Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Is it ART??

Posts

Is it ART??

#1

Is it ART??

JamieDonaldson

>It's thin, so it must be! What would be your criteria and comments for pricing a piece like this? I knew it was full of borer holes,but couldn't resist the Norfolk pine resemblance. 8"Hx7"Hx 3/16"thin


img

Re: Is it ART??

#2

Re: Is it ART??

Jim

>You know what they say. If it won't hold water, then it must be art!

I like it. The general shape is pleasing, and the borer holes make it interesting.

(*The only thing that puts me off is the grey stain. I wonder what can be done about that sort of thing? Perhaps a dye or bleach?)

Re: Is it ART??

#3

Re: Is it ART??

JamieDonaldson

>That should have read 7"W. Pine borers have decimated the pines in most of the surrounding area, and I'm having to remove most of these original pines on our golf course. Some haven't had many holes and look like Norfolk, but the price is much better!

Re: Is it ART??

#4

Re: Is it ART??

Rick Davenport

>I like it fine the way it is.

I think pieces like this are a collaboration between the wood, the borers and the turner.

Great teamwork!

Rick

Re: Is it ART??

#5

Art maybe?

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Art is in the eye of the beholder. I love the turning. What is Art and what is not Art is so subjective it's really hard to debate the question. I�ve seen the debate attempted a few times. There is a lot of Art snobbery also. It affects what some people consider Art. My daughter is an Art student at Kent State University. She is majoring in ceramics. It is in the subcategory of Arts and Crafts. A lot of the Fine Arts students look down on the Arts and Crafts students. They consider them crafts people. Of course if they really knew my daughter and a lot of the other Arts and Crafts people, they would find out they can paint, draw and sculpt as well as the Fine Arts Students. They just prefer a different medium. Some artists believe the idea is everything and the execution is secondary and have the peons do it for them. We have people like that in the construction industry too! We call them Architects. No, I'm not really that cynical, I'm just referring to the worst of the lot. There are actually some Fine Art Students and Architects that know what they are doing. Please excuse a woodturner, carpenter, and craftsman on a rant!

Tom

Re: Is it ART??

#6

Re: Is it ART??

John Lucas

>Jamie in my area you'd be lucky to get $80 out of it. In your area bout $380. It's not the thinness that counts it's the shape. John

Re: Is it ART??

#7

Re: Is it ART??

Ed Karch

>You have to pay more for the holes. I had some buggy box elder and can't turn it fast enough to meet the demand.

Re: Is it ART??

#8

Re: Is it ART??

eliot

>I think it's a beauty! What's wrong with it? The worm holes don't bother me a bit.

Re: Is it ART??

#9

Re: Art maybe?

RobinCorell

>"Art is what makes the felt and sensed tangible so that others might contemplate it." Suzanne Langer

I'm open to other definitions for art, but I really like this one lately.

Robin