Re: negative rake scrapers?
Dick Anderson
>Phil:
I have been using a negative rake scraper for about 4-years. The first negative rake scraper was my skew chisel, which is ground with a 40-degree cutting edge. However, the frequency of grinding required to keep a burr on the edge has resulted in the degree of the cutting edge not remaining a constant 40-degrees. I have not noticed any appreciable change in the use of or results from the tool caused by the change in cutting edge angle, which has varied upward by at least 10-degrees.
I use the negative rake scraper on hard woods (have used it on some soft woods) where I want a smooth surface and it is not possible, rational or practical to sand the surface with the piece turning on the lathe. For example on the thin, natural edge winged bowls made from coolibah, red and brown mallee that I make I use the negative rake scraper to produce a very smooth surface ready for hand sanding (lathe turned off) starting with 400 or 600 grit sand paper.
I have used 3 different skew chisels as negative rake scrapers. A regular 3/4-inch rectangular skew, a radius skew, and a oval skew which can be tricky since it wants to rock on the tool rest. Since I don't like the oval skew as a skew I use it as a negative rake scraper and it becomes a wasting tool, because of the frequent grinding.
I use an 8-inch, 46-grit SG grinding wheel to produce a good burr. The burr last only a few seconds and produces a very fine dust.
I have purchased Stewarts radius negative rake scraper, which works quite well. A radius negative rake scraper can be used on the inside of open bowls, but I find that to be a waste of a good tool, since a very good surface can be achieved with proper use of a sharp gouge or a proper regular scraper.
For me the negative rake scraper is used only in those areas where I don't want to put my hand or fingers, like the edge of a thin winged square edge bowl. To me it does not make any sense to use negative rake scrapers on the inside a hollowform.
Sorby makes what they call a hardwood scraper with a reverse rake angle on the cutting edge and a regular 70-degree scraper angle. Instructions say "Tool is usedwith the long bevel in the upright position." Supposedly the tool will not self feed into endgrain. However, this tool is not a true negative rake scraper, which relies solely on a good burr to produce a very fine, smooth finish cut.
I hope this helps.
Dick