Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Lacer hone - good value?

Posts

Lacer hone - good value?

#1

Lacer hone - good value?

Ed Moore

>I am considering stopping by Alan Lacer's booth in Louisville and purchasing one of his new diamond hones. My question is simple: Are they worth $88? That's the price shown on his website. So far I have not been able to get my 1 3/8" Lacer skew "scary sharp" and wonder if this hone is capable of doing that.

I seek input from those who have the recent Lacer hone.

Thanks

Ed

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

#2

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

jared

>hello: I have one of the lacer hones and it works good. The rounded edges are real handy to get the inside edges of the bowl gouge touched up. I think it is supposed to be about a 600 grit equivalent. YOu can also use the flat sides to sharpen anything else, knives , carving tools, etc. I spent a day with Alan Lacer in his shop about 18 months ago. I learned a lot about the use of his skew which I have since purchased both a large and small one. HE has a real nice shop and house near River Falls Wi, just east of St Paul Mn. We also turned a bowl and I picked up some good tips from him on the use of a bowl gouge too. If you get a chance his private lessons are well worth the cost, which are quite reasonable in my mind. River Falls is a neat town too. Alan also has a nice collection of turned tops, and all sorts of turned objects in his house. Jared Herbert

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

#3

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

john lucas

>I think they sell the same thing in my local knife shop for $39. I'm going to try to get by and look closer to see if they are the same.

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

#4

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

Greg H. from Wisconsin

>I'm fortunate, I live 1 hour from Alan. I have been to his shop and house for classes, PRICELESS. Incredible.

A few notes. Honestly. If you are using a fine or 600 diamond hone like the ones from Craft Supplies $26, and not getting your skew sharp, Alan's won't change that. The difference with Alan's, BOTH flats are coated, the others aren't, you do have to round profiles for gouges, etc. Those are made and coated somewhere in IL. I believe, for Alan. The coating is better than the others. My opinion, if you can afford one, YES its worth it. You have two flats, ($26 times 2, 52, plus the profiles that aren't on anything else, say 15 dollars worth, a better coating. It's really not badly priced, it ain't cheap, but it does have value. I have both, the cheap and Alan's. I like his better.

But as far as your skew, either should sharpen it. A few things to consider, Facets-if you have multiple or even two facets on the grind you'll sharpen the back and the facet only, not the edge. If you have one facet, check for glint, the reflection of light on the dulled edge, if you have alot, grind lightly, a little, hone it. Also the grind should be 1 and a half times the thickness of the steel, fatter skews longer grinds, etc. That will help getting the "base" for the hone established.

Think of it in Alan's Words.

"Sharpen a tool like you sand, 80 grit wheel, 600 grit hone, 2000 grit (white diamond compound) for power honing. (easiest way a work arbor on the lathe with the same diameter MDF wheel as your grinder, white diamond compound charged on the mdf after its trued, yada yada. RUNNING IN BACKWARDS, BACKWARDS. if you don't have that on your lathe, stand on the opposite side of the lathe, place the skew on it like a grinder and watch for black "mud" coming over the edge. Similar to sparks for grinding, you see it, your there. That polishes it, mirrored finish.) If you don't do the rough grits enough, the finer grits won't work. Also power honin isn't a everytime task, if the wood is being touchy, I will power hone. 9 times out of 10, the diamond hone in 600 grit or fine, same thing, is enough. But the skew can be sharpened past that even.

Any questions at all, email me. The skew is probably my fav. tool. I have three, one is one of the Glaser/Lacer's that Alan turns the handles for. It a blast when its right, and sucks when its not. Anything that I can do to help, let me know. Alan explains all of this in the free AAW member DVD this year and in the First skew video the best, Sweet side-etc. Well worth the money, both DVD's are!

Greg

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

#5

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

Ed Moore

>Greg,

I have a power hone set up and have used the compound Alan recommended and white diamond. Probably I need to do the power honing more often on the large skew. I probably also need to power hone the P&N SRG and put a better edge on it.

Thanks for your insights.

Ed

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

#6

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

Greg H. from Wisconsin

>I don't power hone my SRG, I use the diamond hone to hone the inside of the flute and nothing on the outside. The large skew, keep in mind, there's a lot of surface there, take some time grinding with light pressure and honing. Just like sanding, "A" must be right for "B" to work.

glad to help.

Greg

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

#7

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

eliot

>I have several fine skew chisels including a Glasser. And I have both of Lacer's skew DVD's. But I must confess that I seem to nearly ALWAYS have trouble when trying to turn a bead. As soon as I get about halfway around, I get a scroll back. I actually asked Allan Lacer about it; he said to just keep applying pressure against the bead. It doesn't seem to work for me. Others have told me to make sure to rub the bevel and lift up on the handle as I go around. That sometimes works but sometimes it doesn't. I doubt that you can fix my problems here. But I wouldn't mind any advice. I'm determined to master it.

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

#8

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

Greg H. from Wisconsin

>a few points to beads, the first time Alan showed me one, he skated. It happens. Hopefully not often.

Two ways to do them.

1. Rub the bevel and cut in the usually lower third. Great cut, risky process.

2. Have the heal (low point) in the wood. It does help a little to keep the tool "pitched" against the wood if you will in that action.

In either of them. the handle does lift and slightly roll with it.

Make Room, V-cut the hell out of the surrounding area. When your practicing give yourself room, overly pronouce the area to be beaded.

Also don't over lap the cuts. have a little area on the bead flat, about a 16th or so. If the cuts over lap the bead will have point to it. Not as easy to sad out then to blend that 128th (or whatever)of inch flat ridge to blend it in with the rest.

When you make a good bead, you made it to the stopping point, get the tool out of there before you stop and admire. Most catches will happen right then as the tool is leaving.

Practice with a 2x2, rip a 2x4 in half. Nice soft wood, and forgiving.

Lastly,

SHARP TOOL, Sharp tool. You get the point.

What I used to do is to lay out a 12in piece of 2x2, layout and "v" out 3/4 in beads or so from end to end. and just roll 'em.

The skew is like the piano, you must practice your "chords" to play a song.

Is it boring, yeah. Does it help, YES! I haven't caught a bead in a few weeks. And I turn about 10 a day on Tops or Candlesticks or legs. Now that I said that I shoot a top across the shop. But it happens.

Hope it helps

Greg

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

#9

I can't hone...

Peter Teubel

>...to save my life using a stone of any kind. But I can get scary sharp edge with a felt wheel (with green honing compound) mounted in a drill chuck on the lathe. I don't use the edge of the felt wheel...I use the side, while using the toolrest as a platform.

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

#10

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

Allen Neighbors

>Greg, thanks for posting this. I have put my skew away, because I keep ruining good wood with it. Now, with your explanation of use, and John's pics of his jig, I'm going to give it another try. Maybe something will happen...

I apologize for butchering your name in my post to John Lucas, but got it right this time. :o)

Blessings to you.

Allen

C'mon Monday!!!!!

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

#11

Re: I can't hone...

Greg H. from Wisconsin

>As long as you get your skew scary sharp. It doesn't matter if you used a pink and purple elephant to do it. There is a orthodox technique to do it, but thinking outside of the bos isn't bad either.

Good Luck

Greg

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

#12

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

john lucas

>Eliot There are 3 movements you have to do when turning a bead. Because most skews are ground from both sides the bevel is at an angle to the bead. This means to have a square shouldered bead you have to finish the cut with the bevel parallel to that side. This usually requires moving the handle. Of course you have to rotate fom the top of the bead down. This means you have to twist the skew in your hands. Then because the bead gets smaller as you go from top to bottom you have to lift the handle.

So to turn a bead you have to rotate the skew, move the handle to the left or right and lift the handle, all at the same time. If you come off the bevel during any of these you will get the scroll kind of catch. What helped me learn was to really slow down the movements, and concentrate on lifting on the handle. Lifting the handle so it ends up higher than you think also helps keep the bevel in contact with the bead.

You have to practice, there's no way around it. Each day put a limb scrap in you lathe and turn a series of beads. make a bunch of V cuts and then turn the left side of every bead. Don't worry about catch's just keep going. Now do the right side. If you think your getting good at it try the left hand.

I find that turning fairly large size balls or beads that don't have sides perpindicular to the spinning piece, are easier. It requires less movement of the handle to achieve the final results. For my practice piece I start with a large ball shape on the right end and gradually makes the beads narrower with more square shoulders as I go.

Most of the time when people get catchs on a bead it's at the last 1/3 as you approach the bottom of the bead. Concentrate on lifting the handle. I Concentrate on moving the handle left or right using my body and then you can slide the handle up using your hands. You have more control this way.

Just remember what Nick Cook says. There are a certain number of catch's built into each skew and you simply have to use them up.

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

#13

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

eliot

>Greg and John, I will do exactly what you have said. And I really appreciate your help. Greg, you have definitely cleared up one of my main problems when you described the TWO ways -- using the point and not using the point, because others tell me to do one but NOT THE OTHER, e.g. avoid the point. Then I watch Lacer, and he clearly uses the point --sometimes. so again, Greg and John,, thanks. And I'll take the liberty of reporting back if I see improvement.

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

#14

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

Ed Karch

>Eliot

When we get back from Lv'l we will have to get together and make chips and tell lies.

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

#15

Re: Lacer hone - good value?

eliot

>Absolutely! Ever since you said that the great Canadian pianist was Glen Gould, I knew you were the man! If you can personally show me how to skew those beads , I'd be forever grateful.