Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Maybe I shouldn't ask - Revisited

Posts

Maybe I shouldn't ask - Revisited

#1

Maybe I shouldn't ask - Revisited

Ray Carson, New Jersey

>Hey gang,

I knew when I posted the question on Wood Central I was going to stir up the pot. (See Ray Carson, New Jersey -- Friday, 2 June 2006, at 2:07 p.m.)

Stupid on my behalf. I believe first of all that I do not have tools with good steel. I also know that I in fact didn't sharpen them well at all.

That being said, I still want to buy tools with better steel. Then I most certainly plan on learning a thing or two about sharpening a lathe tool properly. My lathe skills are good, what I learned many moons ago in high school hasn't left me. I always called the teacher and said to him can you sharpen this "chisel" for me?

I don't think I'll ever be turning wood 24 - 7. I added the lathe to my arsenal just to have something different to do. There have been a few projects where I could have used a lathe but opted to buy for example, pre-made table legs.

I appreciate the words of wisdom and constructive criticism. Some of it was.......painful........but I can take advice and learn from my elders. :-)

Just kidding.

Thanks for the advice everyone.

Ray

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask - Revisited

#2

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask - Revisited *LINK*

Ron in Drums PA

>Ray Said

"I bought a set of basic turning chisels when I purchased my lathe just a couple of months ago. A gouge, a round nose, a parting tool and a skew.

I've been making some wood chips trying to get back the feel for the lathe and ..........quite frankly I'm ready to upgrade to something better.

I did sharpen the chisels once, and I know I didn't do the best job but they never seemed right from the beginning. "


You said you sharpen your chisels only once in a few months time.

I sharpen my chisels every day I use them, some times, a couple of times a day.

A chisel is only as good as it's edge.

You could buy the world's most expensive tool on the market, you still need to sharpen it.

It ain't the name on the tool, it's the way it's sharpened that counts.

-----

You need to decide what you want to accomplish, then you can decide what tools you need.

Go to the link below you can't go wrong with anyof the tools in their catalog.


http://woodturnerscatalog.com

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask - Revisited

#3

Re: Turning has changed a lot since..

JamieDonaldson

>... my shop class in 1959, and it has changed even more in the last 15 years! Yet many of the spindle techniques are fundamental and use tools similar to the old ones, but made from "better(?)" metal. Bowl and vessel turning, on the other hand, has made quantum leaps forward, including many new lathe designs that didn't exist 10~15 yrs. ago. There are more new tools in that area than anyone could possibly need, and many are not very necessary, so select with some sound advise.

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask - Revisited

#4

And don't call them chisels!!!

JamieDonaldson

>

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask - Revisited

#5

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask - Revisited *LINK*

Gary R

>Hello:

Just wanted to put in my $.02

I have a Jet mini, and have started to experiment with some larger pieces. Up to now, have been turning mostly miniatures. For those, I have a set of mini tools, and make most of my own.

So.... I wanted to secure a few new tools. Main issue I saw was in the sharpening learning curve. After much page flipping in all the major catalogs, I purchased a number of Benjamins Best tools from Penn State. Yes, I agree that the steel is not as good as some, but I thought they would be great to learn with. First one I picked up was the 1/2" bowl gouge (see link). For about $18.00, I think it's super. I just finished making a "Oneway" type sharpening jig, and re-ground to an Irish grind. I was very impressed with the smooth shear cuts I was able to take.

I ordered a few spindle gouges, as well as smaller bowl gouges. They were in stock, and shipped quickly. I picked up a $29.00 grinder from Harbor Freight, and added the wheel balancers from Oneway. Runs really nice. I read all the posts covering 8" versus 6" versus high speed versus low speed. Talked with a few turners from a local club who all used high speed 6" grinders. If I choose to move to a different grinder, I can dedicate that unit to my mower blades - a good $29.00 investment.

Just picked up a Craftsman electric chainsaw (with extended warranty), as well as a nice pile of maple from trimmed trees at camp. Ends are sealed, and waiting to be processed.


http://www.pennstateind.com/store/lcind.html

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask - Revisited

#6

Or take blue pictures!

Ron in Drums PA

>

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask - Revisited

#7

Re: Benjamin's Best tools

GaryG in MD

>I couldn't agree more about the value of the Benjamin's Best tools. They are HSS, and it doesn't bother me a bit that they are not PM or some ultra-modern steel or whatever. They hold an edge just as well as my regular Crown and Henry Taylor tools, and they are significantly less costly. I far prefer getting 4 or 5 good-quality HSS tools in the shapes that I need over purchasing one tool with a "big name" on it. You can look in the Archives and find that BB tools have generally been well received by other WC members. ...Gary

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask - Revisited

#8

Right. They are not called chisels. Got it.

Ray Carson, New Jersey

>I didn't want to rehash this subject. I get it. I'm inexperiened, turning has advanced since my days in high school, I need to learn how to sharpen my gouge and parting tool and my skew better. I need to sharpen more often, etc., etc., etc.

I asked a stupid question and got what I asked for. Good, sound advice and criticism. My question about what tools to buy was ambiguous as to my experience, time spent each day turning, etc., etc., etc.

Sorry if this post comes across gruff, it is not intended that way. I saw that a few people had responded to Friday's post and I tried to respond to them. My mistake for starting a new post.

I'm going to crawl back into my hole now.

Ray

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask - Revisited

#9

Don't go away

Ron in Drums PA

>With a bowl gouge, parting tool and a skew you can turning almost everything.

If I had only these three tools, I would invest in a half round (chisel) gouge next.

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask - Revisited

#10

Re: Don't go away

Ron in Drums PA

>I meant half round scraper

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask - Revisited

#11

Brian McKearney

Re: Right. They are not called chisels. Got it.

Brian McKearney

>No, don't go away. There is no such thing as a stupid question. I'll admit that I haven't read every response closely, but my $0.02 is to put some money into a good sharpening system (i.e. a decent grinder and sharpening jig - in my case, this translates to a Delta variable speed grinder - there are better available, but this works for me - combined with the Oneway Wolverine grinding jig), and then decide what types of items you would like to make and make tool selections from there. Get yourself a copy of Woodturner's Catalog (http://www.woodturnerscatalog.com) and Packard Woodworks catalog (http://www.packardwoodworks.com) and spend your free time in front of the TV flipping through the pages - you can learn a lot from looking at the various tools on the market and reading the descriptions, etc. I've had good luck with Sorby tools, although there are others that are just as good and better, but I don't think that you can go wrong with Sorby.

Hope this helps!

Brian

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask - Revisited

#12

Hey Ray, don't let us ruffle too many ...

Jamie Donaldson

>.... of those feathers! I think the best deal for a grinder for gouges, scrapers, and even dull chisels is the 8" slow speed Woodcraft with the proper white(Al. oxide) wheels included. Never use the normal grey grinders for your good edged tools and they will last much longer and not damage the hardness of most steels and alloys.Its a good plan to practice sharpening an old bolt rather than an expensive HSS tool until you get the proper movements down, then try the good tools.

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask - Revisited

#13

Re: Hey Ray, don't let us ruffle too many ...

Jeff -- Bloomington Indiana

>Jamie Donaldson, BRILLIANTLY said :

"Its a good plan to practice sharpening AN OLD BOLT rather than an expensive HSS tool until you get the proper movements down, then try the good tools. "

I would have never thought of that, but that is absolutley GENIUS!!

Thanks for the idea ...