Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

A Big Laminated Turning Question

Posts

A Big Laminated Turning Question

#1

A Big Laminated Turning Question

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Greetings all

I got a phone call today from a contractor who is looking to have a very large baseball bat turned. It needs to be 6 1/2' long and fit around a support column in a basement. I quoted a ballpark price that I considered to be somewhat on the outlandish side, and he did not even bat an eye, but said write it up and it will probably be accepted.

I have turned some long sticks before, but nothing lamintated like this. I need some segmented advice here. This thing is going to have to fit around a 4" diameter column, and is probably going to be somewhere around 5" at its narrowest and 8" or 9" at the base. Does anyone here have any experience doing anything like this? Not only does it have to come apart in half longways, it is going to have to come apart across the middle, since I can only spin 40" on the Poolewood. I TOLD SWMBO I was going to need that Conover one of these days... ;-)

Thanks.

Bill

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#2

Hey Bill...

David Propst

>Sounds easier than turning a boat mast! :-)

David

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Bill, do you have two lathes? Set them the correct distance apart, and reverse the tailstock on the "driven" lathe to point at the turning. that way, one piece. Is the column removable? If not a split turning would work, using dowels to locate everything for reassembly. the ends of the column could be clamped or bolted together, leaving enough stock to be turned away at the end. Sound doable.

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#4

Re: Hey Bill...

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>I was thinking just the same thing myself David!

This should be an easy one for you Bill..

:-)

take care,

Jim

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#5

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

adrien

>He didn't BAT and eye????

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#6

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Bill, I assume you're thinking staved construction, am I right? That would be the way to go, for sure. With any shape other than a straight cylinder, ripping the staves using the only the tablesaw fence becomes difficult so you need to make a sliding jig to hold the staves, with clamps and stop-blocks to position them. About 3 years ago I had a job turning two 6 ft lampposts, tapered, about 3" on the small end and 5" on the big end. I used an 8 ft. 1 x 6 (cheap poplar, planed straight and true) for a sliding table with a 3/4" guide runner screwed to the bottom. I believe I did 8 segments, which made them roughly 2" wide at the big end. Technically, one should align the staves at the same angle from linear center on the jig as they will be in the final product, but with a long cone such as this it's not necessary. I feel qualified to say this since in a former job I used to fabricate African style percussion drums, the majority of them being cone-shaped and the stave blanks were always cut flat on the sliding jig. Now, if it were me, or if I were you, I'd just turn the straight cone shape and form the shaped ends from solid wood.

I guess you'll have to use 1/2" lumber so the smallest diameter will fit around the 4" post.

Good luck, sounds like a fun job.

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#7

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>Greetings Bill,

I think you can treat it just like a hollow column, maybe 6 or 8 pieces glued on edge and a pair of removable lugs at top and bottom and of course composed of two halves with paper on the seam so you can opent it and glue it permanently on site.

Sounds like a fun project and if they pay you well even more so.

Hope you get it

Jorge

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#8

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>How long is your Legacy mill?

We did some fluted mahogany columns for a room in a cellar. This customer's cellar was nothing like my cellar, of course. Shaping, smoothing, fluting, etc., were only secondary issues in our case, as they are in your project. A friend, and subcontractor, has the Legacy mill (for flutes, and also for more basic shaping). He also has the router bits for coopered hollow columns. (Sorry, I'm not having any luck tonight finding a link to these bits on the net.) When we got to the actual turning of the glued up, coopered, hollow "quarter columns", we attached end blocks at both ends with screws (like face plates) and held the segments together with aircraft hose clamps spaced at intervals along the length. Just like a spindle steady, we had to stop and move the clamps around to get the whole thing turned, and then later to flute the columns from end to end, and then sand them. The coopering router bits allowed us to glue most of the the segments together before turning, and then finish the assembly of four quarter circles, on site, with very little surface variation at the joints. Of course, final sanding and finishing had to be done after installation.

HTH. If you have any questions, contact me via e-mail.

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#9

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

robo hippy

>Gee Bill, I wish you could have been at the last meeting of the Beaver State Woodturners here in Eugene, that was our demo. Frank Ferguson did the demo, and he does a number of this type of column. I would have you contact him, but he doesn't have a tv, or computer. I would suggest to draw out the top and bottom diameters in full scale, and bet board number and layout from there. When making the stave cuts, if the angle figures to be sat 12 1/2, then make the cut at 12 3/4. this will insure that the outside is tight, and a very slight gap on the inside won't matter. Also, depending on how you make the rip cut, make sure that when cutting the second bevel that the edge doesn's slip under the fence or guide (don't cut the bevel through the top (outside) of the bevel, leave a slight square edge on the board. When turning a colum of this sort, there can be considerable tearout, and Frank has a unusual way of cutting it, more like scraping down from the end, rather than like a roughing gouge on a spindle.

robo hippy

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#10

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Thanks guys. Keith, I have done long turnings before, up to 14' 2"! This is going to have some tighter tolerances. Jim and David are harkening back to when I turned the mast for my sailboat in 1999.

Jorge, I am thinking a split turning like you describe, only the remodeler is going to have the privilege of installing it. I suppose I should make it as easy as possible for him though.

My main questions are sort of along the lines of what Ken describes. I am thinking tapered staves, something I have not done yet, even on a small scale.

Ken, I have a 8 1/2 foot sliding table on my Mini Max, so the tapered part is fairly easy to accomplish - well the sliding part is easy to accomplish! Once the tapers are figured, then it will be, dare I say it, straightforward? I've got to figure it so that I have a relatively round inside that will accomodate a 4" post, and still have enough material to get the outside round and down to about 5" or so on the outside. Making the ends solid should not be a problem, and it may not even need ends, as the bottom can "fade" into the floor, and the top is going to have some sort of square box between it and the ceiling.

William, the Legacy will do up to 60". Did you rout the inside as well as the outside?

Reed, what you describe sounds a bit like Ken's description. It is the math that has me going. I know a math prof who is also a turner, so perhaps I will contact him as well. Why, he might be reading this as I type! Ed, are you there?

Oh Adrien, that is one STRIKE against you for that pun.

Bill

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#11

Is this the bit?  *LINK*

Bob Fawcett

>


Router bit

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#12

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

Ron in Drums PA

>I just tested Woodturner Pro. It will figure out angles for tapered staves up to 96" tall

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#13

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

John Lucas

>Bill Have you looked at some of the sliding attachment hardware they have in Woodworkers supply. I used some for some portable walls once. You just align the two sections, one above the other and then drop them in place. They lock quite securely. You could install these in the 2 halves so that it could very easily be installed. I think they would hold well enough for turning but would still feel more comfortable with band clamps or layers of strapping tape for security when turning. The only coopered long pieces I've done weren't that long and I used false ends glued on to secure everything. They were supposed to be 1/4 round decorations for a bar so I couldn't glue them together.

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#14

Thanks Keith, I like it!!

Barry Irby

>This is why I read this stuff. Sorry to jump into your post, Bill, but this was a great idea, at least for me. Sort of a "Duhhh, why didn't I think of that". Two lathes, back to back. You could make a "bar" to clamp from one to the other and line them up and keep them from walking away from each other. A nice piece of sturdy wood ala Conover. I am going to have to turn something really long on my short bed lathes.

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#15

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

Stuart Johnson

>I think turning it as two pieces (four if you figure the two halves) might be better. In effect you have one half that is more or less a straight handle and a second half that is fatter. As Ron says the angles can be figured with WoodturnerPro or another program.

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#16

Mark Sfirri might have some insight.

Craig Daymon

>Bill,

I know Mark's big bats are solid (and a bit twisted), but there are a few that are longer than what you are looking to turn. Send him an e-mail, he's in the BWT directory.

-Craig

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#17

I'm here!

Ed Moore

>Bill,

You want a bat that has a 4" diameter cylinder cut out of the center and that can separate into two halves.

My approach would be to laminate 2" x 2" stock into two pieces and use a router to remove the "center" portion from each half. Make up some thin stock that is the thickness of your saw kerf (bandsaw or tablesaw) put the strips between the two halves and glue it up. Find a lathe big enough to handle the size and turn it.

Rip the bat in half and glue the new strips in place on one half with a little overhang. Clamp the halves together and hand-plane off the excess or sand it off.

How would I join it together? I would use picture hanger router bit and large sheet metal screws. Rout one side and put the screws in the other so that you can insert the screws and slide the two halves into place.

Ed

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#18

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

Bob Lemon, Sacramento CA

>Bill, I gather your bat will not be proportionally correct. I have a Louisville Slugger Little League bat which is 30" long,1 1/8" dia. This means that a 6.5' bat would have a small dia of about 3". I guess you will have to give him a 'fat bat'!

Good Luck, Bob

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#19

Re: Is this the bit?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Yup, that's the type of bit we used. They are made in different angles, for different numbers of staves. IIRC, we used a bit that formed 12 sided forms. Also, they are made in at least two different heights, for staves of different thicknesses. For a roughly cylindrical column, thinner staves would work fine, but much thicker staves are necessary to make something shaped like a baseball bat.

Hey, Bill! Are you going to fill the columns with cork? :^)

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#20

Re: It's a Whiteside, too!

Allen Neighbors

>Bob, Whiteside bits one out over all other bits used in a CNC router test a couple of years ago. I ordered a Whiteside, 4" tall, multiform bit from Librawood (best prices I found) and used it to cut over 160 feet of 2 1/2 inch oak. When I finished, it was still cutting as well as when I started.

Just info.

Allen

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#21

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>My friend's Legacy mill will do longer columns than that. These columns were on the order of eight feet long, but that included some top and bottom details.

The insides of the columns were not routed. They remained flat. Reference the drawings in Bob's Hartville Tool link. A minor problem with these bits is that the angles will not match perfectly if you make tapered staves. I'd have a lot of trouble doing the math to calculate the gap based on the number of staves and the angle of the taper, or even predicting whether the gap would be on the inside or the outside of the column. Sorry.

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#22

Re: It's a Whiteside, too!

Bob Fawcett

>Great info Allen.

I have been using WHiteside bits for a few years. They are also made in America.

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#23

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Thanks for all the responses everyone! I have a lot of information to digest now, both from here and via email. This job is not going to happen until later on towards the end of summer, so I have some time to work on it.

Right now I have some turning to do for some other things, one piece very important to get done. I appreciate all the responses and the time people have taken to email me, etc.

Bill

Re: A Big Laminated Turning Question

#24

Re: Hey Bill- for inspiration look at....

JamieDonaldson

>... the ball bat leaning against the building next to the Louisville Slugger factory while you're here for the AAW Symposium - I believe its 110' tall!