Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

stopper review

Posts

stopper review

#1

Keith Tompkins

stopper review

Keith Tompkins

>Some time ago, (October '05) I met with Ruth Niles at Totally Turning Symposium to discuss the new bottle stoppers which she had just begun to market. I brought a few home with me to test out, and promised to write a review for Wood Central. I also tested various stoppers that are available; however I did not consider the cork variety, as I don't consider them to be long-term products.

The stoppers are machined from 303 stainless steel, and feature three nitrile o-rings, which allow the stoppers to seal bottles of various sizes. Both of these materials are approved by the FDA for contact with food. Two styles of stoppers are available; one model has a plain post, the other has an 8mm x1.5 threaded post.

I chose the threaded model for my test run. The stoppers I tested were well made, and the shoulder that meets the finial was accurately machined, making for a nice fit. I think the stainless steel brushed finish compares favorably with the chrome-plated stoppers I tested, and makes for a more professional final product.The Niles stoppers also have a lower profile than other stoppers, which greatly improves the overall appearance.

For stopper finials, I drilled a 4.5 mm hole in my blank while held in a chuck, and tapped it to match the stoppper. A makeshift mandrel allowed me to finish off the finials.

Although these stoppers are a bit more expensive than the others I tested, their appearance alone is worth the extra amount, and this should translate into increased sales.

If I had a criticism of these stoppers, I think the 8mm post is a bit of overkill. While nearly indestructible, I think a smaller diameter post would allow more flexibility in the finial design, and would not weaken the post significantly. A minor detail that won't affect most turners. I also suggested to Ruth that a starter kit containing a drill bit and metric tap, along with a matching mandrel would be a great aid in using her stoppers, especially for newer turners. This is a well engineered and well executed product, worthy of your consideration.

For further details, Ruth may be contacted a rthniles@yahoo.com


img

Re: stopper review

#2

Re: stopper review

Bill Neddow

>I agree Keith. These are great bottle stopper bases. I was making two types -- less espensive ones ($14) with a silicone rubber base, and the chrome ones for high end purchasers at $28. I took me the best part of a year to get rid of 20 of the high-end chrome ones. Then I saw Ruth's stoppers and decided to give them a try. Same price as the chrome one. I now sell almost as many of the stainless steel bottle stoppers as the silicone rubber ones. (I have gone through 120 stainless steel bases in the last 10 months). People just like the look of them -- and they feel far more substantial and more like a "present". And, one of the o-rings fits down in the neck of most wine bottles, giving a positive seal -- something I never found in the chrome stoppers.

Re: stopper review

#3

Re: stopper review

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>I agree whole-heartedly with you Keith. I have switched over to the Niles stoppers and have had nothing but good comments about them from customers. I drill my blanks with an 11/32" bit and use the mandril from Packard to make mine. I first used the threaded stoppers, but have since switched to the plain ones. I actually found them easier to use than the threaded ones.

Ruth Niles has definitely developed a good product.

keith

Re: stopper review

#4

Re: Stopper Questions, Views on cork

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>I have a couple of spec questions:

8mm x1.5 threaded post

Is the length 1.5 centimeters (15 mm) or 1.5 inches (38 mm)? I assume centimeters?

What are the length and diameter of the plain, unthreaded post? What is the surface treatment of the plain post? Is it rough enough for an epoxy bond?

IMHO, there are some stopper styles for which cork is essential. I make stoppers in the form of reproductions of 18th Century furniture finials, for example,


Stainless and rubber O-rings would be totally incongruous. The weight and balance would also be wrong. I can't imagine my customers paying much of a premium for these in stainless. I don't expect I would sell any at all in chrome, at any price, even if I could bring myself to make one. Cork, even if it has to be replaced in a few years, is a stylistic necessity. My plain turned, uncarved wine finials, using cork and other traditional materials, have sold at benefit auction for as much as Bill's stainless stoppers. The one in the photo is NFS. Some day, it will transfer to the owner of the clock.

Thanks for the excellent review. Ruth's stoppers make a lot of sense, both practically and aesthetially, for almost all applications. If you use wood a lot denser than walnut, or of larger diameter than most of my finials, the weight and balance of the stainless would work much better.

Re: stopper review

#5

Re: Stopper Questions, Views on cork

Bob Fawcett

>William.

8mm 1.5 is the metric thread. 1.5 refers to 1.5 threads per mm.

Re: stopper review

#6

Hmmm ...

Ed in Leaside (Toronto, Ontario)

>Is that threads per mm, or mm per thread. ;-)

Re: stopper review

#7

Leo Van Der Loo

that's the thread pitch, as from top to top 1.5mm

Leo Van Der Loo

>

Re: stopper review

#8

Re: Hmmm ...

Bob Fawcett

>mm per thread, sorry.

Re: stopper review

#9

Leo Van Der Loo

thread pitch, as from top to top

Leo Van Der Loo

>Here's a chart that gives the metric thread, the pitch number gets bigger as the bolt shaft gets larger, pitch on a 100 mm shaft is 6 mm, not 6 treats per mm, pitch on a 10 mm shaft is 1.5 mm, not 1.5 treads per mm. all these are metric coarse pitch.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo


img

Re: stopper review

#10

Leo Van Der Loo

sizes given are not correct ???

Leo Van Der Loo

>Hi Keith

I think there is an incorrect size quotation slipped into your post, to the best of my knowledge the sizes used now are 3/8" smooth tenon or 3/8" 16 for the threaded tenon, Ruth had also an 9 mm smooth tenon before, when I ordered mine last year.

And yes I agree the stoppers are a class act, top of the line quality and fit all my wine bottles very well.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: stopper review

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: Stopper Questions, Views on cork

Keith Tompkins

>Hi William, the post is 8mm in diameter, the pitch is 11.5mm between points.. The length of the post is 13mm, or 1/2 inch. I agree, your classic stoppers work better with a cork stopper..pretty neat, by the way!

Re: stopper review

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: sizes given are not correct ???

Keith Tompkins

>HI Leo, there may have been a production change; mine are metric. They were purchased last year.

Re: stopper review

#13

I agree!

Molly Winton

>I agree whole heartedly Keith. Ruth's stoppers are far above any other I've seen on the market. I also have the experiences of selling these easily at $25 each. I was a little doubtful at first, wondering if anyone would spend that money for a stopper, but no one even hesitated. Top quality all the way!

Re: stopper review

#14

Beautiful work!

Ruth Niles

>Bill, that is one of the most beautiful stoppers I've ever seen. Very nice workmanship!

Re: stopper review

#15

Try to clarify...........

Ruth Niles

>I'm not good with metric but 3/8" is .375, the tenons are machined at .366 to allow room for adhesive when inserted into the wood. The threaded are machined with that same small (actually the thickness of 2 strands of hair!) variance. The 11/32" drill bit is .345 and either tenon works with that size.

The 9mm proved only to confuse and will not be available after my remaining stock is gone. The 3/8" smooth and threaded will be made forever or until they stop making stainless steel, whichever comes first!

Re: stopper review

#16

Re: Beautiful work!

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Ruth,

Your stoppers are beautiful work, too. I'd be using them in a heartbeat if I were turning stoppers in a more modern style.