Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

best finish for a loose change bowl?

Posts

best finish for a loose change bowl?

#1

best finish for a loose change bowl?

GaryG in MD

>I'm going to make a small, shallow walnut bowl or plate to throw loose change (coins) in. Over time, the finish will be abused by the metal. My question is: is it better to go with a penetrating (oil) finish which won't chip but will scratch fairly easily, or a harder surface finish which may be less prone to scratching but more prone to eventual chipping? I'm sure there are arguments both ways. What are your opinions? This will be for a gift, so it won't be able to be touched up -- I'm looking for the best look for the longest period of time. TIA, Gary

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

#2

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA.

>Gary, I reckon you could finish the outside with a few coats of wipe-on Poly, and use Walnut oil, Tung oil, or BLO for the inside surface. Or just oil it all over.

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

#3

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

john lucas

>Gil I would probably go with an oil although the kitchen table top that I coated with water based poly sure is holding up well and you know those take a a lot of abuse. I would think the damage due to the hardness of the coin would be worse than the actual metal contact. Tossing the coins in would dent then finish.

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

#4

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

RevDoug

>It only comes in gallon jugs, but minwax has a new floor finish that is some kind of tough. Other than that, I would think that shelac would be about the toughest regular finish that I can think of.

Turn 'em round,

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

#5

Behlen Rock Hard Table top finish

Ron Bauman

>

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

#6

JL

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

JL

>How about BLO/Poly/Thinner (third/third/third)? It's reasonably tough and some what flexible.

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

#7

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>In my opinion, you have two choices: 1) An easy finish that will not protect the wood (Oil), or 2) Something that will protect the wood, but ultimately would have to be refinished because of chipping and/or scratching.

1) An Oil finish is about as easy as it gets, but will not protect the wood from scratching or denting. To restore the finish you would have to sand away the damage, and then re-apply the oil. Fairly easy.

2) Protecting the surface and the expense of the finish: You have numerous options. Strongest would probably be an Epoxy finish. I have never used one, so cannot comment on the ease of finishing or refinishing. Poly - easy to apply, but does some impact resistance if liberally applied. However, refinishing would require sanding away all the damage, and most of the finish or you can get witness lines. Same applies to most of the waterbased and catalized lacquers.

Now, as most of my friends were expecting, I would recommend Behlen's Stringed Instrument Lacquer. It is hard enough to withstand the abuse fairly well, and flexible enough for the wood to move, and also flexible enough to withstand some of the impact damage. It is formulated for things like guitars and violins, that take lots of physical abuse, but are thin wood that has to move. When repair is required, sand just enough to remove the worst of the dents/chips, and reapply. No worry about wittness lines. It is best appled with a sprayer, but could be thinned and brushed.

Mark

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

#8

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

Ruth Niles

>I made a bowl for similar use for my Dad and just sanded super fine and buffed with only the wax wheel but did not apply any extra wax to the wheel. The bowl stayed beautiful. Actually you don't throw the coins, rather drop them in and when removing them, it's more natural to gently slide them out of the bowl or pick them up a few at a time. There shouldn't be any water or moisture factor involved and, if my Mom is any indicator, the bowl/dish will be wiped with a soft cloth and a little spray wax quite often.

Ruth

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

#9

Ric Taylor

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

Ric Taylor

>Gary,

I made one five years ago that I use every day for coins and keys. I used a wipe-on poly with a matte finish, and there are no marks on the surface at all. It looks as good as it did the day I finished it.

Ric

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

#10

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

Bob Fawcett

>I have a little one I turned that I through coins in. It has a shellac based friction polish on it. Holding up well so far.

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

#11

thanks everyone for your ideas and experience

GaryG in MD

>These are all good thoughts and ideas. They define the problem well and provide a number of good potential solutions. Now I'll have to figure out what I'm comfortable with. Thanks all. ...Gary

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

#12

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

Ned Bulken

>Personally If I received such a bowl, I'd enjoy the patina from use. Put an oil finish on it, let the wood speak for itself and gather wear marks proudly.

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

#13

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

Ron in Drums PA

>Allot of good info.

I'll add my 2� worth.

When I started turning I made some ugly bowls I never will show anybody.

I used BLO as a finish.

I use them as change bowls and they have held up nicely.

Re: best finish for a loose change bowl?

#14

thanks Ned and Ron

GaryG in MD

>Both good ideas. I prefer oil finishes at this point. I'm getting the kind of sheen I want (shiny, but not too shiny) with 4-5 coats of Watco Danish, followed by polishing with Abralon up to 4k, and then a coat of carnauba wax rubbed out. After considering all the comments in terms of my experience and equipment, I think I'll probably give the oil/wax a try and see what happens. I'll be able to monitor the results periodically, and I can always go with a harder finish over the top if the oil doesn't hold up. Thanks again to all who responded. ...Gary