Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Tool making question

Posts

Tool making question

#1

Tool making question

Ed Kelle

>I'm trying to make some small hollowing tools according to all the info I've gotten here. Using 1/4" oil hardened drill rod for this first set, if it works well I might use the 3/16" and 1/8" versions as well. Right now I am just working my way thru the straight one.

Last night, tried using the only torch I had, a propane one. I got it to turn red for a little bit but obviously it wasn't enough. So today I went to the Orange Box and bought a Mapp torch, of course they didn't sell the head separately, so I had to get the pricey set with the auto start head. Anyhow, this got the tip to turn red much quicker and I kept it red for about 2 mins or so. Quenched it in peanut oil and cleaned it off. Then used the propane on it again. I turned off most of the lights to see when it would turn yellow but obviously it blew past that quickly and went blue. Does this mean that I really did not fully harden it?

It is much easier to see the metal turn yellow with the lights on, and by yellow I am assuming it means that first quick yellowing not the yellow before it turns red hot again.

Somewhere I read that after it gets red it should be non metallic, and that's not the case either. Not sure if that matters.

Any insight into if I have done all correctly will be appreciated greatly. I'd like to get this right before I go thru the hassle of trying to bend the swan neck version. Got a metal bender jig that allows you to do all sorts of coils and such, but even with the "instructions" it still is quite a mystery. I am using 7" long pieces which will have about 3" inserted into the tang. Will use a copper pipe coupling for a tang into hard maple handle of about 15".

I've already spend more on the supplies than I could have bought a set of mini hollowers for, but hopefully learning this will be better in the long run. Also bought 1/8" HSS bars, but don't even want to think about trying to drill holes and insert tips yet. I admit to being metally challenged.

Any advice is appreciated, a few good laughs would be nice as well. Thanks

Re: Tool making question

#2

Re: Tool making question

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA.

>Ed, Check your email, I sent you a Word file on tempering by color.

Re: Tool making question

#3

Richard Allen

Re: Tool making question

Richard Allen

>The color is straw not yellow. The steel will not glow straw. The steel will take on a straw color. This is a very small tempature window and the steel which is straw color will quickly change color beyond straw.

Re: Tool making question

#4

Re: Tool making question

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Ed, I found a good page explaining the heat treating of O1--although it's about wood plane blades, it's pertinent to turning tools:

http://www.hocktools.com/diyht.htm

The basic process involves heating to just past the point of the steel losing it's magnetivity; quenching in olive oil to harden the steel which makes it brittle and glass-hard; then gently heating to about 425 deg. F to draw out the brittleness, while still retaining a good amount of hardness. The 425 F. heating produces a "Pale Straw" oxidation color, or slightly dark yellow, on the surface of the metal that's polished bright. You need bright light to see this. This color is an extremely thin film similar to the rainbow colors resulting from oil or gas floating on water. It's easy to overshoot the color to brown, which takes more of the hardness from the metal--and if you've gone to purple and then blue, you need to start all over again.

Alan Lacer also has a very good tutorial on heat treating, in regards to making a hook tool:

http://www.alanlacer.com/articles/basic_hook_tool.html

Re: Tool making question

#5

Re: Tool making question

Barry Irby

>I too am metally challenged. I made some turning tools. What I did was heat the steel red hot until a magnet would not stick to it and then let it plunge into some oil. Was advised to drop it and let it plunge into the oil so that it enteres so fast the oil would not burst into flames. Then I heated the home oven to 425 Degrees (checked it with a thermometer), put the tool in there for an hour and turned the oven off, letting it cool slowly, overnight. Seems to have worked. The tool, a gouge, holds and edge reasonably well and has not broken or chipped, indicating it is not terribly brittle.

For small hollowing tools, you can heat the very tip pf the tool red hot and quench it and use it like that. The rest of the metal will be softer and strong and the tip will hold an edge. They really don't do a lot of cutting and don't need to be the finest steel in the world.

Also, don't make them too big. I did. You don't need a fifteen inch handle. That would make two handles, maybe three. Keep the blades or shafts fairly short too. Tools this thin simply will not reach far without chattering. If they have big handles and are too long they will be awkward.

Re: Tool making question

#6

Re: Tool making question

Ed Heuslein

>Howdy Ed: The other replies are all good and valid. What I do is heat 'till magnatism is lost and immediately quench in peanut oil. Olive oil works fine also. Then, after I have several tools made, I preheat the oven (SWMBO doesn't mind as long as the oil was peanut or olive) to 400 degrees & put the tools in for about a half hour, turn the oven off and let it set - I usually do this late and let it set overnight. This has been successful for me and is pretty easy. While you're at it, make some 1/4" round skews, 1/4" pyramids, and a few hook tools. You'll be glad you did. Oh yeah, one more thing. Grind your new tools to shape BEFORE you heat treat. DAMHIKT. Happy heating. Ed

Re: Tool making question

#7

Anyone know where Bonnie Klein got her reference?

Craig Daymon

>In the AAW sharpening video, Bonnie Klein references a very clear and easy to understand chart covering a variety of different steels. It would be a great one to have as a reference. I think her's was from a book/catalog. If we knew where she got it, we might be able to find it on the web as it is the sort of thing many tooling companies might post on their site.

-Craig

Re: Tool making question

#8

Thanks for all the advice

Ed Kelle

>I'm going to redo the tool tomorrow and be more careful with tempering. thanks for all the great info

Re: Tool making question

#9

Re: Tool making question

john lucas

>Ed and Barry described my method. The only difference is I heat the steel in the oven for 1/2 hour per quarter inch of thickness. It doesn't need to be in there longer than that.

Re: Tool making question

#10

Re: Anyone know where Bonnie Klein got her referen

Phil Joines Krum, Texas

>Tenpering temperatures are the same for all of the carbon tool steels, oil, water or air hardening. 450F works for any of them. I have used all three types and haven't seen any real differance in use.

The high speed steels need very high temps, in the 1400 to 1800 range. Not something most home shops are set up to do. If you are, get the temperature specs when you buy the steel. It can vary between batches.

Re: Tool making question

#11

Re: Anyone know where Bonnie Klein got her referen

john lucas

>Phil When I did my article on heat treating I looked into heat treating HSS and decided you can't do it at home unless you want to invest in a heat treating oven and possible stainless steel envelopes to wrap the piece in. It gets pretty complicated with heat and cool cylcles and varies with every grade of steel since they put so many different things in HSS to give it the properties you want.

Re: Tool making question

#12

Re: Anyone know where Bonnie Klein got her referen

Phil Joines Krum, Texas

>Yep, and I don't think you can bend the stuff either. At least every time I've tried it the metal crumbled.