Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Is there a fundamental law of finisheng?

Posts

Is there a fundamental law of finisheng?

#1

Is there a fundamental law of finisheng?

eliot

>All financial investors know that if you want to go for higher profits, you have to incur more risk; it's like a law of physics. Is there something similar for finishing lathe turned objects -- is there a excellence/time law? Do the best finishes always take more time? Put the other way around, are there any superb finishes that are really fast? I'm asking about larger objects -- not little stuff.

Re: Is there a fundamental law of finisheng?

#2

Re: Is there a fundamental law of finisheng?

Bill Hale / Woodspinner

>1st Law

Your finish can not be any better than your prep and sanding.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ. ( HOT )

Re: Is there a fundamental law of finisheng?

#3

Re: Is there a fundamental law of finisheng?

Carole Valentine

>That sort of depends upon what YOU consider to be a "superb" finish. I may think one persons superb finish looks like crap and likewise, they might think mine looks like crap. ;) However, I think we will all agree with what Bill said about prep work.

Re: Is there a fundamental law of finisheng?

#4

Me too, Me too!!!!

Barry Irby

>Thats exactly what I want. An Excellent finish I can keep and a can near the lathe, that does not need Bloxigen, That goes on fast and looks great. Food safe. Pops the grain. Indestructible. Sadly, I'm not even trying to be funny. I really do want such a finish. Unfortunately, I think its named after one of those Caribbean Islands, St. Happening.

Re: Is there a fundamental law of finisheng?

#5

Actually, There Are Several...........

Barry Turner

>Good finishes do not always take a lot of time. Surface preparation, ie. proper sanding is crucial. You can make or break a finish with sanding. Sand thoroughly, being careful not to round edges or destroy crip details. Sand progressively through the grits without skipping. Sand to at least 320 or 400 grit. Depending on the type of wood, sanding to finer grits may or may not be worth the extra time. You be the judge.

As for finishes, I have had good luck with some very quick and simple ones. After sanding thoroughly, slop on a heavy coat of Minwax Polyurethane, let soak in for a few minutes (5 or 10), then wipe off and let dry overnight. If you wish, you can steel wool or sand out the dust with 320 or 400 grit and apply another coat. This looks surprisingly good on most woods with only one or two coats. It just doesn't get much simpler. You can use the same process with Watco Danish Oil.

Deft lacquer in a spray can is also a quick easy finish. Friction finishes like Myland's or Crystal Coat are also quick and easy for small items like pens and winestoppers. Try some of these methods and pick one or two that you like. Experiment. You may find something that's even easier or better. If you do, let us know.

Re: Is there a fundamental law of finisheng?

#6

Re: Is there a fundamental law of finisheng?

john lucas

>I think the finish has to fit the piece. EVery finish doesn't have to be perfect of high gloss. For example some of Todd Hoyer's pieces don't have a finish or are very rough. Some of John Jordan's carved pieces only have Krylon Fixatif which almost looks like no finish.

Some work needs a very thin satin finish that leaves the wood natural looking and some pieces need a super glossy glass look. It's your decision. You have to decide every step of the way the procedures that you use. How much you sand and to what grit. For example if you are going to paint it with a fairly heavy paint then sanding beyond 220 may actually be conter productive. On the other hand if you intend to finish a piece like Mark Kauder then you better sand as fine as you can get.

I know we are all looking for the perfect finish that's quick, tough, easy to repair and inexpensive. You can't have it all so you have to make choices. I use Hut abrasive waxes for my inexpensive wine stoppers. It looks good but doesn't hold up real well. However it's very quick and seems to sell well. For my more expensive wine stoppers I sand to a higher grit and use lacquer and buff with the Beal. I can afford the extra time on these because they sell for more. I try to make each piece to please the customer but I have to keep time and cost in consideration.

Wish there was an easy answer. REally good finishes take time but not as much as you think if you do them regularly.

Re: Is there a fundamental law of finisheng?

#7

Yep! See Russ's Corner and follow instructions!

Stephen Mushinski

>

Re: Is there a fundamental law of finisheng?

#8

Brad Vietje

Fast, Easy, or Durable -- Pick any TWO !

Brad Vietje

>

Re: Is there a fundamental law of finisheng?

#9

Re: Is there a fundamental law of finisheng?

HarryB

>The one I try to follow is: As soon as I say "That's good enough" that is as good as it will ever be. Better to say, "That's the best I can do."

Pick a finsh and follow the manufacturers recommended procedure.

Re: Is there a fundamental law of finisheng?

#10

Re: Fast, Easy, or Durable -- Pick any TWO !

Russ Fairfield

>Don't you mean, "Pick any ONE."

You might br able to put fast and easy together; but anything that is "durable" is neither fast nor easy.