Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

End Grain

Posts

End Grain

#1

End Grain

W.C. Turner

>Hi all,

I think someone should write a book, and do a video, "Torn End Grain, And, It's Prevention"!! Seems I have more trouble with that than anything these days. Shear scraping don't always work for me.

What's your solution for it?

Thanks,

W.C.

Email: Remove 2

Re: End Grain

#2

Re: End Grain

John Lucas

>Barry On some woods cutting is the only way. Even shear scraping will still give you tearout. sometimes you have to cut in the opposite direction. This can be very difficult or impossible to do on some shapes but if you have that option try it. Often when you do this it will clean up the area you are having problems with but introduce torn grain in another area.

I have been playing with the Stewart Batty grind which is 45 degrees. With the proper push cut technique this will cure some very stubborn grain areas. I'm still learning to use this tool but it really cuts cleanly when used properly.

If all else fails I use either a round card scraper by hand with the lathe off to clean up these areas or 60 or 80 grit. I've even got some 24 grit but don't tell anyone, I try to convince them that it's just there so I can put it on the stairs to keep people from slipping.

Re: End Grain

#3

Re: End Grain

John Lucas

>Sorry I forgot to mention the most obvious of things. Lubricating the wood. Try squirting water on it and making a pass if this doesn't work try putting paste wax on it. These will often do the trick if you have just sharpened the gouge (I assume you already did that).

last but not least is firming up the wood with Thinned lacquer, thinned white glue, or thin CA glue.

Re: End Grain

#4

Re: End Grain

Bob Fawcett

>I recently bought the new Jimmy Clewes DVDs. He used a shellac based sanding sealer prior to the finish cut to help firm up the wood.

Re: End Grain

#5

Re: End Grain, a very long answer

Russ Fairfield

>This an old message that I dig out every time this question is asked.

Some wood is difficult, and some wood is impossible to turn without tearing the end-grain, especially when the growth rings are far apart and the wood in-between the growth rings is rather soft. The soft Maples, Walnut, and 2nd growth Cherry are typical examples.

The most common solution is to sand our way out of the torn grain problems. That's why they sell those little sanding discs in 46-grit.

However, there are some things we can do to cut our way out of the problem, or at least reduce it enough that we can start sanding at 60-grit. If we were finishing a board (like a table top) we would deal with the alternating texture of the wood with a low-angle hand plane that has had the throat closed up and is held to various skewed angles as it is moved across the surface, and then completing the job with a cabinet scraper. The same techniques work on the turning.

Some of the things that I do on wood like this, and a couple tools we might want to consider, are listed. All of these things can be improved with the addition of paste wax to add some bulk support to the wood fibers and lubricate the cutting edge of the tool. Do I need to repeat that the sharper the tool the better it will cut.

1. A tool with a CONVEX bevel will solve most of these problems because it pushes the active bevel up under the cutting edge where it can support the wood as it is being cut. Hold this tool so the flute is facing away from the cutting area at 90-degrees to the center-line of the wood and with the tool handle level. Then rotate the flute no more than 10-degrees upward, and lower the tool handle no more than 10-degrees. The tool will be cutting slightly above center, and the wood flow along the tip of the tool in a shearing action that duplicates the cutting action of the hand plane described above.

This tool should leave a surface that is as smooth as that of a skew chisel when used on a spindle. That�s because the shear cutting action is the same.

2. If you don�t want to use this tool, at least round over the sharp heal of the bevel on your gouge with the grinder.

3. A Continental Spindle Gouge can be used in the same way as the tool described above. It has the advantage of a narrow bevel.

4. Sometimes tool technique can solve the problem with our existing gouge profile. Turn the shape and a fair curve with a very sharp tool with a small tip radius that is moved rapidly across the surface with smooth movements and making shallow cuts. By �rapidly� I mean FAST. This leaves a surface of small shallow ridges that are easily sanded away.

5. On flat surfaces, as across the bottom of a bowl, the old fashioned tool profile can be better than on with a long side-grind, i.e. the Ellsworth Grind. A bowl gouge that has a conventional grind with a bevel the backs away from the flute no more than 1/32" and that is flat all the way around the flute makes an excellent �Bottom Tool�. Run this tool across the bottom surface in a smooth motion so you are riding the bevel and making a continuous shearing cut. I hold the tool so it is riding the bevel while cutting with a very low shearing angle at the bottom of the flute. When done properly, this cut is also similar to using a skew chisel on a round piece and will leave a similar surface on the wood.

Obviously, this is a tool for very shallow forms and platters, but then, highly figured wood is best displayed in a large shallow platter or bowl (In my opinion).

6. If there is still some rough grain, I use a 1" or wider skew chisel that is ground with a radius, honed with a stone to a sharp edge with no burr, and held flat on the tool rest, dead-center to the piece. The skew is rolled across the wood surface in little bites, and very shallow cuts. This is about the finest cutting scraper you will ever get. It is the presentation of the tool edge to the wood and the same cutting action as what is now called a �Negative Rake Scraper�.

7. Do the final cleanup with a cabinet scraper, working the rough areas by hand with the lathe OFF. These scrapers will work pretty well with the lathe running but they get very hot very quickly, and also dull very quickly. A wooden holder can be used, but this removes the hand sensitivity and the scraper can get too hot. Besides, its faster to do it by hand.

8. When all else fails, there are always those 46-grit sanding discs.

I hope that some of this will help. At least, this is what I do, and it works for me.

"It works for me", is sometimes a bad phrase to use when describing a turning technique because the missing ingredient is the "practice, practice, practice."

Re: End Grain

#6

Ric Taylor

What's the Source for 46-grit? :)

Ric Taylor

>

Re: End Grain

#7

Re: End Grain

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>You have had opinions on a number of ways to prevent end-grain tearout. Also, ways to get rid of it, mostly by using heavy grits of sandpaper. There is, of course, the important advice to "rub the bevel" when using the gouge.

The best advice that I can give you is to cut WITH the grain with a sharp tool in your final cuts. Compare it with planing a board. With the grain, you get a smooth cut...against the grain you get a torn surface. The reason you get end-grain tearout when cutting against the grain is that you are cutting against unsupported wood fibres.

Wally

Wally

Re: End Grain

#8

Re: End Grain

W.C. Turner

>I use Ellsworth's gouge, his grinding jig, and have watched his video hundred's of times, at least, so it seems. I do not enjoy the success he achieves on the video. But, now, in retrospect, I need to try his methods on a harder wood, and see if my success rate, using his cuts from his video, doesn't vastly improve.

I mainly posted this out of frustration with my severely sore neck, & of course, I was having torn endgrain problems with the bowl I was working on. Problem is with the outside of the bowl. Also, I failed to mentioned, the wood was Silver Maple, which is in good supply around here. SM, being a softer hardwood, is mostly the problem, I think. And, I did try all the fiber stiffening methods that I could recall, but, I've never tried water in order to raise the grain. I'll try that next time. I also think I need to pull out a harder wood for my next bowl. Should make the torn grain less of a factor, and, should ease tension build-up in the neck area.

W.C.

Re: End Grain

#9

Uh.......John, Wrong Turner

Barry Turner

>I didn't post the message about ton end grain, but I can certainly use the advice. It seems that I run across the occasional piece that just defies my getting rid of the tear out. When all else fails, I use the 60-grit gouge. (Really, power sanding with a 60-grit disc).