Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

buffing speed

Posts

buffing speed

#1

buffing speed

john lucas

>I know we've had some discussion on buffing speed and I happen to be one of the slow speed group. However I've been playing with different finishes this week(it's always good to explore different techniques) and have found that the hardness varies quite a bit between them. I can buff the minwax wipe on poly at a much higher speed than lacquer without causing problems. The Tru-oil is also quite hard although I didn't try to buff this with the 8" wheels at 1725 rpm. I worked too hard on that piece and didn't want to ruin it. I'll try that on some scrap in the next few weeks. Anyway what I was trying to say is that the type of finish we use and how much we build it up may have a lot to do with the differnt speeds we use on the buffing system.

I still like the slow speed, it's less grabby and does just fine for me but a harder finish would let you get away with more on high speed. Anyone else have any thoughts on that? These are obviously just my thoughts on a limited experiment. Your mileage may vary.

Re: buffing speed

#2

Re: buffing speed

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA.g

>Whether fast or slow speed, heat is the enemy to a surface film finish. I like to just polish the wood surface, and give it a coat of Tru-oil or Watco. Generally, I am not a gloss finish person. My 3� worth.

Re: buffing speed

#3

Re: buffing speed

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi John,

I buff at about 500 rpm with my Beall. Heat was a concern for me too as well as the relative softness of the buff to form to the shape of the form I was buffing (the egde of the buffing wheel is "harder" at higher rpms). I just did a trial and error process years ago with my three buffing wheels and 500 worked out best for me.

take care,

Jim

Re: buffing speed

#4

Re: buffing speed

john lucas

>Jim I certainly agree about the shape of the wheel. I frequently push the speed up to "harden" the edges so I can reach into some area of the turning. Most of the times I like the slow speed so it will wrap around the areas. Good point.

Re: buffing speed

#5

Re: buffing speed *LINK*

Phil Joines Krum, Texas

>I buff oil, CA finishes and acrylic on an old 1/4HP 3400 motor with 8" soft wheels. Each wheel has it's own mandrel. For metal I use a hard wheel. There is also a mandrel mounted drill chuck for 2" and 3" sanding disks and drums.

For laquar I use a VS motor at low speed with a 14" wheel.

BTW I mostly use Menzerna fine compound after final sanding from 600 to 1200 grit.


Menzerna at Stew Mac

Re: buffing speed

#6

Richard Allen

Re: buffing speed

Richard Allen

>I will often use buffing to "acelerate" the cure on the finish. This is especialy true for the longer oil varnish finishes I use. This will often gum up the first wheel. The corners of some raw spindle stock will clean it up.

More important than the speed of the buffing wheels is good light and magnification to inspect the progress of the buffing. Feel (touch) is also a part of the inspection process.

Re: buffing speed

#7

Re: buffing speed

Russ Fairfield

>It is interesting that you shoul;d ask. I have just completed a series of hardness tests on a series of finishes on turned wood. This was for a coming article on the hardness and therefore the durability of the various finishes. All were allowed to age for 2 months, and all were on the same wood - Pacific Yew. All wood was sanded to the same 2000-grit and burnished with a piece of grocery bag paper before the application of the finish.

I used the Pencil Hardness Test" which relates to the hardest pencil lead that will not scratch the surface. Following is a summary of the results.

H - Bare wood

H - Wax

2H - Shellac applied as as a Friction Polish

3H - Pure shellac with multipl;e coate to the same thickness

3H - MinWax Polycrylic

3H - Deft lacquer applied as a Friction Polish with Boiled Linseed Oil

4H - Deft lacquer with a spray can

4H - Deft lacquer dipped in the finish

5H - Waterlox

5H - CA Glue

5H - CA Glue applied with BLO as a lubricant

6H - Waterborne Polyurethane (Enduro)

9H+ - Wood that is stabilized with Acrylic

9H+ - Acrylic plastic.

You can read the article or buy the video when they are published for a discussion. Meanwhile, you can draw your own conclusions.

Re: buffing speed

#8

Re: buffing speed

John Lucas

>Fascinating Russ. I look forward to reading the article. I had never heard of the pencil test but makes sense. My test was probably more of a heat test (not on purpose, I just needed to buff the pieces) than hardness test.

Re: buffing speed

#9

Re: buffing speed

Allen Neighbors

>John, my homemade buffing system is a 1725 rpm motor, on which I mount my 8 inch home made wheels of felt (2 1/2" thick, tripoli), Cotton/Polyester Denim (1" thick, white diamond), 100% Cotton Denim (1 1/2", Carnauba), and Cotton Flannel (Rounded 3" thick,clean).

I have no way of reducing the speed of my motor.

I buff lacquered pieces, oiled pieces, and bare wood... the piece dictates the pressure applied.

The fine folks on this forum have taught me how to load my wheels. :o)

Allen

Re: buffing speed

#10

Re: buffing speed

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Kind of like the Mohr's Mineral Hardness scale for finishes eh Russ!

I look forward to reading it as well.

Take care,

Jim

:-)