Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Southern wood ID needed

Posts

Southern wood ID needed

#1

Southern wood ID needed

Pete in Holland, MI

>Morning all - -

This past Fall, I was involved in a mission trip to the city of Biloxi, MS, to help out after the hurricane. Part of the work needs was to take care of a bunch of fallen trees. Being from Michigan, I thought it a good opportunity to come home with some non-native wood to turn.

Attached is a photo of one of the bowls made from the trunk pieces brought back. This is finsh turned, but no sealers applied. Colors are pretty true. The wood turned green pretty well and dried well (with the help of Anchorseal). As I am finish turning, the orange wood proves to be VERY hard, and the sap wood about that of soft Maple. The orange wood tends to tear pretty easy even with the best of my turning efforts (which are still a long way from perfect). The wood is easily friction burned from the bevel of a tool or dull sand paper. This friction burning on the white sap wood leaves an interesting rose color to the wood. The tree itself was in the city and about 2' diameter in the trunk. It was fairly tall, but the canopy didn't spread out too much. There were many Live Oaks in the area, but this one didn't compare in shape and bark appearance. There were no leaves on the entire tree, and the millions on the ground would have made it a crap shoot picking one up.

Any clue as to the wood that I'm working with ?

Thanx guys


img

Re: Southern wood ID needed

#2

Re: Southern wood ID needed

Pete Kekel - Kentucky

>The contrast between heart wood and sap wood, the open looking grain, and the orange-ish color look like Honey Locust to me.

Re: Southern wood ID needed

#3

Could it be Ash?

Carole Valentine

>

Re: Southern wood ID needed

#4

Re: Southern wood ID needed

TDaniel

>It looks like Cypress. Is it heavy or light in weight?

Re: Southern wood ID needed

#5

Re: Southern wood ID needed

James McClure

>Looks like mulberry to me.

Re: Southern wood ID needed

#6

Steven Antonucci

I second Ash...

steve antonucci

>Not sure about it based on the location, but it looks exactly like the ash bowl I have turned and drying in my garage right now...

Steve

My tree was loadd with nails... :-(

dang "road trees"

Re: Southern wood ID needed

#7

Re: Southern wood ID needed

robo hippy

>My guess would be honey locust, or a variation of it that is called moraine locust. The wild honey locust has thorns up to 12 inches long. When ash has the brown/olive color in the center, it doesn't go all the way out to the sap wood, and doesn't follow the growth rings. The locust doesn't have the rough bark like a walnut, and isn't smooth, kind of inbetween. It is very hard, and kind of stringy. Sometimes a very iight finish cut with a scraper works well. It does have a distinct smell which I can't describe, where most of the ash I have turned has almost no scent.

robo hippy

Re: Southern wood ID needed

#8

Re: Southern wood ID needed

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Pete,

Can you post a close-up of the transition area between the heart and sap wood? I think I'm seeing the feathering that you would expect with one of the elms. This is caused by a distinctive "W" pattern in the small pores of the latewood. Looking closely at the endgrain with a 10x lens could answer your question.

Gary

Gary

Re: Southern wood ID needed

#9

Re: Southern wood ID needed - more info

Pete in Holland, MI

>Guys -

Thanx for the input thus far. Answers to some questions: The wood is heavy, kinda like an oak. Yes, the grain is best described as feathery, especially in the orange wood. Yes, it does have a distinctive smell, kinda mildly sweet with a tinge of musty. One of those smells that is good in a short breath, but not a long one. It does have a tendancy to separate at the growth rings near the edge of a bowl. A man from East Lansing sent a photo of some bowls he's turning of honey locust, and it looks exactly like what I'm working with.

Re: Southern wood ID needed

#10

Leo Van Der Loo

Honey-Locust for sure

Leo Van Der Loo

>

Re: Southern wood ID needed

#11

Ditto...

Peter Teubel

>

Re: Southern wood ID needed

#12

Brad Vietje

YUP

Brad Vietje

>

Re: Southern wood ID needed

#13

Re: Honey-Locust for sure-yes

georgetroy

>

Re: Southern wood ID needed

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: Southern wood ID needed

Keith Tompkins

>millions of leaves....sounds like locust to me too.

Re: Southern wood ID needed

#15

Then Honey Locust it shall be !

Pete in Holland, MI

>Thanx for your input !

Pete

Re: Southern wood ID needed

#16

Re: Then Honey Locust it shall be !

Keith Newton

>Pete, I think I am with Gary Evans on the elm guess. It seems to me in the broad area just to the right of the center, where the rings are broad that I can see the little zigzag pattern in the late wood. I think that early wood is too small proportionally to the annual ring for it to be honey locust.

If you could post a closer image it would be easier to tell. If I am wrong I will eat a honey locust bean, if all of those who are so sure of the locust call will agree to match the bet.

If you have never tasted the beans, that is where they got the name. They are soooo sweet initially, but you are left with a bitter after-taste. I have been told that goats and cattle like them. You have to wonder why mother nature fitted them out with such awful thorns. It probably had something to do with old mother-nature trying to favor one type of critter disbursing the seeds, and keeping another type from climbing to get at those sweet beans.

Which leads me to ask. If you help cut up the tree. The wind may have blown the leaves off, but I'll bet the thorns would still be present. were there any.

If you will look around on your camera for a little icon of a little tulip shaped flower, either press that button, or turn the dial to that setting, and you should be able to get in a lot closer to focus. Don't try to use the flash this close.

Re: Southern wood ID needed

#17

You and me, Keith

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>3 observations:

It's difficult to positively identify a species without inspecting the endgrain under magnification, and sometimes not even then.

A particular species grown in the deep south can look different than the same species grown in the midsouth, which can look different than the same species grown in the north due to the differences in the length of the growing season. This translates into differences in the width of the rings and sometimes even the color of the wood.

If there weren't any thorns, it isn't honey locust. Those thorns are not going to blow off as easily as the leaves, even in a hurricane.

No offense intended,

Gary

Re: Southern wood ID needed

#18

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: You and me, Keith

Leo Van Der Loo

>Often bearing long branched thorns, but most cultivars have neither thorns nor fruits.