Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

P&N Gouges?

Posts

P&N Gouges?

#1

P&N Gouges?

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Greetings all

Earlier in the week, the tang on my spindle roughing gouge snapped like a fresh potato chip. I was even turning a spindle! Anyway, I am looking at replacing it with a P&N gouge. I was wondering if anyone here had any experience with them. Since I will be at a fairly large show next week, I will hold out until then to see if anyone might be selling them there. ;-)

Bill

Re: P&N Gouges?

#2

Re: P&N Gouges?

Wayne Leach-NW Ontario

>Hi Bill,

I looked at the P&N and decided that "they could take a lickin and keep on tickin"!!

I purchased the 1-1/4" roughing gouge which you couldnt break if you tried?

Also tougher than dirt, the 3/8" and 5/8" bowl gouge and recently aquired the 1/4 and 1/2 spindle gouges. They hold their edge well and are built tough.

I like to make my own handles and they come unhandled!

I am impressed with these tools!

Hope this helps,

Wayne

Re: P&N Gouges?

#3

Re: P&N Gouges?

Russ Fairfield

>Good steel, and their Roughing Gouge is milled from a piece of barstock rather than being stanmped. It will take some time getting used to because it is heavier than what you are used to using; but the heavier tool just "feels" more right for the roughing task. However, I also use the Roughing Gouge to make planing cuts, turn tenons, cut coves, and make long shallow curves; and for these things the extra weight gets in the way.

If you do a lot of spindle turning and keep the surface of your tool rest polished, you will notice that the satin finish on their spindle gouge seems to be "sticky" on the tool rest when compared to one with a bright polished surface.

Since the inside of the flute has the same finish, I have the perception that the tool isn't as sharp unless I use a stone on it. I said "perception" because it may just be the black color that is making me think it isn't as sharp. I should be using the stone on the inside of the flute on all tools.

None of these things would keep me from buying another P&N tool, but it would not be my first choice.

You asked. Others will have a different opinion.

Re: P&N Gouges?

#4

I like mine

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>Hi Bill,

I have a 1/4" spindle gouge and a 1" flat scraper. They hold an edge very well. I doubt you can go wrong with the P&N tools.

Have a great time in Louisville. I know most of the turners you meet will be looking up to you.

Dave Smith

Flat work to do before a I turn, flat work to do before I turn in Longview, WA.

Re: P&N Gouges?

#5

Roger Dunn

Re: P&N Gouges?

Roger Dunn

>Bill,

I bought two 16mm unhandled bowl gouges and the large skew. The best price I found for them is at Rich Johnson's in San Francisco. His website is :http://home.pacbell.net/latheart/ I reground one of the gouges with an "Ellsworth" jig. The flute is deep and narrower and wet shavings tend to clog up in the flute when roughing. It is good steel. Like Russ mentioned, the flute needs sanding or honing for the best edge. I took a class last weekend from Richard Raffan in Calgary. He likes the P&N skew.

Good luck

Roger Dunn

Re: P&N Gouges?

#6

Re: I like mine

Carole Valentine

>And miles to go before I sleep, miles to go before I sleep ;)

Re: P&N Gouges?

#7

Re: P&N Gouges?

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>I like mine for the most part.

I have a detail gouge, 5/8", 3/8" and 1/4" bowl gouges. They are my primary for all those sized - though my primary gouge is a 1/2" Sweezey bowl gouge. Between the black satin finish, and the somewhat V-shaped flute, they clog a little easier when using a wing for cutting or shear scraping, but over all, not a problem.

Good tools for the price, and I don't have to pay for a handle I will not use. I use mostly metal handles (Houslak, OneWay, Bosch, etc).

Mark

Re: P&N Gouges?

#8

Re: P&N Gouges?

Rick in Colgate, Wi

>I have a 5/8ths P&N bowl gouge and also have trouble with with chips packing in the flute when turning green wood, and the edge dont hold up nearly as well as my Sorby bowl gouges.

Re: P&N Gouges?

#9

Re: SRG Planing

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Russ, I got a P&N SRG last Winter and ground the flute tips back by about 5*. I find with this grind (and a quick inside stone-hone) I get a nice shear cut when planing that can leave a shine on the wood surface almost up to that of a skew. Also seemed to help with the "stickiness" you noted.

Re: P&N Gouges?

#10

Re: P&N Gouges?

Russell L. Babbitt Jr.

>Bill if you want a SRG that will stand up to your meager stature wait to see the offering from CryoSteel and Paulo Marin. If as promised they will be in Louisville everyone will be surprised with what they see.

Re: P&N Gouges?

#11

Re: Mark- wait a minute,....

JamieDonaldson

>... a Sweezy gouge?? That's a name I've never heard before??

Re: P&N Gouges?

#12

Re: P&N Gouges?

Bill Neddow

>Bill, I have five or six P&N tools now, of various types, from detail gouges of various sizes to the spindle gouge and bowl gouges. I like them all. I keep five 5/8 inch bowl gouges going at the same time, sharpen them all together and use them all until dull. This cuts down on trips to the grinder, which is a ways away from the lathe to keep the sparks out of the shavings. I find the P&N bowl gouge lasts as long as the Sorby and the Henry Taylor. The Oneways last a little longer, but they are M4 steel. Best value for money i have found, except for the Benjamin's Best (Chinese) tool I got from Penn State. That only cost $20 and also last as long as the Sorby and Henry Taylor.

Re: P&N Gouges?

#13

Re: Mark- wait a minute,.... *LINK*

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Jamie,

Sorry, I misspelled the guy's name: Sweazey

The descriptive flyer for the gouge is quoted here:

--------------------

"Proudly made in the USA, The Sweazey 1/2 inch bowl gouge is produced from premium M42 cobalt high-speed steel. This steel was chosen because of its superior wear resistance and edge-holding qualities compared to the more common M2. The heat treating process is accomplished in a vacuum chamber (to prevent contamination) followed by quenching in nitrogen. The steel is then tempered at 1000� F in a nitrogen atmosphere to achieve a hardness of 66rc yielding a very hard (but not too hard) material. The result is an exceedingly durable edge able to retain its sharpness for a very long time.

Well-known Pacific Northwest Wood turner Dave Schweitzer provided valuable assistance in meeting several design objectives. Beam strength of the tool when extended well over the tool rest, the capacity to expel chips freely and the ability to work well with a wide variety of grinds were accomplished in this deep-fluted bowl gouge.

The unique handle is drilled 12 inches from the outboard end and filled with lead shot. This provides "heft" as well as vibration absorption to the tool.

The superior edge-holding steel, the advanced flute shape and the vibration absorbing handle all combine into a premium bowl gouge that should be a pleasure for any woodturner.

The tool is available handled for $84.00 or unhandled for $59.00 plus shipping and WA sales tax for Washington residents."

--------------------

There are two grinds available. One is the conventional swept-back thumbnail grind. The other is a convex grind referred to as the "DS" grind for Dave Schweitzer who is a strong proponent of this style grind and contributed greatly to its design.

Two pictures are attached. The first shows the entire tool. The second shows the two grinds available.

I will be looking forward to hearing from you and thanks for your interest,

Bob Sweazey

21701 112th St. E.

Sumner, WA 98390

253-862-9643


http://www.sweazeytools.com/

Re: P&N Gouges?

#14

Re: Mark- wait a minute,....

Bob Fawcett

>Mark,

How would you characterize the "advanced flute shape" in the description?

Re: P&N Gouges?

#15

I like them

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>Hi Bill,

I have several of the P&N gouges, the roughing gouge along with the Kelton handle is great combo for roughing, also I like the detail gauges very much, have the two larger ones and recommend them highly, I use them for a lot of situations not just detailing, think of them as a different shape skew, great for convex or concave cuts, I like also using them with a wooden handle, the Kelton handle is too heavy for general use.

Jorge

Re: P&N Gouges?

#16

Re: I like most of them

Ed Karch

>Im OK with the spindles and the bowl does clog up a bit. My SRG however has a milling ridge on the inside nesr one side that results in a bump on one side of the cutting edge that will cut a groove with a right side smoothing cut. If you get one look it over good first.

Re: P&N Gouges?

#17

Re: P&N Gouges?

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Thanks for all the responses everyone! There is no emergency, and I have plenty of stuff to turn that does not need a roughing gouge (and I still have my 3/4" SRG) so I am going to wait until the symposium and see what is there. These are high on the list.

Bill