Re: Gouge selections.....
Dick Gerard
>Here's my $ .02 worth ...
To start with, invest in a good handle like those made by Mike Hosaluk. Then just buy the steels to fit. You can use one end for 5/8 and the other for 1/2" bowl gouges. Adapters are available for 3/8 and 3/4. Here's a link for a review:
http://www.newwoodworker.com/reviews/onwytrnchslsrvu.html
Personally, I use 1/2 and 3/8 inchers almost exclusively. Maybe its just what you get used to, but these are the gouges I "go to" time after time, year after year. Think the old superflutes without handles (actually, to be honest, I got one with the handle, cut the handle off and used the bare steel in the Hosaluk handle).
For roughing gouges get those with a good deep "U" section. I have 2 ... both I believe are from Henry taylor "Diamic". Probably over 20 years old. High Speed Steel. Got 'em from Craft Suppies, I think. larger one measures 2" from flute to flute. Smaller one is 3/4 inches.
If you do this you will have several advantages:
1) One handle for all your bowl gouges. Cheaper to buy unhandled steels.
2) Easier to sharpen. Remove from the handle and you don't have the handle getting in your way.
3) If you travel to demonstrate or teach or take a class, pack just one handle for your bowl gouges.
4) Less clutter in your shop
5) The Hosaluk handles are warm to the touch.
6) Have you read any of the lathe tool reviews that talk about how nicely balanced the tool is straight from the factory? What happens to that nice balance after you've ground it down say, even 1/8"? But, if balance is really an important criteria, think about having a handle that let's YOU determine how much of the tool extends beyond the end of the handle.
7) Adaptability: the Hosaluk (now One Way Master Cut handles) can be joined to make longer handles, thus providing more leverage.