Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Did I help it or hurt it?

Posts

Did I help it or hurt it?

#1

Did I help it or hurt it?

Chris DiCiaccio

>Should I leave the finial or lose the finial? What do you think? My first skinny finial. Didn't have any other contrasting wood to use for the finial.

Thanks folks.


img

Re: Did I help it or hurt it?

#2

Re: Did I help it or hurt it? 

Chris DiCiaccio

>


img

Re: Did I help it or hurt it?

#3

Re: Did I help it or hurt it? 

Chris DiCiaccio

>


img

Re: Did I help it or hurt it?

#4

Re: Did I help it or hurt it? 

Chris DiCiaccio

>


img

Re: Did I help it or hurt it?

#5

Just Me

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi Chris,

You are a hard working turner...you really have been working hard on developing your skills and forms.

My comment is my own thoughts and not a critisim of your work. I think a finial should have some aspect of form or shape that compliments an element or part of the shape of the body it is resting on. I think if I look at the shape of the turning and see a round form, my eye wants to see a complimenting shape somewhere in the finial, maybe I am wrong, but that is just me...

I also would look at the transition between the two. I see a large step and I think a blended transion or again a design element that ties the top to the bottom might be a feature to look at.

Chris, I have to also be honest, I have only tried this once myself and I know how this is something that takes work, it does not come easy bring two ideas together.

So as carver Chris Pye says, Showing Up is 95% of being there, you are well on that path in my mind. Keep at it, I alsways view the work you post.

Again, these are my thoughts, meant to be from a different set of eyes..

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: Did I help it or hurt it?

#6

Jim,

Chris DiCiaccio

>Thanks for the honesty, that's the only way I'm going to ever do better. Now I know some things to work on. I appreciate it.

Re: Did I help it or hurt it?

#7

Chris

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Thanks CHris,

Be proud of your work, you are always getting better. I know that we have some other eyes here who can also comment with better experience than I have...I hope you keep pushing your skills and designs...you are doing great!

Turning is a passion, it's fun too!

Take care,

Jim

I need to make some pens..hmmm

Re: Did I help it or hurt it?

#8

Re: Did I help it or hurt it?

GeeSeaWhy

>I'd lose the finial. It doesn't look like it belongs with the piece. Maybe try a collar instead, rounded over and not even as high as the bottom straight element of your finial. I think it would have to be dark - if you don't have any dark wood, try black dye or shoe polish.

Free advice. Worth every penny.

Graeme