Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Secondary dust collector

Posts

Secondary dust collector

#1

Secondary dust collector

Edward J

>Have "inherited'a shop dust collector, but am finding that the impellor keeps getting plugged with shavings from the lathe. Did some research and find that I need a secondary container to sidetrack the shavings. These are invariably plastic trash bins with a special top. The cheapo version is nothing more than a lid with two ports, but with a price of CDN$40.00. The Lee Valley version, called a "Cyclone lid" is a bit fancier with strategically placed and angled ports. My "Inner cheapness" (and also hearing my wife pointing out) is questioning the fact of forking out $40-50 for a plastic garbage can lid...

The dust collector in my garage is situated in a tight place and I don't have the room for a round trash bin. I'm thinking of making a custom sized one, rectangular in shape, to fit in this tight space and making my own lid.

Does the design of this secondary chip collector demand that it be round? Do the ports have to be angled and strategically placed?

Any advice would be helpful

Thanks,

Edward in Vancouver

Re: Secondary dust collector

#2

Re: Secondary dust collector

Allen Neighbors

>I don't think it needs to be round, but I think it needs a hanging baffle to make sure the larger chunks fall to the bottom rather than just being sucked on into the dust bag. Make sense?

Somebody else may chime in and give you some better explanations of this theory.

Allen

Re: Secondary dust collector

#3

Re: Secondary dust collector

Dave Belser

>What you are talking about is converting a single stage dust collector to a two stage dust collector. The trash can lid thingy is basically a "drop box" with some cyclone action. It is important that the volume is sized to the CFM of your dust collector, too small and the air velocity won't slow enough to allow the big chips to fall out. To big and you will lose a lot of collection power. If you can check the book "Woodshop Dust Control" by Sandor Nagyszalanczy, he has info on building your own trash can pre-separator and also info for making a drop box.

His pre-separator uses some pvc pipe, considering $40 for the lid it's probably not worth the time to mess with making one. A properly sized drop box can get pretty big based on CFM.

- Dave

Re: Secondary dust collector

#4

Re: Secondary dust collector

Edward J

>O.K., thanks. Got to check the cfm of the unit, think the motor is a 1/2 or 3/4 hp with cotton collection bags. See what the library has, and maybe trott off the L.V. and snoop around their books too.

Re: Secondary dust collector

#5

Re: Secondary dust collector

robo hippy

>I use my dust collector for dust, and chips from dry spindle turnings, but on bowl turnings I use a scoop shovel for the shavings. I can fill 2 of the big trash bags easily in a days worth of turning (about 80 to 100 gallons of shavings.

robo hippy

Re: Secondary dust collector

#6

Re: Secondary dust collector

Dave Belser

>Yeah, I agree and do the same. With a lathe it's just not worth filling a dust collector bag with green shavings from a few roughed out bowls. I usually bring in the wheelbarrow and a shovel! If I'm sanding, the DC is running.

- Dave

Re: Secondary dust collector

#7

Re: Secondary dust collector *LINK*

Mike Brazeau

>Edward - one easy solution is to put some 1/2" hardware cloth over the entrance to your collector hose so that the curly's are filtered out. I use flexible expandable aluminum dryer tubing mounted on an arm on a post behind the lathe. I use a large fibre drum using a PVC 45 degree inlet to swirl in the drum on a 1 HP system and it works fine. One improvemnet I am going to make is to increase the size of the centre tube to 6" to decrease the exit velocity. Once the drum gets more than half full it starts to pull the shavings etc out of the drum. Have purchased a 6" to 4" reducer from HD for that purpose. I have more pictures in the Tools & Jigs section at site below.


img

Mike's Photo Site

Re: Secondary dust collector

#8

Re: Secondary dust collector

Jim Terry

>I notice you mention plastic trash bins. You must use a metal trash can. Plastic will collapse under vacuum. I have been using one with my dc and it is a lot easier to empty the can than take the bags off of the dc.

Re: Secondary dust collector

#9

Re: Secondary dust collector *LINK*

eaglesc

>I based my collector on one built by Sonny Edmonds using 55 gallon plastic drums


img

home built separator

Re: Secondary dust collector

#10

Re: Secondary dust collector

Dave Belser

>Hey thats a great idea. I've got a couple of drums kicking around to build one with.

Thanks for the pic,

- Dave

Re: Secondary dust collector

#11

Re: Secondary dust collector

Edward J

>Thanks for the diagram, Mike. I've already turned the port connectors for the hose out of spruce with a lip to fix onto the top. Never did like that PVC glue...

One question though, stupid, but important none-the-less: By "inlet" do you mean the line from the DC, and "outlet" going to the lathe or thickness planer?

Thanks,

Edward

Re: Secondary dust collector

#12

Re: Secondary dust collector

Mike Brazeau

>The inlet is the incoming material being drawn into the drum. A 45 degree elbow aimed along the wall of the drum gives the cyclone effect in the drum. The outlet is the connection to the dust collector. I fastened them to the top of the drum by first putting some plywood on the top of the locking metal top that comes with the drum, and using L brackets from the hardware store and some short sheet metal screws into the PVC.

Re: Secondary dust collector

#13

Re: Secondary dust collector

Edward J

>O.K., thanks. Looks like I'll use a galvanized can, it's a bit smaller and will fit in the space I have intended for.

Mmm... the challange now is to make a wood 45 elbow....

Re: Secondary dust collector

#14

Re: Secondary dust collector

eaglesc

>Elbo not necessary if a "Deflector" is used on the suction inlet.(The fitting that goes to the D.C.)Miter the suction fitting(the one that is upwind of the separator)

I am a tin knocker so I used galvanized metal pipe.The "deflector" is a small sheet rock"mud bucket"It don't have to be pretty it just has to work.


img

Re: Secondary dust collector

#15

Re: Secondary dust collector

Pete in Holland, MI

>3 things:

1) Make sure to gasket the lid on your trash can with foam rubber to preserve the vacuum at the inlet by your machine.

2) Cut a 1" wide slot on the side of your metal can, and screw & seal a piece of Lexan as a sight glass. Dry woodworking chips in my system, once this pre-filter gets above the half way full mark, start to carry over into my bags.

3) Sucking wet curly chips can easily clog a system. The moisture in them will also accellerate corrosion of any bare metal.

Re: Secondary dust collector

#16

Re: Secondary dust collector

Edward J

>Thank you gentlemen, I'll be working on it this weekend. Green wood shavings isn't much of a concern. Tried it once waaay back when I was 14, manged to rust up the lathe bed and a good quantity of my dad's tools with the shavings, not to mention getting myself covered in water/sap...