Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

collars again

Posts

collars again

#1

collars again

dwfII

>I have two questions...one is a little redundant...but they are kind of related, so I hope you'll forgive me.

I am still working on my maple hollow form. It is roughly 8 inches wide and 5 inches deep. I have it on the lathe attached to a waste block which is about three inches across. The opening in the top is maybe two...two and a half inches...in diameter (had to get my Sorby Hollowmaster in there). I have sanded the inside and the outside has been sealed with shellac and sanded to 4000 with abralon.

My first question is how to go about making a collar. I read the articles on WOW especially the one by Wally Dickerman and while it is both straight-forward and informative, he indicates he has two mwethods and this one is for vessels with small openings. What puzzles me is...should I make the collar seperate and then glue it in or rough turn and drill it and glue it in and then finish turning, sanding, and finishing it?

My second question is...how do I part and finish the bottom of the HF and how does the application of a collar affect this process? I guess I'm looking for a reasonably simple procedure so that I won't be fumbling around or re-inventing the wheel as I go along. Seems like, as my pieces get a bit more elaborate, I spend almost as much time trying to figure out how I am going to dismount and finish off the bottoms of these pieces than actually turning them. I'm not advanced (confidant) enough and my turnings are not complicated enough that I am comfortable re-engineering the process every time.

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

Re: collars again

#2

Re: collars again

Barry Irby

>DW, I have very little experience with collars, but I would say that unless your HF is still running almost absolutely true you will have a hard time getting the collar to center up and look exactly correct. My first thought would be to make the collar perhaps before you make the HF and have it waiting. Then you could finish the HF and mount the collar without have to dismount the HF and Remount it or allowing it to relax and dry while you make the collar.

As for reversing the HF, many people use a jam chuck. In effect a bowl it fits into with some padding and bring the tail stock up against it. If you leave the tail center mark on the piece from the beginning it will help to locate the center as you do this. I have done this, but it makes me a little nervous. You are putting the thin wall turning into compression. If your turning is short and fat and has a rather broad top, there is a fairly large area that is very thin end grain. Easy to crush. Be careful.

What I often do is use a stick. I turned one with a No. 2 Morse taper on it and tap it directly into the shaft in the head stock. You could put a small piece in a chuck also. Turn it into a dowel that will pass through the opening in the HF and long enough to reach to bottom. Put a piece of cheap carpet pad into HF and pass it up onto the stick. Bring the tail stock up to center it. If the stick is really small there won't be much driving surface, but the carpet pad provides friction and and some protection from marking the inside of the HF. The advantage here is that you have crack the TS up pretty tight and because the end of th stick is directly opposite the TS, there is little cane of crushing the HF. If my stick is smaller that the opening in the HF I wrap tape around it as a filler.

PS, don't forget to remove the carpet pad from inside when you are finished. I use a wire with a hook bent in the end.

What I do is start the roughing of the HF with the top toward the Head Stock and this automatically leaves the tail center mark on the base. I intentionally leave it on the piece until I am finished becasue I find it so usefull for remounting the work later.

Re: collars again

#3

Re: collars again

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>DW, my second method for creating a collar is very simple. On openings as large as 2 inches or more, I simply turn a flat area around the rim and glue on the material for the collar. It now is just part of the roughed out blank and you can go ahead and turn the collar in whatever shape you want.

Wally

Re: collars again

#4

Re: collars again

John Lucas

>I do it both ways, depending on the vessel. If I've made a very thin vessel with a small foot you can get a lot of chatter if you insert the collar and then turn it. On those vessels I will turn the collar seperately and then insert it. Also I will occasionally need a detail between the collar and the vessel that can be difficult to do if the collar is in place. On these I will turn the collar seperately, or at least partially turn it.

On vessels that will handle it,I prefer to put the color on and then and then turn it. I feel I can get a more complimentary shape that way. It hard to make the collar flow with the form of the vessel. I find that I can do that better when it's on the vessel.

As far as reverse turning the bottom, I use some sort of jam chuck similar to the photo Carole published the other day. Make a tenon to fit the hole in the color then add some friction type material to the front. Sometimes you have to turn a scrap to sort of roughly fit the shape of the collar and then add the friction material in order to get enough friction to drive the piece. Then I have a live center in my tailstock. I use the cup center but remove the point. This holds everything in place. I have also used a regular 60 degree live center point but put a small washer on the tip. The small washer will reduce the amount of penetration of the tip so you don't waste as much wood when turning the bottom.

Re: collars again

#5

Re: collars again

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>DW, when you need to work on a vessel that is already thin, you need a steadyrest. Otherwise the the wood flexes and chatters and just won't cut. I really recommend the Oneway. I've been using a 3-wheel steadyrest for years. I recently purchased the Oneway and I really like it. It's easy to install and it's more versatile than a 3-wheel.

Wally

Re: collars again

#6

2 wheels or 3?

Jim K in Trappe PA

>Wally,

Oneway has a two wheel bowl rest and a three wheel spindle rest. Which do you use?

Thanks,

Jim K

Re: collars again

#7

Re: 2 wheels or 3?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>For bowls or vessels I use the 2 wheel. You can buy the 3 wheel spindle steady and use the same shaft for both.

Wally

Re: collars again

#8

Re: 2 wheels or 3?

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>If you liked a more "Captured" type of bowl steady, and don't want to build one or spend $$$$ for a custom made one, I just bought two of the Oneway's and put one on each side of the lather (front and back).

Mark

Re: collars again

#9

Re: collars again

dwfII

>Thank to everyone who responded on this question of collars. Every little bit helps...

Wally,

That seems to be a problem with Jet minis...you can't find a steadyrest that one) fits the 1014, two) is reasonably priced, and three) doesn't rob too much clearance from under the vessel. At eight inches in diameter on this maple HF, I am working almost at the limits of the machine when you consider how much space the banjo takes up. Oh, for a Vicmarc 200 shortbed! [sigh]

Tight Stitches

DWFII--Member HCC

Re: collars again

#10

Re: collars again

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>You can make one for a Jet Mini - I turned on a Jet Mini for about 4 years, turning bowls up to 9.5" using my bowl steady. The key is for the bottom piece/brace to be made of 3/8" steel, while you can make the rest of it out of wood. This picture is not very good, but you can get an idea about how to do it.

Mark


img

Re: collars again

#11

Re: collars again

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>P.S. These pictures are from when I was making it, before I routed the slots for the locking nuts on the arms. That is why you see all the clamps.

Mark

Re: collars again

#12

Re: collars again

dwfII

>Mark,

Yes, that's the ticket. Looks just like what I had in mind.

I have a very small shop...which is why I turn on a mini in the first place...and I don't own a bandsaw or a router. If someone was making or selling these at a reasonable price I'd be first in line.

Thanks for the photos and the advice...

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

Re: collars again

#13

Re: collars again

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>I sold mine to Carole Valentine last month, or I would be happy to send it to you. I do bowls a big lathe now, and my mini is now for spindle work.

I will tell you, that you can get one of the Oneway Bowl steadys, and you bolt it to the lathe near the headstock, and angle it so that the support wheels are supporting the bowl 12" or more out from the headstock. Even if you put the steady right under the bowl, you only lose about 1/2" of clearance.

Good luck

Mark

Mark

Re: collars again

#14

Re: collars again

dwfII

>Mark,

Hmm, that's interesting! Why do you need to angle it? And will it fit the Jet mini--I assume it will if you're recommending it....

Thanks for the advice. This might be a reasonable solution.

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon