Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Powermatic Headstock Problem (?)

Posts

Powermatic Headstock Problem (?)

#1

Brad Vietje

Powermatic Headstock Problem (?)

Brad Vietje

>Hi Gang,

I recently learned that earlier versions of the PM 3520 had a very dangerous problem with the headstocks -- the castings occasionally broke, and they FELL OFF -- while being used ! This apparently was not a problem of over-tightening the locking mechanism on the sliding headstock, but a serious design flaw.

There doesn't seem to be much on-line about this, but last weekend I talked with some very, very well known professional turners who relayed that 3520 lathes at both Arrowmont and Anderson Ranch had this problem....

Can anyone out there add any details ?

I have two reasons for asking:

1. Owners of older 3520-A lathes might want to look into extended warranties, recalls, fixes, or other actions they might take to protect themselves.

2. I recently bought a 3520-B, and from what I hear, the problem has been corrected in these newer models -- but is this true ?

I would appreciate any additional info the group can provide on this.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Powermatic Headstock Problem (?)

#2

Re: Powermatic Headstock Problem (?)

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>Never heard of it and find it hard to believe unless the early modles are a lot less massive than the 3520a or b.

Re: Powermatic Headstock Problem (?)

#3

Re: Powermatic Headstock Problem (?)

john lucas

>Brad I can give you details because I've been following these machines since thier beginning. The very first models used a cast round ring as the locking device for the headstock. We had one break and the headstock fell of on one of the school lathes. Powermatic changed the design and thier hasn't been a problem since. They had several minor engineering problems with the first models. They had a fantastic locking mechanism for the tool rest but it was expensive to make so they changed to the familiar locking handles, unfortunately they made them hollow with a brass pin so you wouldn't damage the tool post. Of course being hollow they broke, so they changed that.

They also had some electronic shut down problems with the very first few sold but they solved that.

These have been very solid machines with few problems ever since. I won't say they don't have any. Apparently some tolerance problems exist occasionally but WMH tool group has been very good about taking care of these.

Mine has worked perfectly for the last year and a half and I've turned hundreds of items both big and small. There must be 6 or 8 in our club that own them and they all work well. We have 9 at school and only one is having problems and the electrician thinks it might be the schools power, not the lathe. They take a huge amount of abuse by the students.

Re: Powermatic Headstock Problem (?)

#4

Brad Vietje

Re: Powermatic Headstock Problem (?)

Brad Vietje

>Thanks John.

I noticed that the new 3520-B has a circular steel disk like a hockey puck for lockdown of headstock, tailstock, and toolrest banjo, and all seem to work real well. The 3520-A banjo, with the post above the eccentric cam rod doesn't seem to lock down as well as the beefier one on the B model, but the offset toolpost (B) can make roughing a bowl between centers a little crowded unless the tailstock ram is extended quite a ways.

Do you know if there was a general recall or retro-fit of the early 3520-A models to replace the cast ring that was breaking ? If a big hunk-o-wood is spinning at 800 RPM, and comes flying off, headstock and all, I sure wouldn't want to be in the shop with it ! That could ruin your whole day...

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Powermatic Headstock Problem (?)

#5

Re: Powermatic Headstock Problem (?)

robo hippy

>I have one of the early 3520A models that had the cast iron pressure plate under the headstock (since 2000). It broke on me, while coring some black locust. Fortunatly, it only tilted forward, and did not fall off the lathe. It was 4 plus years old at the time. I went to the local Woodcraft store (of course this happened at 6:00 pm on Friday, as I was getting ready to sand for a show the next day. I checked out the newer 3520A in the store, and it had a steel bar stock (not round) pressure plate on it. On Monday I called PM, and told them what happened. I said I wanted a replacement steel one. They asked me if I was still under warrenty and I told them that it didn't make any difference because they had a problem which they corrected, and should have told all of the reps about it because it was dangerous. They hummed and hawed for a bit, and sent me a replacement part no charge. In the mean time, my neighbor welded up something out of bar stock that worked, and to date, I haven't used the new piece. I did discover, that if you use the new plate (I don't know about the round one), it needs a longer bolt than the cast iron one had.

On another note, I did wear out one set of headstock bearings. After 5 plus years of heavy use, and a lot of chainsawn blanks, turned without the tailstock, they were worn out (at least according to several local turners). I got the replacement bearings, and new belt, had it fixed for less than I could get the parts for through PM. I don't know one set of bearings from another, but the guy who works at the bearing store here, is an old friend of mine, and he said that they are very good. The spindle was rusted in place probably because I turn wet wood, and was a pain to remove (no I didn't do it myself, that is a job for professionals).

I now have a Laguna 16 HD bandsaw, and my bowl blanks will be a lot more balanced to start, so this set of bearings should last a lot longer.

I am hard on my tools, I don't abuse them, but I do use them.

robo hippy

Re: Powermatic Headstock Problem (?)

#6

Re: Powermatic Headstock Problem (?)

john lucas

>Brad I don't know of a recall. I've never actuall heard of any other machines having the problem we had at the school. It may have simply been a bad casting, but they did change to the steel disc instead of cast.

I like the new tool rest especially for turning platters. I can't tell you how many times I've almost hit the banjo with a square edge bowl. This tool rest would stop that problem.

They also changed how the tailstock locks. You can't get the banjo right next to the taistock on my lathe because the locking mechanisms hit. They moved the locking mechanism back on the tailstock and also made the alingment flanges longer so it's easier to get the tailstock on after you've removed it.

Re: Powermatic Headstock Problem (?)

#7

Re: Powermatic Headstock Problem (?)

David Galloway

>I have serial number 00003, the first went to Rude, the second to Willard, and the 3rd was supposed to go to Nick Cook, but went to Joe Matwick. I purchased it from him three years ago.

I love the machine, American made. However I did have the cast plate break on me once while turning a large bowl. Replaced the plate with an extra one Nick had, and it cracked when I was tightening it down. I replaced it with a Oneway steel plate made for the PM bed and it works great.

I am hoping to get a 3520B as soon as I can. I have enjoyed turning on it at Nick's shop. When I get the B, then I can put my 00003 in a museum along with all my Grateful Dead stickers a la Jacques Vesery.

Re: Powermatic Headstock Problem (?)

#8

Re: Powermatic Headstock Problem (?)

Phil Joines Krum, Texas

>I broke a cast iron banjo plate on one of the first ones. It was about a year old and they had already started replacing them with steel.

Re: Powermatic Headstock Problem (?)

#9

Re: Powermatic Headstock Problem (?)

Philip F Duffy

>My old machine, no letter at the end, has had no such problems in the 6 years it has been running here in my garage and it was a used machine about 4 years old when I bought it. Love it, yellow and all. Phil

Re: Powermatic Headstock Problem (?)

#10

Re: Powermatic Headstock Problem (?)

Phil Joines Krum, Texas

>I agree, it's the best lathe for the money, one might say it's a cut above. :>) It's just that cast iron isn't a good material for that part. It isn't hard to make a replacement with a couple of hole saws on the drill press.