Aspen Burl Bowl
Dave Winters, Steamboat Springs, CO
>Here's a few of my latest. Critiques on form and photos welcome, please.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Aspen Burl Bowl
Dave Winters, Steamboat Springs, CO
>Here's a few of my latest. Critiques on form and photos welcome, please.
Re: Aspen Burl Bowl
Dave Winters, Steamboat Springs, CO
>Another.
Re: Aspen Burl Bowl
Dave Winters, Steamboat Springs, CO
>Rim Blackened and Grooved
Cottonwood Burl
Dave Winters, Steamboat Springs, CO
>Natural edge, base way too big?
Re: Aspen Burl Bowl
Jennifer@Indy.USA
>Hi Dave, I like all three but I am partial to number 2 and most of all number 3. The wood is fantastic and your shapes are great too. I like the burned detail on the rim of number 3.
Your photos look good but they appear a tad on the yellowish side? Could you perhaps not have your White Balance setting in the proper position? It should probably either be on incandescent, or fluorescent depending of course on what you're using.
Thanks for sharing you work!
Jen
Re: Aspen Burl Bowl
john lucas
>Dave it's hard to critic the photo. It's excellent other than being slighly off color on my computer. I'm assuming you didn't use a slighty orange yellow background. The bowl is excellent. I'm assuming the dip in the rim was a natural flaw. That's the only part that bothers me and it might not in person, I can't see the natural edge inside the dip. That might make it more acceptable to me. I do like the shape of the lip and don't think it would have been improved by lowering it to the point of getting rid of that little dip. I'm just wondering what could be done to enhance the perception that the dip is a natural part of the bowl. Like I said in person that part might not bother me but not being able to really see the dip makes it look sort of like you carved it but the shape doesn't look intentional.
Re: Aspen Burl Bowl
Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA.
>Dave, I like all four!! Fine work.
If I had to pick, it would be #2.
Re: Cottonwood Burl
Juergen
>Dave are you sure that's Aspen and not Cottonwood? The bark seem a lot thicker than the Aspen we have at 6000 ft in Colorado Springs. I've turned a lot of Cottonwood and it looks similar to your piece.
Re: Cottonwood Burl
Dave Winters
>Juergen- Are you asking if the bowl titled "Cottonwood Burl" is Cottonwood?
Re: Cottonwood Burl
Juergen
>OOPS!! After 3 Aspen pieces I just didn't read the title of the post. I guess it proves that I can tell if it's Cottonwood 1 out 4 times. :-)
Re: Cottonwood Burl
Dave Winters, Steamboat Springs, CO
>Yeah, you called it. I end up turning quite a bit of it for lack of anything else really. It does get some decent burls sometimes and the crotch figure can be stunning. My wife says it smells like cat piss when I green turn it. It doesn't bother me much, but it does have a nasty odor. Pretty useless otherwise. Too stringy to split for firewood even. You use it a little, huh?
Yellow?
Carole Valentine
>Looks peach colored on my monitor. This just makes me wonder what color-cast others may see in my photos when I post them, even though the colors appear perfectly true on my monitor!:(
Dave, I like all of them. My favorite wood is the Cottonwood - it's gorgeous, but that is my least favorite form of the three.