Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

Posts

New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

#1

New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

Ted Owen, Moderator

>A number of the Hand Tools readers have asked that we provide some protection from certain auction posts. After discussion here at WoodCentral, we have a new rule to deal with the issue.

Any message on any WoodCentral messageboard, other than Classifieds, announcing that the poster of the message has listed--on any site, including but not limited to auction sites--a product for sale, shall be deemed in violation of the rule against commercial posts. This rule shall not be construed to prohibit sellers from answering questions about their products, including questions asking whether a particular product is, or ever might be, for sale.

This rule applies to prohibit such posts without regard to whether the poster is a commercial enterprise or an individual. The Classifieds messageboard continues to be available only for individuals. If an individual posts a WoodCentral Classified, it is permissible to post a short notice on any other messageboards that the Classified ad exists; however please include in the subject line language such as "Ad on WC Classifieds" to indicate the post relates to the Classified, so readers can skip that message if they wish.

While some other forums prohibit any reference to open auctions, we do not wish to do so; sometimes such references can be helpful and nonintrusive. Accordingly the new rule does not apply to prohibit or restrict noncommercial discussion of products offered for sale by persons or entities other than the poster. Hence a helpful "heads up" message that something is available on eBay, as well as a discussion of the relative merits of products for sale, shall continue to be encouraged. Heads up messages cannot, however, be posted, other than on the Classifieds messageboard, by the actual seller.

This rule shall not affect or restrict the content of messages posted by WoodCentral or the Moderators. Ellis needs to be free to make announcements or initiate discussion, but those messages will be marked clearly in the subject line.

The rule also is intended to apply to situations or circumstances not explicitly mentioned or currently foreseen. Accordingly, Moderators have authority to apply this or any other rule, or decline to apply this or any rule, in circumstances that in their judgment seem appropriate.

Thanks for your cooperation.

Best, Ted,

Moderator, WoodCentral Hand Tools

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

#2

huh?

e

>sorry, don't understand what you're trying to tell us!

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

#3

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>I'm a bit confused too? Could you give us an example of what is not allowed? I'm thinking it's somethign as simple as "hey I have something for sale over on ebay...go check it out"....but I'm not sure what the hand tool people have to do with it?

It's late...and I've been burning a cherry bowl for the past 5 hours, so it's no wonder I'm confused :)

Jennifer

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

#4

Guess I'm dense, too

Earl Eyre

>Huh? I don't understand at all what you are saying? Can you say it more simiply? Thanks. Earl

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

#5

it simply says...

GaryG in MD

>that we are no longer permitted to announce (i.e., advertise) our own auction posts for external auctions (that are not on the WC Classifides). It is permissable for anyone to bring attention to external auction items that are not their own. ...Gary

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

#6

Does that include a raffle???

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

#7

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

>That is what it refers to. I had posted on the classifieds a book on Stanley Tools I had listed on Ebay. I also posted on the Hand Tools forum the same message more as a headsup to the hand tool people than as a promotion because the book is out of print and very scarce, but I guess it is still a promotion. So next time I'll have to get someone to post a headsup telling of something I have on Ebay.

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

#8

I understand your message...

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>but I'm offended by the tone.

God save us from lawyers.

Gary

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

#9

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

Ron in Drums PA

>I'll bet he's trying to say...

Don't post links to an ebay auction that you have listed items for sale.

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

#10

Hmmmmm

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I think Ted's from Pittsburg which is not too far from Philly which is where lawyers are paid by the page count . . . . .

I keep waiting for Bill Maher to jump into this thread, but I think he's on hiatus.

[OK you guys, NEW RULES - no free advertising in any form, and shilling or pimping for outsiders!]

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

#11

Ahhhh!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Now I get it!

Thanks for the clarification Mark :)

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

#12

Re: huh?

Ted Owen, Moderator

>Don't post "See my eBay auction, link attached" on any WC board except Classifieds.

Best, Ted

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

#13

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

Ted Owen, Moderator

>Hand Tools is just where it came up, Jen.

The rule came out a lot more complicated sounding than I intended. As I was writing, additional scenarios kept coming to mind, and one was later raised by a Hand Tools reader. Ken's explanation is good, or see my response to "e."

BTW, I tried to call you last week while I was in Indy at Marc Adams. Directory Information didn't have a listing for a Jennifer and too many with just the J. Hope you weren't near the tornado.

Looks like I'll be back your way in late August for a MASW rocking chair class.

Best, Ted

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

#14

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

Russ Fairfield

>Ellis has tried to keep this site on the "honor system" with few to no rules. It worked for a long time. Unfortunately, as it has grown, there are more of those who would take advantage of the situation. Controlling their behavior requires rules, and that makes it difficult for the rest of us.

What is is difficult with the term "No Advertising"? Is it some part of the word "No" that is beyond us, or is it the definition of "Advertising"?? Is a list of what is and is not considered as "advertising" coming soon??

There is the issue of "fairness". This site is partly supported by advertisers who pay for being here. It is unfair to them to let others get in "free".

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

#15

Probably not

Ted Owen, Moderator

>If you're referring to announcing a charity raffle or auction taking place here or on another site, I can't imagine anyone complaining about it. Similarly, the WoodCentral Benefit Auctions wouldn't work as well if you couldn't annouce them.

This issue arose because some feel we should do as other forums and prohibit any reference at all to any open auction. We don't want to go that far, but we also don't want the WC readers to feel imposed upon.

Best, Ted

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

#16

Ron, your way would have been...

Ted Owen, Moderator

>a lot better than all that stuff I wrote.

My father used to remind me to use my two ears and one mouth proportionately. He's probably pointing down at me and chuckling about now.

Best, Ted

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

#17

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Ted, please let me know when you're back in town. Perhaps a drive down to Marc Adams could be arranged. I popped in over there when Jim Shaver was here and fell in love with the place. It's been right here the whole time and I'd never been there. Go figure?

Jen :)

Re: New Rule: Open Auction and other announcements

#18

OT: Marc Adams

Ted Owen, Moderator

>A Pittsburgh friend of mine, one of the Marc Adams masters, has been trying to pursuade me to attend a class or two. After having spent a week there on Advanced Finishing with Jeff Jewitt, I'm a huge fan of the school. Was back home only a few days before wangling permission to return for Sculptural Rocking Chairs (Maloof style) August 26-September 1. You'll enjoy seeing the school again.

If you can give me your contact info email, I'll get in touch as we approach late August.

Best, Ted