Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

Posts

Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#1

Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

Dave Winters, Steamboat Springs, CO

>Here's a good one: What's your favorite and least favorite wood to turn, as far as the smell? I love the smell of the rosewoods when I'm turning. And I keep a billet of Juniper around to peel some shavings with a skew if I know clients are coming round to the shop.

Least favorite has to be wet Cottonwood. My wife makes me change clothes in the mud room before she'll let me in the house when I'm roughing Cottonwood blanks.

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#2

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wi

robo hippy

>I agree with you about the wet cotton wood. My favorites are chinkapin (golden chesnut) because of the smell, kind of likc pencil cedar. Cherry because of the smell, and color. Madrone because it has the smoothest texture, and because wood movement as it drys is so unpredicable in direction and amount. It is insane, which fits my tastes of warped bowls.

robo hippy

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#3

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wi

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

>Favorite has to be Camphor

Least Favorite has to be some pieces of Poplar that smell like an old horse stable when machined.

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#4

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wi

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>My favorite smelling green wood is cherry; the least is Ailanthus.

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#5

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wi

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>I love the smell of Sassafras. Wet Poplar and Apple are not favorites. I recently turned some Red Oak that had been dead for a couple years and it really had a sour vomit smell.

Terry

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#6

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wi

Bill L.

>Lignum vitae is my favorite . It has a fragrance that rivals any cologne . The resin was sometimes used for treating gout and rheumatism a long time back . The only drawback I see is that it gums up sandpaper . Bill L.

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#7

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wi

Terry M

>My favorite would be bloodwood and also Myrtlewood. Least favorite Oak

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#8

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wi

David Breth

>Favorite is Sassafrass. Least favorite smelling is Box Elder. It isn't the most offensive smell by a longshot, but I just don't care for it.

David B.

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#9

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wi

Chip in Plano

>Bloodwood, bocote and asian padauk all have wonderful smells. Cherry is nice, too, but I get a better aroma from a tablesaw cut than a turning. Zebrawood is rather stinky to me.

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#10

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wi

Peter Teubel

>Cherry is my all time favorite. Love that smell! Wet Red Oak is so offensive to me that I refuse to turn it in my shop. Dry is ok, though.

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#11

Re: I enjoy the peppery smell of bocote.

JamieDonaldson

>

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#12

Re: Oscar Meyer hotdogs

OB OBrien In Pensacola

>I cut into some real dry dogwood the other day and it smelled just like Oscar Meyer hotdogs. No kidding, Two guys in the shop agreed with me. Wonder if there's a connection.....Dogwood - Oscar Meyer. ??

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#13

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wi

Jim

>Add one more "least favorite" for Red Oak. Smells like cat or dog poo. Eeeyuck. I also hate the smell of English Boxwood at any time, cut or uncut. Of course I'm talking about the decorative shrub used in formal gardens. (At one point I had it confused with Box Elder (Acer negundo) because of the similar names. By several accounts it smells like dirty socks. I can't say I've had the pleasure.)

Add another favorite for Sassafrass. Close behind that would have to be Red Cedar (juniper) and Yellow Pine. And speaking of shrubs, for some strange reason I like the smell of Creosote.

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#14

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wi

Scott Longberry

>Favorites are Teak and Cocobolo (Yeah, I know, if you can smell the Cocobolo it's not good for you!)

Least favorite is Zebrawood (Has to be named for smelling like a Zebra and not for the stripes!)

:)

Scott

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#15

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wi

RobinCorell

>Here is another vote for Camphor with Port Orford cedar as a very close second.

I have some Japanese Boxwood and enjoy turning it because I think it smells a bit like buttered popcorn, very diferent from someone elses impression of English Boxwood.

I used to not care for Chinese Elm, but now find the peppery smell pleasant. I am not overly fond of wet Black locust, but I refuse to work with red oak for any project because of the way it smells.

Robin

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#16

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wi

Molly Winton

>My favorite is cherry, with close seconds of myrtle and camphor. Least favorite is zebrawood. Green elm fits in somewhere as a unique smell. It reminds me of a horse barn. It's not the most pleasant smell, but it's associated with fond memories.

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#17

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wi

Jim

>Actually I can't describe the smell of English Boxwood... It's just... unpleasant. The Japanese variety may smell better. Buttered popcorn doesn't sound too bad actually.

Speaking of smelly trees. I've heard that blooming Chestnut smells like rotting meat. I also had an aquaintance say that Chestnut smells like Clorox. I've smelled a Clorox smell before on my wooded lot and went looking two days ago, but no success in locating a Chestnut.

Anyone else smelled Chestnut before? What does it remind you of?

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#18

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wi

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>Favourite Camphor Laurel.

Intense dislike Zebrano, is that what Zebras smell like?

Regards Peter.

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#19

Spanish Cedar, Yes. Yellowheart, No.

Craig Daymon

>I haven't turned it, but when I planed a substantial amount to make a picnic table, I left the chipy lie for quite a while because it smelled so good. I don't think it is a great turning wood, but maybe it is. It is in the Mahogany family.

I love the wood, but hate the smell of Yellowheart.

-Craig

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#20

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wi

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA.

>Camphor smells great!!

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#21

Also Yes for American Chestnut.

Craig Daymon

>Got lucky at a woodturning meeting and acquired a roughed bowl blank of American Chestnut. (Thank goodness for the mud covering the labeling the original owner wrote on it.)

Smelled great. Hope I get to turn some more in the future.

-Craig

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#22

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wi

David Galloway

>Cherry is my favorite....very sentimental memories associated with the smell. I also love the smell of most conifers.

Poplar and box elder sends my family into revolt as the smell goes up from the basement!

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#23

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wi

Carole Valentine

>Wild Black Cherry is my favorite. My least favorite used to be Elm until I turned a piece of some sort of poplar the other day. Boy did that stink! Smelled like a sewer. It had a lot of what looked like mineral staining in it, so maybe it grew over a sewage field of some sort. Yuck.

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#24

sassafras/Red (Piss) Oak

Gerry Meekins in MD

>

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wise

#25

Re: Favorite and least favorite wood, fragrance-wi

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>My favorites are cherry and port Orford cedar, my least favorites are elm and the worst ailanthus.