Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Any Segmented Turners using incras?

Posts

Any Segmented Turners using incras?

#1

Any Segmented Turners using incras?

dick mc neill

>Do any segmented turners use an incra miter gauge in lieu of the home made miter sled or chop saw? If so any comments? I'm interested in using the model 3000 on my table saw for segment cutting & on my disc sander for small pieces in a featured ring. Also does anyone use the Jolly Jig as a stop for segments? Thanks in advance.

Re: Any Segmented Turners using incras?

#2

Re: Any Segmented Turners using incras?

Russ Fairfield

>The best claimed accuracy from upscale miter guages is a tolerance of plus or minus 5-minutes of angle. For a 12 segment ring, that error is multiplied by 24, and we have the potential for a total accumulated error of 2-degrees. I can get better accuracy than that from a home-made sawing jig and save myself 300 bucks.

I know there will be differing opinions.

Re: Any Segmented Turners using incras?

#3

Re: Any Segmented Turners using incras?

john lucas

>You won't get a different opinion from me. I've used custom miter gauges and built my own. You have to coax each one into the accuracy needed. I'll take my homemade device. Since I just finished tuning my table saw sled up I'll use Russ's example. I did a 36 sided ring. If your off .001 inch by the end you have a gap of .036. To give you an example of how big that it look at your spark plug. The gap is usually around .030. That's a pretty big hole. That's why so many people teach you to glue up rings with no glue at the 180 degree mark and then true up both halves later.

I've never used one of the really high end miter gauges but I just can't believe they could be that accurate and some fine tuning will be needed. If I going to have to do that anyway I might as well build my own.

Re: Any Segmented Turners using incras?

#4

Re: Any Segmented Turners using incras? *LINK*

georgetroy

>I don't have an Inca, but I do use the Jointech sled and the Wood Haven Miter gauge. Currently using the Wood Haven with a John Tally Saw stop. The Wood Haven is set so that not daylight comes through when the rings are clamped with a hose clamp. After that the next step is my sanding sled setup on a 12" disc sander. I have taken two classes with Curt Theobaugh. I also have his videos. The sanding sled is super accurate. I can use almost any means to cut segments, Miter saw, radical arm saw, table saw and bandsaw.You also can make your own miter sleds. All you need is that sanding sled. I helps if your board strips are flat and true all the way around. I call it 4 square. The other responders have also give you good advice. A how to make your own miter gauge is on my basic instructions web site. GT


Segmented turning

Re: Any Segmented Turners using incras?

#5

ebd

Re: Any Segmented Turners using incras?

ebd

>I absolutely agree. The sleds I build are single purpose. After I get through with doing the fine adjustment I lock it down - never to be changed again. From then on I simply pick up a sled and get a perfect fit for that angle/segment number. The time it takes to build a sled is nominal compared to the time it takes to get the angle perfect so that you can cut the segments and glue them without adjustment. Even using plexiglass or polycarbonate for the bed (no shrinkage/expansion or distortion problems) and toggle clamp hold downs you could make about 10 sleds for the same $300.

Re: Any Segmented Turners using incras?

#6

anything can work

John Lucas

>I know this was about the Incra gauge but I've found over the years that you can fine tune almost anything and make it work. Back when I was doing segmented work and having trouble I thought it was my saw and wanted to buy a better one. Gary Johnson from Missouri came and did a demo and he used a fairly cheap taiwaneese miter saw. He simply clamped it in place with a C clamp, made a series of test cuts and then tapped on moveable plate with a hammer until he had the exact angle he wanted. then he tightened the C clamp more. He made is stip block by hot glueing a nut and bolt to the fence so he could make the cuts repeatable.

I never did buy a new saw. I determined that part of my inaccuracty was the fit of the miter slot so I made a sliding table that fits in both miter slots. This reduced the error tremendously.

I would love to try the disc sander technique but my disc sander is homemade and simple doesn't run accurately enough.

I built a homemade hand miter box to do 72 segmented rings for my mirrors. cut a slot with my dovetail saw in the front and back fence. The front fence was just clamped. I rounded over the edges of the cut part so I could rotate the fence which was clamped with C clamps. Then I made test cuts and move the fence by tapping with a hammer until it cut accurately. Then I put some thin CA glue on the fence to lock it down. I made a stop block by glueing a piece of wood with a nut that is tapped into it. I can now cut a 72 segmented ring up to 5" in diameter using just my dovetail saw and my jig.

As they mentioned in this months article in American woodturner it's all about fine tuning and repeatability. You have to feed the saw at the same rate with the same pressure,standing on the same foot with the same underwear, socks and shoes and probably holding your mouth the same way, to get really accurate cuts.

Re: Any Segmented Turners using incras?

#7

Re: Any Segmented Turners using incras?

Stuart Johnson

>I use a Jointech SmartMiter but I agree dedicated jigs might be better. In my case I also use it for flatwork plus it works well for compound miters required for staves. Operator error has a lot to do with how accruate any cut is regardless of the miter type used.

Re: Any Segmented Turners using incras?

#8

Re: Any Segmented Turners using incras?

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Dick,

I will join the crowd here. I do as much segmenting as anyone around, and I say the a dedicated is the only way to go, even if you only do one or two segmented pieces a year. $10 worth of plywood and a couple hours of your time will make a dedicated sled.

Mark

Re: Any Segmented Turners using incras?

#9

The sleds have it.

dick mc neill

>Thank you all for your responses. Apparently the flat miter sled is the way to go. I will give it a try.