Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Grinding Radius Skews

Posts

Grinding Radius Skews

#1

Grinding Radius Skews

RK in Milw

>Because I teach a skew class at the local Woodcraft, I need a faster way to shape tools for students. Invariably, students show up with tools that are either horribly sharpened or tools that have been purchased the day of the class. The Tormek is great for final sharpening and maintaining the edge, but it doesn't remove metal fast enough for initial shaping. Another consideration is that not all students are going to buy a Tormek, so I wanted to present an easy to build solution that students can use at home.

Tormek jigs are the best I have found. They have the only jig for skews that handle not only oval skews, but also grind a perfect radius on a skew. I got to thinking that it would be great to have the best of both worlds.

I finished this setup last night and tested it and it works perfectly. This setup uses the same geometry as the Tormek but you get the speed of a normal grinder to boot.

The grinder shown is the cheap grinder that Woodcraft sells. You can see that the grinder is configured for the Wolverine jigs and they are still mounted and used. The distance from the base of the grinder to the center of the arbor is 6 1/4" as specified by Wolverine.

To mimick the geometry of the Tormek, the base of the tool rest holder (Tormek XB-100) must be 1 5/8" above the center of the grinder arbor. Therefore the pedestal for tool rest holder is 7 3/8" high on my setup. My baseboard is 24" long by 11" wide and 1 1/2" thick. The center of the pedestal is 12" from the center of the grinder. I have tested the Tormek SVS-50 skew jig and the SVD-185 gouge jig. Just about any Tormek jig should work on this setup. Consult the Tormek owners manual for actual setup of all Tormek jigs. Note that the guard on the grinder had to be cut back a bit.

Parts list: XB-100 Horizontal Base for Universal Tool Support (19.95) Micro Adjust Universal Tool Support (31.95) HB-10E Tormek Owners Manual (16.95)

I make no claims for the efficacy or safety of this setup. I hope this helps any of you that have frustrations with current sharpening systems. Feel free to repost as an article.

See you all in L'ville and at lunch on Friday.

Ron Nelson.


img

Re: Grinding Radius Skews

#2

Re: Grinding Radius Skews pic 2 

RK in Milw

>


img

Re: Grinding Radius Skews

#3

Re: Grinding Radius Skews pic 3 

RK in Milw

>


img

Re: Grinding Radius Skews

#4

Re: Grinding Radius Skews - clarification

RK in Milw

>The pedestal height of 7 3/8" places the center of the Universal Tool Support 1 5/8" above the center of the grinder arbor.

The pink grinding wheel shown in the photos will be replaced with a coarser grit. The pink wheel (120 grit if I remember correctly) heats the metal too fast and loads up quickly.

Ron Nelson

Re: Grinding Radius Skews

#5

JL

Re: Thanks for the idea..

JL

>now I have to decide whether or not I need a radius skew. OK - do I really need one? How is this an advantage over my oval skews? I use them for skimming and planing cuts and doing beads.

Re: Grinding Radius Skews

#6

Re: Grinding Radius Skews

john lucas

>Ron Cool idea. I think there was a hand made round tool rest adaptor for grinders in one of my Shop Notes magazines that might be easier for students to build and of course cheaper than the Tormek adaptor. I will go look this morning and see if I can find it. Might take a little digging and I have to work today so if I don't find it this morning I'll look tonight.

Re: Grinding Radius Skews

#7

The manual may be downloaded... *LINK*

Clem Wixted

>...at the link below. Look to to left when you get to the page and there is a TORMEK HANDBOOK selection.

Clem


Site for Tormek Handbook

Re: Grinding Radius Skews

#8

Re: Grinding Radius Skews

john lucas

>It wasn't in shopnotes or woodsmith magazine. Who knows where I saw that. It was basically a bar that ran the full length of the grinder and pivoted at the bottom. I don't remember the details of the tool rest that fit on the bar. Maybe someone else will remember this. I have most every magazine on the market but thier index's suck and you can't usually find anything. Wood magazine's index is fair.

Re: Grinding Radius Skews

#9

Re: Thanks for the idea..

RK in Milw

>Hi JL

There are three main advantages to using a skew with a radius edge. They are easier to use when making a planing cut and a finishing cut. Also, you can cut coves with a radius skew. The radius shape minimizes the chance of a catch. The tip of a radius skew is 90 degrees to the body and that is great for cutting tenons.

All of my skews are ovals but I have one straight skew and one radius skew in each of the two sizes I use. I highly recommend Alan Lacers video as a reference for skew technique.

The most difficult thing to learn to do with a skew is to roll beads. The key is to always make sure that you are arcing into the cut to stay on the bevel. Never push into the cut when rolling a bead.

Ron Nelson

Re: Grinding Radius Skews

#10

Re: Grinding Radius Skews

Jeff Farris

>While this may sound like a great idea, consider carefully before you "rough shape" on a dry grinder. Even HSS (high speed steel) can be damaged by heat. While it may not lose its temper, like carbon steel, it can become very brittle. Despite what you may see in videos and demonstrations, quenching HSS in water once it is hot is usually counter-productive.

My personal opinion, and that of TORMEK management is that little time can be gained by rough grinding on a dry grinder, if it is done correctly. If you proceed at a pace that avoids excessive heat, you will spend approximately the same amount of time that you would spend at a TORMEK.

While reshaping a tool, particularly a skew, you can speed the shaping process on your TORMEK by following a few simple suggestions.

1) Work with the Universal Support in the vertical position, so that the wheel is turning into the cutting edge. The grindstone cuts much more aggressively while turning into the edge.

2) Grade the stone aggressively and frequently with the coarse side of the stone grader. If you see any build-up of black or red matter on the stone surface, it is not cutting efficiently. Efficient and fast cutting can be reactivated by cleaning the stone with the stone grader. Use firm pressure. Also, the corner of the grader will cut the stone faster than the flat surface of the grader.

3) Don't be afraid to apply considerable pressure against the grindstone with the tool. If you have learned to sharpen on dry grinders, this will be hard to do, since you have been trained to use a light touch. But we don't have any chance for heat build-up. Firm pressure will speed the removal of steel from your tool. If your TORMEK slows dramatically when you apply firm pressure, your drive wheel has become glazed. Remove the honing wheel and rough up the surface of the drive wheel with coarse sandpaper.

If you are shaping a side grind or fingernail grind gouge, please ignore suggestion #1 above or do it very carefully. Gouges can groove the grindstone pretty quickly with the wheel turning into the edge, particularly at the large edge angles typically ground on bowl gouges. I do gouges in the horizontal position, with firm pressure applied to the grindstone and I vary my position on the stone frequently to avoid grooving the stone.

Re: Grinding Radius Skews

#11

Re: Grinding Radius Skews

RK in Milw

>Hi Jeff,

I know all of the tricks and tips with regards to the Tormek. I am just as much of a Tormek evangelist as you are and I don't make a dime from it. The Tormek has serious limitations when it comes to removing larges amounts of metal required to properly shape a gouge or a skew. I did shape my first radiused skews on my Tormek and it took 3 or more hours each. I went through a stone in less than a years time shaping tools that way. As you know, the Tormek stone was formulated for flat blades like plane blades. As grinding stones go, the Tormek stone is pretty darned soft.

Peter Child in England is now selling a harder stone for the Tormek for turning tools and I may give that a try. But with my setup using Tormek Jigs on a high speed grinder, initial shaping of a new fingernail grind on a gouge, or putting a radius edge on a skew now takes minutes, not hours. Going to the Tormek for final sharpening and edge maintenance... well, as I said, I now have the best of both worlds.

The weakness in the Wolverine system is that they can't tell you how to set up for a 35 degree angle nor can they explain how to get a particular finegrnail shape. You are supposed to take a $65 bowl gouge and figure it out for yourself by trial and error. In fact, the instructions for the Vari-Grind are backwards. I did figure out how to get the Vari-Grind to work properly by back engineering from the Tormek setup. Total cost of setup on a Vari-Grind for my students is now the price of a length of 3/8" dowel.

Metallurigical theory aside, thousands of turners sharpen on a high speed grinder with no ill effects to their high speed steel. There is no logical or practical reason not to use a high speed grinder for initial shaping. The cost of a Tormek and accessories is pretty high. You can buy a very good table saw for that kind of money. A lot of people can't or won't justify that kind of expense for a sharpening set up. I will say that in the classes I teach where students get to experience a tool sharpened on the Tormek, the rate of sales goes way up. If I were you, I'd be at the woodworking shows and at the AAW convention with a lathe set up and some properly sharpened tools for folks to try on a piece of spinning wood.

It is with turning tools that the Tormek really lives up to it's maximum potential. Turners need to sharpen constantly. My Tormek is my most frequently used tool other than the lathe itself. If I wuz making or selling Tormek systems, I would come up with a stone optimized for turning tools. Then I would sit down with some people like me who use the system to the max and get some ideas for improvements to some of the accessories. The jig for sharpening parting tools is pathetic given the brilliance that is inherent in the rest of the system. My solution was the cost of three scrap pieces of wood 3 inches long by 1 5/8 inches wide and a bit of superglue.

Jeff, thanks for widening the discussion. You have a great company with great service and a very helpful website. Hope I run into you real soon; if not, then at the Woodworking show in Milwaukee.

Ron Nelson

Re: Grinding Radius Skews

#12

Re: Grinding Radius Skews

Jeff Farris

>My concern with your system, Ron, is that people may get the idea that they have to have both a TORMEK and a dry grinder to get where they want to go, and that simply is not the case. I stand by my earlier statement that if you use a TORMEK correctly and compare it to a dry grinder used correctly that the "time to grind" advantage that a dry system would have is marginal. If someone is trying to decide between the two options I do not want them to think that they will HAVE to get a dry grinder if they decide to take advantage of TORMEK's advantages.

I have had a lathe by my side to show the advantages of a truly sharp turning tool at every Woodworking Show for the last 13 years. I exhibited at the AAW conference for many years and would to this day if not for a competitive agreement.

There are two completely distinct processes involved with the grinding of turning tools. Shaping the tool and Sharpening the tool. If any advantage can be given to a dry system it would be in shaping, but that should be a once in a lifetime process for a tool while sharpening will be done every 15 to 20 minutes for the rest of the tools useful life. I thank you for your evangelism as it relates to the sharpening of turning tools. I just joined the discussion to be sure that people do not get the mistaken impression that a dry grinder is a necessary supplement to a TORMEK sharpening system.