has some serious attitude, and must be dealt with on its own terms. If this doesn't work for you, I see three options: 1) spend lots of money and turn kiln-dried wood exclusively (never enjoying the dust-free joy of green turning); 2) Keep turning green wood with mixed success, while flaming those who take their time to try to help (which won't make you many friends on this forum); 3) Get a new hobby and turn metal or plastic, which behave a lot more predictably than wood.
>I too was frustrated by the rough turning then having to dry the bowl system. I solved this by building me a kiln out of an old upright freezer, 2 light bulbs and a fan. I now cut my blanks, wax the ends and dry them in the kiln before I turn. Depending on the weather (humidity/temperature) and moisture content of the blanks this takes about 4 - 6 weeks. Just suits me better to turn dry wood than go through all the rough turning/dry systems. The kiln cost me about $40 total as I already had the freezer ( note: cost did not include the new freezer purchase for the house to replace the brokern one!! LOL) I still will loose a piece now and then to a hidden crack or warping due to stress relief but that is very few in number. Let me know if you want more details in how to build.
I thought he was talking to you, but I wonder if we're not dealing with a kid here. That's the tone that I caught. "I don't like what you're telling me, I want things to be my way, or I'm going to be mad!"
Anyway, not worth worrying about. Hope to see you in Louisville,
>Wilford, I'm interested in the 'fan' part of it. I have an old side-by-side fridge that I use for a kiln. Lightbulbs in each side, air holes in bottom and top, but no fan. How'd ya do the fan thing?
I picked up a bath room exhaust fan at the local lumber yard for about $14. This fan is made to take moisture so I figured it could handle the heat and moisture in the kiln. I mounted it to the back wall and bottom shelf at about a 45 degree angle pointed up(made to blow into a 4 inch or so pipe so discharge can be aimed) - this keeps the air swirling and does not let it fail to blow over the shelf edges. Just wired it into a 110 circuit and light switch.
>Hey Wilford, this is great! That is exactly the system that suits my mindset: cheap, fast, no re-turning. I have seen other people's "drying boxes": the only difference is that they build their box instead of using an old fridge. Works great; I think that is what I'll do myself.
Thanks a lot for your complete and thorough answer. Yes, you are the only one to actually answer my question, which was "Has anyone tried to dry blanks by burying them in dry shavings?" I also appreciate your point about the difference between using dry and wet shavings. The historic review was also very helpful. All in all, I enjoyed reading you.
>I like old dishwashers. The venting is already designed into it, there are no holes to cut, there is no need for a fan, there is no messy insulation to contend with, it fits under a workbench or counter, and it is easier to carry home.
This is going to be a bit long, so please be patient. There are several points I would like to make.
To start with, I was purposefully provocative, in order to test the reaction of people on this forum. The result is excellent: I can now know who takes it easy and who does not. There are those that put themselves on the pedestal of being old hands, very experienced (�thousands of bowls�), and seem to snub us the poor beginners; yes, they give us free advice (and often very good one), but expect us to pay back in respect and humility. Humble I am not; very few people have my respect and they have earned it the hard way. In other terms, it is not the relative experience in a particular field that determines the respect. Being patronising and condescending is not the way to get my respect. All this seems offensive to you, doesn�t it? Well, take it easy�
Secondly, I asked a clear question and nobody seemed to want to answer it. Let�s look at my first post: I wrote �Has someone had any experience with this method of drying wood by leaving it buried in dry shavings for a while?� Well, guess what: only Russ Fairfield answered this question, and in a spectacularly good way. Everyone else gave me their way of drying rough-turned bowls (and not of blanks, important distinction); I can find this information on thousands of web sites. Frankly, your first answer to my first post was informative and thorough, but did not answer my question nor told me something I didn�t know: I was disappointed and screamed in response. Someone got offended? I�ll have to live with it�
Now to your �free advice� I didn�t ask for: everyone will make their own mistakes. This is a fact, fate. Advice can help a bit, but there is nothing like personal experience. What did the other guy say? �Wise men learn from their mistakes; geniuses learn from other people�s mistakes.� (Or something of the sort; you get my point, I hope.) One can learn from turning ten bowls what another will not learn from turning thousand bowls. Again, this seems offensive and disrespectful? Ah well, so be it�
I�d like to add a point of my own: woodturning is a simple process. I repeat: a simple process. It is not rocket science. It is not science to start with: it�s a craft. The basic concepts are few and simple and can be understood by anyone with high school education. Yes, wood is a heterogeneous material in three dimensions with variables such as humidity, density, and texture. When we consider that some of these vary in time, this makes at maximum a seven-dimensional system. How complicated is all this? I hate to add more to my image of someone arrogant, big-headed, and pretentious, but I�m afraid I learned to turn very quickly. Yes, I agree that once the first steep bit of the learning curve is behind me, I�ll make the real big errors. Yes, the drivers with most accidents are those with just enough experience to make them think they are good. I accept this inevitability.
Let me tell you about the first and only instructor I�ve had. He was not wearing any eye, face, or lungs protection (and didn�t offer any to me, neither); there was no dust extraction system in his workshop. Agreed, he was better than me at that time and had much more experience; do you think I respect him? Well, I�m not an idiot: once I set up a workshop of my own, I built a very good dust extraction system; I ALWAYS wear a face shield and the best dust mask money can buy around here. You see, I learn�
Finally, I would like to comment on your three suggestions:
1. I will never buy wood: it seems to me obscene to pay for wood. Friends, family, neighbours, colleagues, the local builder, anyone: they all have bits of wood they don�t need and will give me for free.
2. I don�t quite see your point here: For whatever reason I enjoy turning dry wood and am not interested in green wood. I have tried turning green wood and yes, its cuts smoothly and effortlessly, but the satisfaction for me ends here. Will I change my mind? Is my inexperience showing here? Maybe.
3. You suggest I change hobby and disappear from this forum? Interesting; very welcoming. It is also very interesting that you suggest I turn metal. In fact, I�m quite proficient with metal turning. Coming from a family of mechanics and engineers, understanding metal is natural to me. But don�t get me wrong: I do understand wood and enjoy working it.
Well, I�ll end by saying that I have nothing against anyone on this forum, on the contrary: people have been helpful and offered their grain of salt willingly; I do appreciate this.
>Displacement is a process where the moisture in the wood is replaced by another material that prevents shrinkage and collapse of the cell walls in the wood. PEG is such a material. A thinned mixture of a drying oil and varnish will do the same thing in this sections. And, there are those who advocate using a Liquid Dishwashing Detergent (LDD) to displace the moisture in the wood. I am sure that someone will discover something else. It could be argued that filling the wood with an acrylic plastic, a process we call stabilization, is a similar process with a harder material.
Someone mentioned using a Microwave Oven for drying the wood. Microwave drying is still the same process of evaporation of the moisture from the surface of the wood. The difference is that the wood is internally heated to create a driving force to move the moisture to the surface more rapidly than natural evaporation.
Heat always helps any drying process because heated air will hold more moisture, and therefore the evaporation from the surface of the wood is faster.