Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?
Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL
>In my opinion, you have two choices: 1) An easy finish that will not protect the wood (Oil), or 2) Something that will protect the wood, but ultimately would have to be refinished because of chipping and/or scratching.
1) An Oil finish is about as easy as it gets, but will not protect the wood from scratching or denting. To restore the finish you would have to sand away the damage, and then re-apply the oil. Fairly easy.
2) Protecting the surface and the expense of the finish: You have numerous options. Strongest would probably be an Epoxy finish. I have never used one, so cannot comment on the ease of finishing or refinishing. Poly - easy to apply, but does some impact resistance if liberally applied. However, refinishing would require sanding away all the damage, and most of the finish or you can get witness lines. Same applies to most of the waterbased and catalized lacquers.
Now, as most of my friends were expecting, I would recommend Behlen's Stringed Instrument Lacquer. It is hard enough to withstand the abuse fairly well, and flexible enough for the wood to move, and also flexible enough to withstand some of the impact damage. It is formulated for things like guitars and violins, that take lots of physical abuse, but are thin wood that has to move. When repair is required, sand just enough to remove the worst of the dents/chips, and reapply. No worry about wittness lines. It is best appled with a sprayer, but could be thinned and brushed.
Mark