Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Design question - lidded boxes

Posts

Design question - lidded boxes

#1

Design question - lidded boxes

Ed Moore

>I recently made five lidded boxes from walnut and made the inset lids from the same piece of ambrosia maple. For reasons that don't matter, the client wanted no more than two woods. I am not displeased with the lids I used, but the question is:

Would this style box look good with a Cindy Drozda style finial?

I am not talking about an extreme finial, and would be curious about the recommended size for one.

dimensions: basic box is 3 1/8" high, diameter is 2 1/8", overall height is about 4"


img

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

#2

lidded boxes - different lids

Ed Moore

>I actually made and sent along a second set of lids from walnut and an ebony knob. Because of finishing problems with ebony I probably won't use it for that again.

Please critique/criticize any of the lids and boxes in these two posts. Go ahead, I can take abuse, I've been married almost 43 years. ;^D

Ed


img

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

#3

Re: lidded boxes - different lids

Stuart Johnson

>I think the lids and finials are just right. I really like the two with the different wood.

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

#4

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

bob davis

>tha walnut lids and finials seem tome more appropriate to the design.they look great

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

#5

Re: lidded boxes - different lids

john lucas

>I would not use a long finial either. I think the ones you made look fine. What kind of finishing problems did you have with ebony. The only problems I've had was I polished it too much and it looked like plastic. I now try to get ebony with some brown in it so it still looks like wood.

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

#6

Re: lidded boxes - different lids

Ed Moore

>John,

I used General Seal-A-Cell and Arm-R-Seal on the boxes because I like the results with walnut. On some of the ebony knobs the finish wouldn't dry. I ended up wiping it off agressively and just waxing the knobs which wouldn't cooperate.

John - please tell Jennifer hello for me this evening. ;^D

Ed

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

#7

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

georgetroy

>This looks like a nice match up to me Ed. Nice looking boxes I would be proud to have them on my shelf. GT

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

#8

Re: lidded boxes - different lids

Ruth Niles

>Ed,

I really like the design and agree with Stuart, I like the two with the contrasting wood on the lids.

If you're showing/selling/giving to other woodturners, make very tall, very thin finials. If you're showing/selling/giving to a regular person, your design is perfect. They can lift the lid comfortably without worrying about breaking the finial.

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

#9

Ruth - you hit the nail on the head!

Ed Moore

>Hi Ruth,

I still haven't forgotten your first words to me at the OVWG Symposium. ;^D

But you hit the nail on the head about the recipient of the boxes. It's a lot like the wall thickness of a bowl. Woodturners have one view of things and the buying public has quite another. I made the lids loose so that they can be easily opened by the knob.

Thanks,

Ed

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

#10

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

Carole Valentine

>Like everyone else, I wouldn't change a thing, Ed. Nice combination and nice design.

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

#11

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

Jake Niedling

>Well I like the knob on the second picture the best. The box design with the ambrosia is nice, but I perfer it to have the knobs in the second picture.

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

#12

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

Ron in Drums PA

>I like the round knobs with the contrasting wood best

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

#13

Re: NO

Russ Fairfield

>

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

#14

Re: lidded boxes - different lids

Scott Hurley in N. VA

>I like the contrasting wood, also.

Scott

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

Keith Tompkins

>I gotta agree with Jake...either lid will work just fine, but the second set of knobs seem to go better with the forms. It appears that the grain on the maple lids is cross-grain orientation. Not a problem with loosely fitting lids, but will bind with humid conditions if made to fit tightly. Nice pieces Ed.

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

#16

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

Ed Moore

>All the lids are end-grain, same orientation as the boxes. I prefer the ambrosia lids with walnut, but I agree that the knobs could be shaped like the ebony ones.

Ed

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

#17

Thank you!

Ed Moore

>I appreciate the comments of each who contributed. Thank you.

Ed

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

#18

ebd

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

ebd

>I don't think a Cindy Drozda style finial would look good at all on these. I like the contrasting wood better and I like the non-round knobs better. I also think that the non-round knobs would make it easier to lift the lids. Just my $0.02

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

#19

Brad Vietje

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

Brad Vietje

>Ed,

Great boxes ! I like the Maple lids better, but the second knob design looks right to me.

I made some like this with Walnut and Yew, so I'm partial to the color contrast. These are much like the design in Chris Stott's fine book, Turned Boxes, 50 Designs.

There are also some subtle differences in the shape of the body of these. All are very nice, but the middle (rear) shape in the second photo is right on the money -- for some reason that one really pops more than the others. The one at left is a little more cylindrical, while the one on the right changes slope a little further down, making it look a bit heavier. That middle one is a home run. Is it the same box as on the right in photo #1 (or did you hit 2 homers in a single series...)?

Nice posting -- we can see how little design changes can really change the look of something.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

#20

Re: Design question - lidded boxes

Ed Moore

>Thanks, Brad. I have absolutely no idea which boxes were used in which pictures. Each box has two lids, one maple and one walnut, and they were all together for the photos. You are right that I probably saw the box in Chris Stott's book of 50 designs, but it is so basic that I haven't worried about whether there is someone's name attached to it. I think Ray Key made small hollow forms like that, and so have I. Boxes sell better. ;^D

Ed