We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Bowl turning is a blast!.... but since my technique is still lean, my bowls require much sanding...too much sanding! The hi-tech system which I am using involves tearing sand paper sheets into quarters, folding them a few more times, then pushing the sandpaper into the bowl as it spins on the lathe��I was thinking that there must be a better way, so looked at a few catalogs�Rockler, WoodCraft, ParkardWoodWorking, CraftSupply, CuttingEdgeTools, etc, etc, and there so many choices, my head spins! I have a 3/8 corded drill, a Foredom flex shaft tool (not sure if its largest collet is 1/8� or 1/4"). In the future I would like to turn hollow vases, bowls of all useful sizes, etc., and want to buy a sanding system which will make these surfaces nice and smooth. I guess there is the power tool and/or holder as well as the abrasive � which needs to be frequently replaced; Performance is primary. I would like to purchase the correct tool(s) the first time�.which ones do you suggest?
1. Power Lock Abrasive Flex Edges Discs
2. Sorby Velcro Bowl Sanding System
3. New Wave Velcro Sanding Discs
4. Sioux Sanding Drill (which speed Slow or High?)
5. Apprentice Dual Action Air Sander
6. Extend-A-Sand
7. Reach Sanding Ball
8. Inertia Sander
9. Artisan Disc Holders
OR
10. ????????????
11. ?????????
Thank you so much! Please either email , PM, or post.
>Phil I use a 2" padded disc with velcro and a Dewalt electric drill. I also do a fair amount of hand sandwork. I find that usually when people have trouble sanding they didn't start with a course enough paper, whether power sanding or hand sanding. I even succumb to that. I'll start with 120 and sand and sand and realize I should have started with 80 grit. Once you get all the tear out and tool marks out the sanding goes really fast. When it doesn't seem to go fast you probably didn't sand well enough with the last grit.
>I agree with John. I use 2" and 3" disks. Our turning club buys them from Industrial Abrasives wholesale and splits them up. They are the Velcro type. This is not a specific recommendation, I'm sure there are other brands that are as good or maybe better, but these have worked well. I use a Dewalt corded drill, because I hate the drill and am waiting for it to die so I can get another one I hope to like better. Been eying one of the Sou ix or Milwaukee angle drills, but I have read so much about the bearings failing that I now suspect they are not as good a tool as I would have expected from these companies. (Many posts here one WC about bearings and how tricky it is to reinstall and reassemble the tools)
John is Right about the sanding. There is much bragging about "I can cut that bowl so clean I can start with 320 sandpaper.", but for most of us, that's not part of the real world. Probably most of us should start with sandpaper that is at least one grit coarser than we think and at least spot sand out the tear out. I personally have trouble with two spots on opposite side of the inside of the bowl where the grain direction transitions. I admit it. Better on some woods, worse on others, and again, much talk here about how to avoid or reduce it. I try all those things, negative scraping, water, oil, finish, glue, honing, etc, and then I sand. I lock the shaft on my lathe and sand out the two spots, sometimes with 120, and sometimes with 100 or even 80. Then I step up to the next grit and sand the whole bowl. At that point look very closely. You should have eliminated all of the tear out and other minor defects. The coarsest grit removes wood and may cut away the surface, removing tear out and tool marks. All the sanding after that smooths the surface and removes the scratches left by each succeeding grit.
I power sand, and I may let the lathe free wheel and make the bowl spin with the sander, or I may run the lathe and sand at the same time. I reverse the lathe and the sander from time to time. If you are using a chuck or face plate, take care not to unscrew it while running the lathe backward.
What I would like to have: an excellent drill and a separate disk for each grit. Each mandrel or disk would have a hex shaft with a snap connector and I would line them up in order and change the pad to change the sandpaper. How trifling is that? Too lazy to even change Velcro sand paper. Actually, there is some logic in it. If you lay the Velcro paper around, it tends to collect shavings on the back side and is a PITA to clean off to reinstall. This would allow the disks to cool between uses, also. (Really, you should use a light touch and not generate that much heat.)
You have asked and "How high is up" question. There are as many answers as there are turners. Find what works for you. I also chuck the pads into my drill press and apply the bowl to them. I use my (5"0 RAS on the outsides if it suits me. I hand sand both on and off the lathe. Lately I have started experimenting with cabinet scrapers before sanding.
>It is a big question. I do a lot of bowls, and like the Sioux/Milwaukee angle drills (I have heard that Sioux makes the ones for Milwaukee, so they are identical). They save a lot of time and work. You can stop the lathe, and work on problem spots. I used to like the high speed ones, but after using a slow speed one, I like it better. Higher speeds create more heat, which causes the sandpaper to wear out faster, and can cause the velcro to come unglued. It doesn't make the sanding go any faster. I have 4 drills, one of which is pneumatic (Sioux). I don't use it much, I guess because I find the speed harder to control. On the others, I have a 1, 2, and 3 inch pad. Mostly I use the 3 inch pad, and the 1 and 2 inch pads are used to sand the mortice on the bottom of the bowl. I like the angled drills better that the in line or 90 degree drills. They allow better access to the bottom of the bowls, especially if it is a deeper and bigger bowl.
As far as the bearings wearing out, most people can get a year or three before this happens. I get less than a year. It is a drill, and made for drill bits. We use it more as a grinder. Three inch pads put a lot of pressure on the drill, which will cause eventual failure, even if you remember not to put a lot of pressure on it as you sand.
If you get one, get a good mandril ($15 to $20) and the softer pads to go on the mandril ($4 to $6). Replacing the pads when the hooks wear out is cheaper than replacing a mandril.
I usually sand at slow speeds. My bowls are green turned, allowed to warp and dry, and then sanded. It would be impossible to sand at higher speeds. I have grits from 80 to 400. When I was just learning, I would power sand to 150, then hand sand at 150. This would leave a different scratch pattern, and make it easier to see scratches that you didn't get out the first time. General rule, is get out ALL of the marks before going to the next grit. If you think 'it is almost gone, and I can finish it with the next grit' you will keep saying it all the way to the end, and then have to go back and start over. Sand till you think you have it all out, and then sand a little bit more. I still like to finish with a hand sand. The linear marks of 400 grit look better than the circular marks. Beyond 600 grit you really can't see the scratch marks, or at least you can't see the 600 grit marks. I spend as much or more time sanding each bowl as I do turning it.
There is one drill that is available (I think it is J M Tools in Riverside, CA) that sells for $29.95 plus shipping. It looks like a clone of the other drills. I got one and used and abused it severely to see what it would take. I wore it out in less than 2 months. I thought that the bearings had failed, but a friend took it to check it out. He said that the housing around the shaft failed because it was plastic. I know of a few others who got them, and had switch problems. If it was still under warrentee, then they would replace them. I think that they are worth $30, and at the rate that I would go through them, It might be about the same value as the Sioux/Milwaukee drills.
I also heard of another person who had factory rebuilt Milwaukee drills for about $60 and sold them on e-bay, but never checked it out.
One modification that I will do some time is to put a baffel on the vents where the air comes out of the drill. This will blow the air and dust towards the sanding head rather than out at 90 degrees to the body of the drill. This tends to blow the dust everywhere, which makes dust collection a pain. With hand sanding, you can put a hose behind the bowl, and get almost all of the dust. With power sanding, this is harder. I built a hood out of 1/2 of a white plastic food grade 55 gallon barrel. I cut the bottom out so that it would fit around the spindle on the headstock, and it bolts on through a wood fitting that is bolted on where the safety shield bolts on. The tailstock end is open, but I cover it with clear plastic. The top comes over the front a bit. Put me in frong of it, and this leaves less than 2 square feet open in front and I can sand all day with no dust mask. There is no dust on my glasses, or in my nose. Sorry, but I don't have a picture of it. Building a cover box of some sort isn't too difficult.
Do blow the dust out at least once during any heavy use, or every day that you use it.
>You have gotten excellent responses so far. One more thing, though: I have found that no matter how carefully I power sand, there are always some circular scratches that never seem to disappear. What I have found to be helpful is to start with power sanding and then hand sand --with the grain and the lathe stopped -- before going on to the next finer power sanding step. In other words, hand sand with the grain and lathe off between each power sanding step. It's slow, but I think it's the best way to get a superior surface. Also, don't underestimate the usefulness of making (for next to nothing) one of those passive sanding holders. It's basically just a stick with a hole in it. These leave less scratches most of the time.